Search arXivSearch

arXiv · 1812.05571

Analytically Embedding Differential Equation Constraints into Least Squares Support Vector Machines using the Theory of Functional Connections

Abstract

Differential equations (DEs) are used as numerical models to describe physical phenomena throughout the field of engineering and science, including heat and fluid flow, structural bending, and systems dynamics. While there are many other techniques for finding approximate solutions to these equations, this paper looks to compare the application of the Theory of Functional Connections (TFC) with one based on least-squares support vector machines (LS-SVM). The TFC method uses a constrained expression, an expression that always satisfies the DE constraints, which transforms the process of solving a DE into solving an unconstrained optimization problem that is ultimately solved via least-squares (LS). In addition to individual analysis, the two methods are merged into a new methodology, called constrained SVMs (CSVM), by incorporating the LS-SVM method into the TFC framework to solve unconstrained problems. Numerical tests are conducted on four sample problems: One first order linear ordinary differential equation (ODE), one first order nonlinear ODE, one second order linear ODE, and one two-dimensional linear partial differential equation (PDE). Using the LS-SVM method as a benchmark, a speed comparison is made for all the problems by timing the training period, and an accuracy comparison is made using the maximum error and mean squared error on the training and test sets. In general, TFC is shown to be slightly faster (by an order of magnitude or less) and more accurate (by multiple orders of magnitude) than the LS-SVM and CSVM approaches.

Explore related subjects

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

Carl Leake, Hunter Johnston, Lidia Smith, Daniele Mortari. 2019-10-09. Analytically Embedding Differential Equation Constraints into Least Squares Support Vector Machines using the Theory of Functional Connections. https://doi.org/10.3390/make1040060

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related papers

Combinatorial Inference on the Optimal Assortment in Multinomial Logit Models

Assortment optimization has received active explorations in the past few decades due to its practical importance. Despite the extensive literature dealing with optimization algorithms and latent score estimation, uncertainty quantification for the optimal assortment still needs to be explored and is of great practical significance. Instead of estimating and recovering the complete optimal offer set, decision-makers may only be interested in testing whether a given property holds true for the optimal assortment, such as whether they should include several products of interest in the optimal set, or how many categories of products the optimal set should include. This paper proposes a novel inferential framework for testing such properties. We consider the widely adopted multinomial logit (MNL) model, where we assume that each customer will purchase an item within the offered products with a probability proportional to the underlying preference score associated with the product. We reduce inferring a general optimal assortment property to quantifying the uncertainty associated with the sign change point detection of the marginal revenue gaps. We show the asymptotic normality of the marginal revenue gap estimator, and construct a maximum statistic via the gap estimators to detect the sign change point. By approximating the distribution of the maximum statistic with multiplier bootstrap techniques, we propose a valid testing procedure. We also conduct numerical experiments to assess the performance of our method.

stat.ML

C-Learner: Constrained Learning for Causal Inference

Debiasing methods such as augmented inverse propensity weighting (AIPW), and targeted maximum likelihood estimation (TMLE) enjoy asymptotic properties like semiparametric efficiency and double robustness, but can produce unstable estimates in practice that require ad hoc adjustments (e.g., truncating propensity scores). In contrast, simple plug-ins can remain stable but lack these asymptotic guarantees. To achieve the best of both worlds---a plug-in that enjoys strong asymptotic guarantees---we propose a constrained learning framework that trains a nuisance model to minimize prediction error subject to the constraint that the estimated first-order error of the resulting plug-in is zero. To compare different debiasing methods that share the same classical limit, we study a stylized high-dimensional regression problem where nuisance estimation errors do not vanish asymptotically. Our unified analysis covers both $d n$, as well as ridge regularization, and characterizes how overlap affects the estimators' limiting distributions. Under sufficient overlap, our estimator has smaller asymptotic variance than AIPW and TMLE, whereas when overlap deteriorates so much that AIPW and TMLE are no longer root-$n$ consistent, constrained learning still retains the direct plug-in's root-$n$ limit. Empirically, across a range of experimental settings including those with text-based covariates and language models, we observe our estimator outperforms classical debiasing methods in challenging settings with limited overlap between treatment and control, and performs similarly otherwise.

stat.ML

Small Gradient Norm Regret for Online Convex Optimization

This paper introduces a new problem-dependent regret measure for online convex optimization with smooth losses. The notion, which we call the $G^\star$ regret, depends on the cumulative squared gradient norm evaluated at the decision in hindsight. We show that the $G^\star$ regret strictly refines the existing $L^\star$ (small loss) regret, and that it can be arbitrarily sharper when the losses have vanishing curvature around the hindsight decision. We establish upper and lower bounds on the $G^\star$ regret and extend our results to dynamic regret and bandit settings. As a byproduct, we refine the existing convergence analysis of stochastic optimization algorithms in the interpolation regime. Some experiments validate our theoretical findings.

stat.ML