Search arXivSearch

arXiv · 1411.5775

Two-phase sampling experiment for propensity score estimation in self-selected samples

Abstract

Self-selected samples are frequently obtained due to different levels of survey participation propensity of the survey individuals. When the survey participation is related to the survey topic of interest, propensity score weighting adjustment using auxiliary information may lead to biased estimation. In this paper, we consider a parametric model for the response probability that includes the study variable itself in the covariates of the model and proposes a novel application of two-phase sampling to estimate the parameters of the propensity model. The proposed method includes an experiment in which data are collected again from a subset of the original self-selected sample. With this two-phase sampling experiment, we can estimate the parameters in a propensity score model consistently. Then the propensity score adjustment can be applied to the self-selected sample to estimate the population parameters. Sensitivity of the selection model assumption is investigated from two limited simulation studies. The proposed method is applied to the 2012 Iowa Caucus Survey.

Explore related subjects

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

Sixia Chen, Jae-Kwang Kim. 2014-11-21. Two-phase sampling experiment for propensity score estimation in self-selected samples. https://doi.org/10.1214/14-aoas746

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related papers

From Metrics to Decisions in NBA Analytics: A Critical Integrative Review and Decision-Readiness Framework

National Basketball Association (NBA) teams have increasingly detailed metrics, but better predictions do not necessarily improve decisions. This critical integrative review draws on prior reviews, citation tracing, and topic searches across seven research streams: on-court action, player value, role, lineup synergy, availability, draft and development, and contracts and roster construction. An observation-state-action-decision-evaluation chain organizes the synthesis. Six decision-readiness gates guide our assessment: point-in-time validity, uncertainty, context portability, action feasibility, opportunity-set observability, and evaluation, with requirements matched to each claim. The reviewed literature is strongest in measuring and predicting individual components of a decision. Evidence is less developed at interfaces that combine components, transfer them across settings, and compare feasible actions. We outline a proposed deployment workflow, a reporting contract, and a research agenda covering player transport, role substitution, roster fragility, legal action generation, and asset valuation. The 2023 collective bargaining agreement and forthcoming 3-2-1 Draft Lottery illustrate how institutional changes generate research questions. Models should inform evaluable comparisons of feasible choices. While its effect on organizational decision quality remains an empirical question, the framework provides a diagnostic and reporting structure for matching decision claims to evidence requirements.

stat.AP

Bayesian calibration of adaptive-behavior SIR models for multi-wave COVID-19 incidence in New York City

Epidemic incidence reflects both transmission dynamics and adaptive human behavior, yet these mechanisms may be difficult to distinguish from aggregate case data alone. We calibrated four susceptible--infected--recovered (SIR) specifications to weekly confirmed COVID-19 incidence in New York City from June to December 2020, comparing a single continuous SIR trajectory, a wave-initialized SIR model, and two adaptive-behavior models with either shared or wave-specific transmission. Inference was performed using rejection Approximate Bayesian Computation (ABC), and in-sample reconstruction was assessed using root mean squared error (RMSE) and the weighted interval score (WIS). Reinitializing the epidemic state by wave produced the largest structural improvement over the continuous SIR trajectory, reducing mean-based RMSE by 48.6\% and WIS by 17.6\%. Adding delayed prevalence-dependent behavioral adaptation with shared transmission further reduced mean-based RMSE by 23.4\%, but yielded essentially unchanged WIS relative to the wave-initialized SIR model. Allowing transmission to vary by wave did not provide a consistent additional advantage and produced strongly asymmetric posterior-simulation trajectories. Behavioral sensitivity, response midpoint, and delay remained only weakly to partially identified. The clearest posterior structure was a negative association between transmission intensity and the behavioral midpoint, indicating that higher transmission could be compensated by behavioral responses activated at lower prevalence. Sensitivity to ordered behavioral priors further showed that reconstruction and behavioral inference depend materially on structural prior assumptions. These results suggest that adaptive mechanisms can improve multi-wave incidence reconstruction, while aggregate incidence alone is insufficient to sharply separate transmission from behavioral adaptation.

stat.AP

Short-term rental market occupancy - daily time series for 2017-2022 on 500 markets worldwide

Short-term vacation rentals, as promoted by platforms such as Airbnb, Homeaway, Vrbo, etc., are a growing component of the travel industry. This paper provides a unique, large dataset on global market occupancy for the short-term rental market using data from the American company Wheelhouse. The dataset consists of data for $500$ markets around the world. For each market, a daily occupancy time series from January $2017$ to December $2022$ is provided, allowing for studies of local and global patterns in the evolution of the short-term rental market. Additionally, the dataset includes curves representing the booking trajectory of each market and stay date up to one year prior to the stay date. This large dataset comprises a unique combination of time series and survival analysis data, and is suitable as a methodological benchmark for both classical statistical and machine learning models.

stat.AP