Spectral sequences of Type Ia supernovae. I. Connecting normal and sub-luminous SN Ia and the presence of unburned carbon

Abstract

Type Ia supernovae are generally agreed to arise from thermonuclear explosions of carbon-oxygen white dwarfs. The actual path to explosion, however, remains elusive, with numerous plausible parent systems and explosion mechanisms suggested. Observationally, type Ia supernovae have multiple subclasses, distinguished by their lightcurves and spectra. This raises the question whether these reflect that multiple mechanisms occur in nature, or instead that explosions have a large but continuous range of physical properties. We revisit the idea that normal and 91bg-like supernovae can be understood as part of a spectral sequence, in which changes in temperature dominate. Specifically, we find that a single ejecta structure is sufficient to provide reasonable fits of both the normal type Ia supernova SN~2011fe and the 91bg-like SN~2005bl, provided that the luminosity and thus temperature of the ejecta are adjusted appropriately. This suggests that the outer layers of the ejecta are similar, thus providing some support of a common explosion mechanism. Our spectral sequence also helps to shed light on the conditions under which carbon can be detected in pre-maximum SN~Ia spectra -- we find that emission from iron can "fill in" the carbon trough in cool SN~Ia. This may indicate that the outer layers of the ejecta of events in which carbon is detected are relatively metal poor compared to events where carbon is not detected.