Search arXiv⌕ Search
Home/Archive/arXiv

arXiv · 1407.6865

A critique of recent semi-classical spin-half quantum plasma theories

Govind S. Krishnaswami·Rajaram Nityananda·Abhijit Sen·Anantanarayanan Thyagaraja
View original source ↗Read source document ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

Certain recent semi-classical theories of spin-half quantum plasmas are examined with regard to their internal consistency, physical applicability and relevance to fusion, astrophysical and condensed matter plasmas. It is shown that the derivations and some of the results obtained in these theories are internally inconsistent and contradict well-established principles of quantum and statistical mechanics, especially in their treatment of fermions and spin. Claims of large semi-classical effects of spin magnetic moments that could dominate the plasma dynamics are found to be invalid both for single-particles and collectively. Larmor moments dominate at high temperature while spin moments cancel due to Pauli blocking at low temperatures. Explicit numerical estimates from a variety of plasmas are provided to demonstrate that spin effects are indeed much smaller than many neglected classical effects. The analysis presented suggests that the aforementioned `Spin Quantum Hydrodynamic' theories are not relevant to conventional laboratory or astrophysical plasmas.

Explore related subjects

physics.plasm-phcond-mat.otherphysics.flu-dyn

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

Govind S. Krishnaswami, Rajaram Nityananda, Abhijit Sen, Anantanarayanan Thyagaraja. 2014-09-01. A critique of recent semi-classical spin-half quantum plasma theories. https://doi.org/10.1002/ctpp.201400043

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related papers

arXiv2026

Experimental validation of a fast control-oriented, physics-informed surrogate model for plasma equilibrium reconstruction in the TCV tokamak

Magnetic equilibrium reconstruction provides the plasma state estimate required for real-time shape control in tokamaks. We present a fast, physics-informed neural network surrogate of the \texttt{liuqe} equilibrium reconstruction code \cite{liuqe1} for the TCV tokamak at EPFL, achieving inference times below 100~$\bmμ$s and enabling 10~kHz shape control. The model is trained on around 10,000 TCV discharges spanning the full operational range of plasma shapes. Its modular branch/trunk architecture decouples magnetic measurement encoding from spatial coordinate processing, enabling physics-informed regularization via automatic differentiation of the predicted flux map. The surrogate has been compiled and deployed on the TCV real-time control system, and validated both offline and in real time against the models \texttt{liuqe-rt} and \texttt{lih}, showing comparable accuracy. Closed-loop performance assessed with the real-time software in-the-loop \texttt{fge} \cite{fge1} demonstrates control-equivalent behavior across multiple control strategies.

physics.plasm-ph↗
arXiv2026

Development of Thomson parabola spectrometer for diagnostics of ions driven by ultrahigh intensity laser: Simulations and numerical analysis

A Thomson parabola ion spectrometer (TPIS) has been designed and developed for diagnostics of laseraccelerated ion beams in the MeV energy range. The TPIS has been validated by ion acceleration experiment at petawatt laser facility. Necessary simulations to evaluate the electric and magnetic field distributions have been performed with the help of a numerical simulation software to aid the selection of the spectrometer geometry while minimising fringe-field effects. Analytical dispersion expressions have been formulated from the simulations that take into account the spatial variation in the electromagnetic field profiles. The ion deflections obtained from these expressions demonstrate an improved agreement with experimentally measured proton trajectories compared to the case when constant fields are considered. The TPIS hence fabricated in-house has been subject to magnetic field measurements, which are in excellent agreement with the simulated field profile. The TPIS has the provision to change the field-free drift region, showcasing flexibility to be employed over a broad energy range and with different experimental setups. The spectrometer has been subsequently used for detecting laser-accelerated ion beams from thin aluminum foil targets. These experiments have demonstrated the capability of the spectrometer to resolve multiple ion species with sufficient separation between them. The developed TPIS provides a compact, flexible and accurate diagnostic for high-energy laser-plasma experiments.

physics.plasm-ph↗
arXiv2026

Calibration of cross-field transport models in SOLPS-ITER on the TCV-X21 case

Cross-field turbulent transport remains one of the largest uncertainties in edge plasma simulations and is commonly approximated through empirical transport coefficients. In this work, we calibrate and assess several cross-field transport models implemented in SOLPS-ITER using measurements from the TCV-X21 reference case. The considered models range from conventional constant-diffusivity descriptions to the self-consistent k-model, in which anomalous diffusivities evolve along with plasma conditions. Model parameters are estimated through gradient-based optimization by minimizing discrepancies between simulated and experimental upstream and divertor profiles in forward field configuration. The calibration results show that increasing the number of free parameters substantially improves agreement with the calibration dataset. However, these more flexible models exhibit poor predictive capability when applied to the reversed field configuration, indicating overfitting. In contrast, the simplest constant-diffusivity model provides the best overall predictive performance while requiring only a small number of calibrated parameters. The k-model achieves a calibration quality comparable to the constant-diffusivity model and reproduces the experimental profiles with similar accuracy, while simultaneously providing a physics-based description of the spatial variation of anomalous transport. Predictions for a density scan reveal differences that are not apparent near the calibration point. The k-model predicts increasing transport levels around the separatrix with increasing density, leading to broader upstream profiles and an earlier onset of divertor rollover compared to the constant-diffusivity model. The presented framework provides a systematic and efficient route for model calibration in SOLPS-ITER, and a set of calibrated k-model parameters to be employed in future studies.

physics.plasm-ph↗