Search arXiv⌕ Search

arXiv · 0709.3584

100 Years of dimensional analysis: New steps toward empirical law deduction

Abstract

On the verge of the centenary of dimensional analysis (DA), we present a generalisation of the theory and a methodology for the discovery of empirical laws from observational data. It is well known that DA: a) reduces the number of free parameters, b) guarantees scale invariance through dimensional homogeneity and c) extracts functional information encoded in the dimensionless grouping of variables. Less known are the results of Rudolph and co-workers that DA also gives rise to a new pair of transforms - the similarity transform (S) that converts physical dimensional data into dimensionless space and its inverse (S'). Here, we present a new matrix generalisation of the Buckingham Theorem, made possible by recent developments in the theory of inverse non-square matrices, and show how the transform pair arises naturally. We demonstrate that the inverse transform S' is non-unique and how this casts doubt on scaling relations obtained in cases where observational data has not been referred to in order to break the degeneracy inherent in transforming back to dimensional (physical) space. As an example, we show how the underlying functional form of the Planck Radiation Law can be deduced in only a few lines using the matrix method and without appealing to first principles; thus demonstrating the possibility of a priori knowledge discovery; but that subsequent data analysis is still required in order to identify the exact causal law. It is hoped that the proof presented here will give theoreticians confidence to pursue inverse problems in physics using DA.

Explore related subjects

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

Michael Taylor, Angeles I. Diaz, Lucas A. Jodar-Sanchez, Rafael J. Villanueva-Mico. 2007-11-21. 100 Years of dimensional analysis: New steps toward empirical law deduction. https://arxiv.org/abs/0709.3584

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related papers

Automated Sailboat Navigation using Controllabilty-Aware Nonlinear Model Predicitive Control under Stochastic Winds

This paper presents a systematic approach to plan and execute a time-efficient sailboat trajectory under the challenging stochastic wind conditions for automated sailboat. Unlike deterministic scenarios, stochastic wind disturbances introduce challenges such as gust unpredictability, directional shifts, and fluctuating apparent wind speeds. These characteristics render traditional planning methods, such as Line-of-Sight (LoS) and waypoint approaches, to be ineffective and not applicable, as they often rely on static or deterministic environmental models. This paper proposed a new path planner and controller based on nonlinear model predictive control method. It is compared with a baseline planner and controller. A Lie-algebraic analysis of the sailboat dynamics is carried out to identify the operating conditions under which the vessel loses first-order control authority in surge, and these conditions are embedded as constraints in the NMPC. Finally, simulation results are provided to validate the proposed framework.

physics.class-ph↗

Recovering long-range cumulative response to geometric frustration in quasi-1d systems, mediated by constitutive softness

Cumulative geometric frustration can drive self-limited assembly and morphology selection through size-dependent energetic costs. However, the slenderness of quasi-one-dimensional systems generally suppresses the formation of long-range longitudinal gradients. We show that the suppression of longitudinal gradients can be overcome by tuning the ratio between the longitudinal and transverse (shear) moduli. We demonstrate the recovery of cumulative frustration across distinct quasi-one-dimensional systems, each frustrated through a different mechanism, by the introduction of a soft response mode. The resulting saturation length scale is universal and is dictated by the local constitutive information of the system.

physics.class-ph↗

Generalized reverberation theory in diffuse sound fields: Introducing mean residual free path for macroscopic and microscopic unification

Sabine's foundational theory established the cornerstone of modern architectural acoustics. However, it fails to predict zero reverberation time in perfectly absorptive rooms. Eyring subsequently addressed this issue by proposing a new formula, which Knudsen later extended to incorporate air absorption. Nevertheless, Eyring's underlying approach contains fundamental theoretical contradictions. To resolve these flaws, the author previously introduced macroscopic and microscopic models for a revised reverberation theory; however, their mathematical unification, rigorous derivation from differential equations, and the mechanism behind Eyring's underestimation remained unclarified. This paper presents a comprehensive generalization and mathematical foundation of the revised theory. The macroscopic model is derived directly from fundamental energy differential equations, incorporating air absorption and a generalized mean residual free path. By reformulating the microscopic model as a sequential convolution process, its fundamental consistency with the macroscopic model is mathematically demonstrated. Crucially, it is shown that Eyring's underestimation can be interpreted as stemming universally from the structural omission of temporal variance expansion (σ_{n}^{2}=nσ^{2}) inherent to multiple reflections, regardless of the assumed probability distribution. Finally, ray-tracing simulations validate the scale-invariant accuracy of the proposed theory. Ultimately, this mathematically consistent framework establishes the theoretical limit for future generalized theories in non-diffuse sound fields.

physics.class-ph↗