Anonymity in Predicting the Future

Dvij Bajpai; Daniel J. Velleman

Home/Archive/arXiv

arXiv · 1508.06865

Anonymity in Predicting the Future

Dvij Bajpai·Daniel J. Velleman

View original source ↗Read source document ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

Consider an arbitrary set $S$ and an arbitrary function $f : \mathbb{R} \to S$. We think of the domain of $f$ as representing time, and for each $x \in \mathbb{R}$, we think of $f(x)$ as the state of some system at time $x$. Imagine that, at each time $x$, there is an agent who can see $f \upharpoonright (-\infty, x)$ and is trying to guess $f(x)$--in other words, the agent is trying to guess the present state of the system from its past history. In a 2008 paper, Christopher Hardin and Alan Taylor use the axiom of choice to construct a strategy that the agents can use to guarantee that, for every function $f$, all but countably many of them will guess correctly. In a 2013 monograph they introduce the idea of anonymous guessing strategies, in which the agents can see the past but don't know where they are located in time. In this paper we consider a number of variations on anonymity. For instance, what if, in addition to not knowing where they are located in time, agents also do not know the rate at which time is progressing? What if they have no sense of how much time elapses between any two events? We show that in some cases agents can still guess successfully, while in others they perform very poorly.

Explore related subjects

math.LO

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeX RIS

Dvij Bajpai, Daniel J. Velleman. 2015-08-27. Anonymity in Predicting the Future. https://arxiv.org/abs/1508.06865

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related papers

arXiv2026

Forcing with Symmetric Systems of Models of Two Types

The purpose of this paper is to present a general method for forcing on $ω_2$ and $ω_3$ with finite conditions, while preserving all cardinals and some fragments of $\mathrm{GCH}$. This method is based on the technique of forcing with finite symmetric systems of elementary submodels, and improves earlier versions of this forcing by including models of two types. We will present several applications of the pure side condition forcing and variants thereof, by adding a Kurepa tree on $ω_2$, a club subset of $ω_2$ that avoids infinite sets from the ground model, a function bounding every canonical function below $ω_3$ on a club, and a simplified $(ω_2,1)$-morass.

math.LO↗

arXiv2026

On some NIP Fragments of Fields

In this document we study sets of NIP formulas in some theories of fields and valued fields, with a special focus on the sets of quantifier-free and existential formulas. First, we give a new proof of the fact that Separably Closed Valued Fields of any characteristic and any imperfection degree are NIP, and use this result to fill some gaps of a proof of the so-called NIP Transfer Theorem for henselian valued fields of equal characteristic. Second, we prove a variant of a theorem of Johnson: every positive characteristic valued field whose existential formulas are NIP is henselian, and generalize this result for finer sets of existential formulas, like positive existential with a given number of quantifiers, in type-definable fields. Finally, we set the ground for the finer question of transfer of NIP formulas of valued fields with bounded quantifier rank. Namely, we prove that for any henselian equicharacteristic valued field, any formula of quantifier rank at most $n\geq 1$ is NIP if and only if the same is true for the residue field and the value group, provided that the valued field is separably defectless Kaplansky and conditional on a multi-variable generalization of a well known statement about indiscernible sequences of singletons in ac-valued fields.

math.LO↗

arXiv2026

Combinatorics of Schur ultrafilters

In this paper, we provide a combinatorial characterization of the elements of Schur ultrafilters on countable commutative groups. Using this characterization, we construct a Schur ultrafilter on $\mathbb Z$ that is not infinitary Schur. Moreover, assuming the Continuum Hypothesis, we establish the existence of Schur P-points in $β(\mathbb Z)$. On the other hand, it is consistent with ZFC that there exist P-points in $β(\mathbb Z)$, but none of them are Schur. Also, we extend the result of Fernández-Bretón, Navarro-Castillo, and Soria-Rojas by showing that no Schur ultrafilter on $\mathbb Z$ is a Q-point.

math.LO↗