Search arXivSearch

arXiv · 1104.2146

Reply to "Comment on 'Isotope effect in multi-band and multi-channel attractive systems and inverse isotope effect in iron-based superconductors'"

Abstract

The Comment insists on the following: in our model it is assumed that the effective interactions have specific energy ranges within the single band with a cutoff at ω_1 for the phononic part and a range from ω_1 to ω_2 in the AF channel. Our reply is that we assume that V_i(k,k')\neq 0 if |ξ_k|<ω_i and |ξ_{k'}|<ω_i, and otherwise V_i(k,k')= 0 (i=1,2), as stated in our paper. This is the model of BCS type with two attractive interactions, and this assumption is the characteristic of the BCS approximation. The claim "the integration limits have been modified such that the AF channel mediated pairing sets in where the ph-channel pairing terminates and is limited at an energy given by ω_j=ω_{AF}" in the Comment is wrong. We describe the model and the method to solve the gap equation in more detail.

Explore related subjects

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

Takashi Yanagisawa, Kosuke Odagiri, Izumi Hase, Kunihiko Yamaji, Parasharam M. Shirage, Yasumoto Tanaka, Akira Iyo, Hiroshi Eisaki. 2011-04-12. Reply to "Comment on 'Isotope effect in multi-band and multi-channel attractive systems and inverse isotope effect in iron-based superconductors'". https://doi.org/10.1143/jpsj.79.126002

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related papers

Theoretical Prediction of Optimal $T_c$ and Fermi Pockets in Nickelate Superconductors

High-pressure bilayer $La_{3-x}Sm_{x}Ni_{2}O_{7-δ}$ (LSNO) reaches a record $T_c=96 K$, triggering wide discussion on the $T_c$ ceiling of nickelate superconductors. We show monoclinic and tetragonal LSNO share the same octahedral quantum-well motif governing $T_c$ with $YBa_{2}Cu_{3}O_{7-δ}$ (YBCO). Using the Planckian quantum-well scaling $T_c = Λ/ξ^{2}$ ($ξ$: lattice-modulated quantum-well depth), we obtain $T_c=93.4 K$ and $97.1 K$ for monoclinic and tetragonal LSNO, matching experimental values $92 K$ and $96 K$. Despite distinct stoichiometry and global symmetry ($P2_1/m$ for LSNO, $Pmmm$ for orthorhombic YBCO), both systems have nearly identical $ξ$ ($3.6629$ angstrom vs. $3.6720$ angstrom) and consistent $T_c$ responses. Further calculations yield a universal $T_c$ limit $\sim100 K$ for rare-earth nickelates, irrespective of stacking sequences. We examine four nickelate multilayer stacking variants: 2222 (pure bilayer), 1212 (alternating single-bilayer), 2323 (bilayer-trilayer), and 1313 (single-trilayer). Mirror symmetry breaking of coupled twin quantum wells, unique to bilayer nickelates, dictates $γ$ Fermi pocket formation and ambient-pressure superconductivity. We further prove Fermi surfaces constitute a hologram of quantum-well electrons, establishing intrinsic links between quantum-well symmetry breaking, Fermi pocket structural evolution, and superconducting properties.

cond-mat.supr-con

Enhanced superconductivity in palladium hydrides by non-perturbative electron-phonon effects

Palladium hydrides exhibit the largest isotope-effect anomaly in superconductivity: replacing hydrogen with heavier isotopes increases the superconducting critical temperature. Although this behavior is commonly attributed to strong anharmonic hydrogen vibrations, \textit{ab initio} treatments have so far incorporated anharmonic effects only through phonon renormalization, neglecting non-linear contributions to the electron-phonon interaction vertices. While such approaches reproduce the anomalous isotope trend, they severely underestimate the critical temperatures. Here, we show that non-linear electron-phonon coupling is essential in palladium hydrides. A straightforward inclusion of higher-order perturbative terms leads to a qualitative breakdown: the critical temperature is overestimated and the isotope anomaly is lost. We therefore adopt a non-perturbative framework based on an explicit evaluation of the ion-mediated electron-electron interaction, enabling anharmonic effects to be treated consistently in both the phonon spectra and the interaction vertices. Applied to PdH and PdD, it restores the anomalous isotope effect and brings calculated critical temperatures into significantly improved agreement with experiments.

cond-mat.supr-con

Optical manifestations of loop currents in Haldane's model and in time-reversal-breaking superconductors

We present a theoretical study of optical manifestations of loop currents in Haldane's model and in time-reversal-breaking superconductors. For Haldane's model, we calculate the expectation value of loop currents in terms of model parameters and relate it with the integrated optical spectral weight for the frequency-dependent ac Hall conductivity. Thus, experimental measurements of the latter can provide information about the presence and magnitude of steady loop currents in the system. Then we elaborate on loop currents in a chiral superconductor on the honeycomb lattice, studied earlier by Brydon et al. (2019). We demonstrate that a sharp optical absorption peak in the ac Hall conductivity originates from excitations between the lower and upper Dirac bands, activated by the time-reversal-breaking superconductivity. The frequency of the peak is twice the energy difference between the Fermi level and the Dirac point. The optical spectral weight of the peak is directly related to the magnitude of loop currents induced in the unit cells by the chiral superconducting pairing, in similarity to Haldane's model.

cond-mat.supr-con