Search arXivSearch

arXiv · 1509.07570

Investigating transfer of learning in advanced quantum mechanics

Abstract

Research suggests that students often have difficulty transferring their learning from one context to another. We examine upper-level undergraduate and graduate students' facility with questions about the interference pattern in the double-slit experiment (DSE) with single photons and polarizers of various orientations placed in front of one or both slits. Before answering these types of questions, students had worked through a tutorial on the Mach-Zehnder Interferometer (MZI) in which they learned about interference of single photons when polarizers of various orientations are placed in the two paths of the MZI. After working on the MZI tutorial, students were asked similar questions in the isomorphic context of the DSE. We discuss the extent to which they were able to transfer what they learned in the context of the MZI to analogous problems in the isomorphic context of the DSE.

Explore related subjects

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

Alexandru Maries, Ryan Sayer, Chandralekha Singh. 2016-04-18. Investigating transfer of learning in advanced quantum mechanics. https://doi.org/10.1119/perc.2015.pr.047

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related papers

Trends, Impact, and Thematic Evolution of Physics Education: A Bibliometric and Topic Modelling Analysis of Six Decades of Publications

Physics Education has played a prominent role in advancing physics education research since its establishment in 1966. However, a comprehensive investigation of its publication trends, impact, and thematic evolution over six decades remains limited. This study examines the journal development through a bibliometric analysis of publications over six decades. Following a PRISMA-based screening process, 6,311 documents were retained from an initial dataset of 7,709 records. Publication trends, citation impact, leading countries and institutions, topic modeling, and topic evolution were analyzed to examine the journal's development and thematic structure. The results indicate sustained growth in publication output, significantly after the digital and information era. The UK and the US emerged as the most productive contributors and accumulated the highest total citations, whereas Germany and Norway achieved the highest citation impact in terms of citations per paper. This pattern was further reinforced by increasing contributions from countries in Asia and the Global South, reflecting the growing internationalization of the journal. Major research themes include force and motion experiments, energy and light experiments, laboratory-based learning, conceptual understanding, and physics teacher education. Topic prevalence analysis indicates that, while experimental and laboratory-based studies have remained a defining feature of Physics Education, increasing attention has been devoted to conceptual understanding, assessment, technology-supported instruction, and pedagogical innovation in recent decades. Overall, Physics Education has evolved from a journal primarily centered on laboratory experiments and instructional demonstrations into a multidisciplinary venue emphasizing conceptual understanding, educational technology, and contemporary innovations in physics teaching and learning.

physics.ed-ph

From Prompts to Physical Laws: A Generative AI Workflow for Engineering Physics Education

This work explores the use of generative artificial intelligence (AI) as a source of synthetic experimental content for introductory physics courses in engineering education. Using PixVerse.ai, Grok Imagine, and Pippit, three video scenarios were generated to represent distinct resistive force regimes: constant friction, linear drag, and quadratic drag. Kinematic data were extracted from the generated videos using Tracker, an open-source video analysis tool, and subsequently fitted to the corresponding analytical models through non-linear least-squares regression in Microsoft Excel. The results show good agreement between the synthetic data and the classical kinematic equations derived from Newton's Second Law. From the fitted parameters, physically meaningful quantities were recovered in each case, with values broadly consistent with those reported in the literature under the assumed conditions. A recurring observation is that the physical plausibility of the generated motion depends on the level of detail included in the text description used to generate the videos. More specific descriptions tend to produce more coherent dynamical behaviour, suggesting that the formulation of input prompts plays a relevant role in shaping the resulting physical consistency and can be regarded as an integral component of the experimental design process. The integration of generative AI, video-based motion tracking, and curve fitting provides a complete workflow that mirrors key stages of experimental practice, from model construction to quantitative validation. The proposed methodology engages students in experimental design, data acquisition, parameter estimation, and model evaluation, promoting key engineering competencies in modelling of physical models using widely available tools. Overall, the proposed methodology demonstrates the potential of generative AI to support physics education

physics.ed-ph

Calculating a journey to Mars with introductory physics

The problem of a crewed mission to Mars provides a compelling and realistic context for teaching introductory physics. In this work, we present a coherent set of calculations describing a round-trip journey between Earth and Mars, using only mathematical tools accessible at the high-school level. The treatment integrates key topics that are typically taught separately -such as Newtonian gravitation, energy, circular motion, and basic astrodynamics- into a single coherent framework. The analysis includes Hohmann transfer orbits, travel times, launch conditions, and mission constraints, illustrating how a complex real-world problem can be transformed into an effective classroom resource. This work aims to support teachers and students in exploring interplanetary travel as an accessible and motivating application of fundamental physics.

physics.ed-ph