Search arXivSearch

arXiv · 1311.4665

Analysis of Farthest Point Sampling for Approximating Geodesics in a Graph

Abstract

A standard way to approximate the distance between any two vertices $p$ and $q$ on a mesh is to compute, in the associated graph, a shortest path from $p$ to $q$ that goes through one of $k$ sources, which are well-chosen vertices. Precomputing the distance between each of the $k$ sources to all vertices of the graph yields an efficient computation of approximate distances between any two vertices. One standard method for choosing $k$ sources, which has been used extensively and successfully for isometry-invariant surface processing, is the so-called Farthest Point Sampling (FPS), which starts with a random vertex as the first source, and iteratively selects the farthest vertex from the already selected sources. In this paper, we analyze the stretch factor $\mathcal{F}_{FPS}$ of approximate geodesics computed using FPS, which is the maximum, over all pairs of distinct vertices, of their approximated distance over their geodesic distance in the graph. We show that $\mathcal{F}_{FPS}$ can be bounded in terms of the minimal value $\mathcal{F}^*$ of the stretch factor obtained using an optimal placement of $k$ sources as $\mathcal{F}_{FPS}\leq 2 r_e^2 \mathcal{F}^*+ 2 r_e^2 + 8 r_e + 1$, where $r_e$ is the ratio of the lengths of the longest and the shortest edges of the graph. This provides some evidence explaining why farthest point sampling has been used successfully for isometry-invariant shape processing. Furthermore, we show that it is NP-complete to find $k$ sources that minimize the stretch factor.

Explore related subjects

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

Pegah Kamousi, Sylvain Lazard, Anil Maheshwari, Stefanie Wuhrer. 2013-11-19. Analysis of Farthest Point Sampling for Approximating Geodesics in a Graph. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.comgeo.2016.05.005

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related papers

Unlabeled Multi-Robot Motion Planning with Improved Separation Trade-offs

We study unlabeled MRMP for unit-disk robots in a polygonal environment. Although the problem is hard in general, polynomial-time solutions exist under appropriate separation assumptions on start and target positions. Banyassady et al.(SoCG'22) guarantee feasibility in simple polygons under start--start and target--target distances of at least $4$, and start--target distances of at least $3$, but without optimality guarantees. Solovey et al.(RSS'15) provide a near-optimal solution in general polygonal domains, under stricter conditions: start/target positions must have pairwise distance at least $4$, and at least $\sqrt{5}\approx2.236$ from obstacles. This raises the question of whether polynomial-time algorithms can be obtained in even more densely packed environments. In this paper we present a generalized algorithm that achieve different tradeoffs on the robots-separation $ρ$ and obstacles-separation $ω$, all significantly improving upon the state of the art. Specifically, we obtain polynomial-time constant-approximation algorithms to minimize the total path length when (i) $ρ=2\frac{2}{3}$ and $ω=1\frac{2}{3}$, or (ii) $ρ\approx3.291$ and $ω\approx1.354$. These solutions are weakly-monotone; we also provide a monotone solution requiring $ω=\approx1.614$ and $ρ=4$. We prove that monotone plans may not exist when $ω<1.614$, and weakly-monotone plans may not exist when $ω<1.354$. We then present tradeoffs between the separation bounds and the approximation factor, specifically achieving an (almost) optimal bound of $ρ=2$ at the cost of a linear approximation factor and requiring $ω=2$. This applies also for the labeled variant of MRMP, in which case we show a tight bound on $ω$. Finally, we show that without any robots-separation assumption, obstacles-separation of at least $1.5$ may be necessary for a solution to exist.

cs.CG

Low-Dimensional Embeddings for Gaussian Kernels on Manifolds

The Gaussian kernel is a widely used similarity measure underlying kernel methods such as kernel PCA and spectral clustering, but computing Gaussian kernel distances for many pairs of points can be expensive. Using Random Fourier Features (RFF), Chen and Phillips [ALT 2017] showed that for points in a $d$-dimensional Euclidean ball in ${\mathbb R}^N$, $t=Ω((d/\varepsilon^2)\log(dR/\varepsilon))$ features suffice to preserve all pairwise Gaussian kernel distances within a $(1\pm\varepsilon)$ factor with high probability. We establish a uniform relative-error embedding theorem for the more general setting of an arbitrary positive-reach submanifold $\mathcal M\subset{\mathbb R}^N$ of intrinsic dimension $d$. We show that $t=O((d/\varepsilon^2)\log(\operatorname{vol}(\mathcal M)^2N^{2d}/(\operatorname{vol}(B_1^d(0))^2\operatorname{rch}(\mathcal M)^{2d}\varepsilon^{2d+1}δ)))$, or approximately $O((d^2/\varepsilon^2)(\log N+\log(1/(\varepsilonδ))))$, RFFs suffice, with probability $1-δ$, to preserve the Gaussian kernel distance between every pair of manifold points up to relative error $\varepsilon$. Thus the bound depends only logarithmically on the ambient dimension and on manifold parameters such as volume and reach, while retaining the $1/\varepsilon^2$ Euclidean rate. We also prove a topological consequence: under the same RFF embedding, persistent homology is preserved in the sense that weighted Cech and Rips filtrations built from Gaussian kernel power distance are $(1\pm\varepsilon_\star)$-interleaved, where $\varepsilon_\star$ accounts for both distance distortion and kernel-weight approximation.

cs.CG

Perfectly Guarding Straits: Exact Algorithms for Weak Visibility Polygons

The Art Gallery Problem (AGP) asks for the fewest guards that see all of a simple polygon. It is $\exists\mathbb{R}$-complete, hence NP-hard. We show that for a particular class of polygons, confining guards to a single edge makes AGP exactly and efficiently solvable. We call this the Strait Guarding Problem (SGP). Its input is a weak visibility polygon (WVP): a simple polygon where every point is seen from some point of one fixed edge, the base. SGP places the fewest guards on the base that jointly see the whole polygon. First, a structural fact: guards on the base edge that cover the boundary already cover the entire interior, turning a two-dimensional covering problem into a one-dimensional one. Our main result is the Witness-Guard Algorithm, which solves SGP exactly in $O((n + \mathrm{OPT} \cdot ρ)(\log n + \log \mathrm{OPT}))$ time, where $ρ$ is the number of reflex vertices in the WVP and OPT is the minimum number of guards. It is output-sensitive and certifies optimality by a witness set of size OPT derived from its output. We also study the guarding-the-vertex version and prove a tight $Θ(n \log n)$ bound, with the lower bound following from Sorting. As a corollary of SGP, we obtain two results for altitude terrain guarding (ATG), a special case that SGP generalizes. We give a linear-time perfect-guarding algorithm, improving the previous $O(n^2 \log n)$ bound of Daescu, Friedrichs, Malik, Polishchuk and Schmidt. We also resolve their problem on the minimum guarding altitude, in $O(nk + k^2 \log k)$ time, improving on the $O(k^2 λ_{k-1}(n) \log n)$ bound of Kang, Kim and Ahn.

cs.CG