Search arXivSearch

arXiv · 1808.05569

Estimating the Anisotropy of Protein Structures from SAXS

Abstract

In the field of small angle x-ray scattering (SAXS), the task of estimating the size of particles in solution is usually synonymous with the Guinier plot. The approximation behind this plot, developed by Guinier in 1939 provides a simple yet accurate characterization of the scattering behavior of particles at low scattering angle $q$, together with a computationally efficient way of inferring their radii of gyration $R_G$. Moreover, this approximation is valid beyond spherical scatterers, making its use ubiquitous in the SAXS world. However, when it is important to estimate further particle characteristics, such as the anisotropy of the scatterer's shape, no similar or extended approximations are available. Existing tools to characterize the shape of scatterers rely either on prior knowledge of the scatterers' geometry or on iterative procedures to infer the particle shape \textit{ab initio}.\\ In this work we develop a low angle approximation of the scattering intensity $I(q)$ for ellipsoids of revolution and show how to extract size and anisotropy information from the parameters of that approximation. Beyond ideal ellipsoids of revolution, we show that this approximation can be used to infer the size and shape of molecules in solution, both in computational and experimental scenarios. We discuss the limits of our approach and study the impact of a particle's anisotropy in the Guinier estimate of $R_G$.

Explore related subjects

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

Biel Roig-Solvas, Dana H. Brooks, Lee Makowski. 2018-08-16. Estimating the Anisotropy of Protein Structures from SAXS. https://arxiv.org/abs/1808.05569

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related papers

Scale dependent chirality in twist-bend liquid crystals

The discovery of new classes of lyotropic and thermotropic liquid crystals (e.g., twist-bend, splay, and ferroelectric phases), together with significant advances in experimental techniques for their investigation, has renewed interest in a number of physical phenomena that have been studied in classical liquid crystals (nematics, cholesterics, and smectics) for more than a century. In this paper, we revisit one such ''old--new'' problem, recently highlighted in the preprint by A. Ashkinazi, H. Chhabra, A. El Moumane, M. M. C. Tortora, and J. P. K. Doye, ''Chirality Transfer in Lyotropic Twist-Bend Nematics,'' arXiv:2508.03544v1 (2025), in which various mechanisms of chirality transfer from the molecular scale to the structural scale were discussed. Here we present a simple theoretical analysis of chirality transfer within a Landau theory describing the phase transition between cholesteric and chiral twist-bend liquid crystals. We demonstrate that the handedness of the heliconical structure is opposite to that of the parent cholesteric phase. This relationship originates from the orthogonality between the cholesteric director and the vector order parameter characterizing the phase.

cond-mat.soft

Why life is hot

The process of evolution by natural selection leads to phenotypes of increasing fitness. For cellular chemical reaction networks, this means optimising a variety of fitness functions such as robustness, precision, or sensitivity to external stimuli. We argue that these diverse goals can be achieved by a versatile, generic mechanism: coupling chemical reaction networks to reservoirs that are strongly out of equilibrium. Using theory and numerics we show that this mechanism of optimisation comes at the price of significant heat dissipation. We compute the heat flux caused by kinetic proofreading in {\it Escherichia coli} and show that it constitutes a significant fraction of the total heat flux experimentally measured in this model organism. We then demonstrate that the degree of optimality achievable saturates, and that Nature appears to operate near saturation despite high energetic costs. We argue that `life is hot' largely because of the need for a versatile mechanism to optimise a variety of fitness functions.

cond-mat.soft

Understanding Structural Representation in Foundation Models for Polymers

From the relative scarcity of training data to the lack of standardized benchmarks, the creation of effective foundation models for polymers faces significant and multi-faceted challenges. At the core, many of these issues are tied directly to the structural representation of polymers. Here, we present a chemical language foundation model built on using a SMILES-based polymer graph representation (CPG) that incorporates polymer architectural features and connectivity that are often missing in other line notations. This foundation model exhibited excellent performance on 30 different polymer property benchmark datasets. Critical evaluation of the developed representation against other variations in control experiments reveals this approach to be a robust method of representing polymers in language-based foundation models. These experiments also reveal a strong invariance of structural representations to small perturbations, with many variations of structural representation exceeding or equaling state-of-the-art (SOTA) performance. Surprisingly, SMILES representations which are chemically or semantically invalid also provided near or SOTA performance in several instances--underscoring an unexamined blind spot in the development of chemistry language models. Examination of error sources and attention maps for the evaluated structural representations corroborate the findings of the control experiments, highlighting the ability of the model to interpolate SMILES sequence space in a manner that is loosely congruent to chemical and architectural space for polymers. Overall, this work highlights the surprising robustness of chemistry language models to structural representation perturbations and identifies the conditions under which CPG representation provides meaningful advantages.

cond-mat.soft