Search arXivSearch

arXiv · 1506.07401

Testing reanalysis datasets in Antarctica: Trends, persistence properties and trend significance

Abstract

The reanalysis datasets provide very important sources for investigating the climate dynamics and climate changes in Antarctica. In this paper, three major reanalysis data are compared with Antarctic station data over the last 35 years: the National Centers for Environmental Prediction and the National Center for Atmospheric Research reanalysis (NCEP1), NCEP-DOE Reanalysis 2 (NCEP2), and the European Centre for Medium-Range Weather Forecasts Interim Re-Analysis (ERA-Interim). In our assessment, we compare the linear trends, the fluctuations around the trends, the persistence properties and the significance level of warming trends in the reanalysis data with the observational ones. We find that NCEP1 and NCEP2 show spurious warming trends in all parts of Antarctica except the Peninsula, while ERA-Interim is quite reliable except at Amundsen-Scott. To investigate the persistence of the data sets, we consider the lag-1 autocorrelation $C(1)$ and the Hurst exponent. While $C(1)$ varies quite erratically in different stations, the Hurst exponent shows similar patterns all over Antarctica. Regarding the significance of the trends, NCEP1 and NCEP2 differ considerably from the observational datasets by strongly exaggerating the warming trends. In contrast, ERA-Interim gives reliable results at most stations except at Amundsen-Scott where it shows a significant cooling trend.

Explore related subjects

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

Yang Wang, Dong Zhou, Armin Bunde, Shlomo Havlin. 2017-01-10. Testing reanalysis datasets in Antarctica: Trends, persistence properties and trend significance. https://doi.org/10.1002/2016jd024864

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related papers

Surface Stokes drift from compact drifting wave buoys

Surface Stokes drift depends strongly on the energy and directions of short waves, which are incompletely resolved by routine wave observations. We derive surface Stokes drift vectors from wave measurements collected by compact drifting buoys during three deployments in the North-East Atlantic and the Alboran Sea. The calculation uses vertical-acceleration spectra and first directional Fourier moments, which describe the mean wave direction and directional concentration at each frequency; it accounts for the Doppler shift caused by buoy motion relative to the water and adds a calibrated high-frequency tail above an intrinsic frequency of 0.7 Hz. Across 13,139 records, the median estimated speed is 0.081 m/s at a median wind speed of 6.8 m/s. Over the measured band of 0.04-1 Hz, accounting for wave directions reduces the magnitude by a median 39% relative to the unidirectional assumption. The median ratio of the parameterised tail magnitude above 0.7 Hz to the total estimated magnitude is 0.37. Comparisons with WAVEWATCH III and Copernicus Marine MFWAM show strong covariation and similar wind-dependent differences from the buoy-derived estimates. On the station-matched sample from the two Atlantic deployments, WAVEWATCH III directional spectra indicate that these differences within the compared band arise mainly from spectral levels rather than from net directional reduction. The observations provide constraints for model evaluation; the contribution of the unresolved short waves remains sensitive to the assumed spectral tail and its directional spreading.

physics.ao-ph

Unreported large errors from two PAMGuard three-dimensional localizers of whale calls

Confidence intervals of location (CIL) of calling marine mammals, derived from time-differences-of-arrival (TDOA) between receivers, depend on errors of TDOAs, receiver location, clocks, sound speeds, and location method. When these errors are minuscule, simulations yield small errors of PAMGuard's 3D simplex localizer when click sounds of beaked and sperm whales originate in a 1000 x 1000 x 1000 $\mbox{m}^3$ region using five receivers having horizontal and vertical separations of 1000 m and 150 m respectively. Realistic uncertainties of sound speed up to $\pm 10$ m/s lead to errors up to $10^{14}$ m. With clocks maintained by atomic standards and common practice of correcting TDOA from synchronization measurements at the start and end of an experiment, errors of location are up to $10^{4}$ m. Errors up to $10^2$ and $10^3$ m are found when the receiver's locations are uncertain within 10 and 40 m respectively. Errors of PAMGuard's 3D hyperbolic localizer are almost independent of the above uncertainties, yielding errors of location up to about $10^4$ m even when simulated errors are minuscule. Causes of PAMGuard's 3D location errors are unknown. These algorithms are briefly compared to another method designed to yield a reliable CIL.

physics.ao-ph

Tropospheric Ozone Formation Potential and Related Design Considerations for Radiative Coolers

Recently, radiative coolers have been widely explored for reducing cooling loads or lowering temperatures in buildings, and at urban scales as a heat-mitigation measure. However, the potential impacts of radiative cooler deployment on the chemical composition of the atmosphere remain largely unexplored. A defining feature of recently-designed radiative coolers is their high ultraviolet (UV) reflectance, which is required for sub-ambient cooling under strong sunlight. Yet, wide adoption of such UV-reflective radiative coolers could substantially increase the UV actinic flux in the atmosphere above. This, in turn, may affect tropospheric ozone concentrations, particularly in urban atmospheres with high NOx concentrations. Here, as a case study, we use a 0-dimensional photochemical box model, constrained by field measurements of meteorological conditions and chemical concentrations in the urban environment of Houston, Texas, to explore the potential impact of the widespread use of UV-reflective radiative coolers on ozone concentrations. Our calculations show that complete deployment of radiative coolers may increase tropospheric ozone levels by as much as 30% during specific meteorological conditions in Houston. Informed by the wavelength-dependent modelling results, we propose specific designs, namely pigmented radiative coolers with different UV reflectances, and UV-absorptive visible-reemitting fluorescent radiative coolers, that could minimize negative ozone formation while retaining appreciable cooling performance. Our results motivate further study on the effects of widespread deployment of radiative cooling designs like superwhite roof paints on air quality, and materials that simultaneously minimize adverse photochemical impact and maximize cooling performance.

physics.ao-ph