Search arXivSearch

arXiv · 2003.05452

Global 21-cm signal extraction from foreground and instrumental effects III: Utilizing drift-scan time dependence and full Stokes measurements

Abstract

When using valid foreground and signal models, the uncertainties on extracted signals in global 21-cm signal experiments depend principally on the overlap between signal and foreground models. In this paper, we investigate two strategies for decreasing this overlap: (i) utilizing time dependence by fitting multiple drift-scan spectra simultaneously and (ii) measuring all four Stokes parameters instead of only the total power, Stokes I. Although measuring polarization requires different instruments than are used in most existing experiments, all existing experiments can utilize drift-scan measurements merely by averaging their data differently. In order to evaluate the increase in constraining power from using these two techniques, we define a method for connecting Root-Mean-Square (RMS) uncertainties to probabilistic confidence levels. Employing simulations, we find that fitting only one total power spectrum leads to RMS uncertainties at the few K level, while fitting multiple time-binned, drift-scan spectra yields uncertainties at the $\lesssim 10$ mK level. This significant improvement only appears if the spectra are modeled with one set of basis vectors, instead of using multiple sets of basis vectors that independently model each spectrum. Assuming that they are simulated accurately, measuring all four Stokes parameters also leads to lower uncertainties. These two strategies can be employed simultaneously and fitting multiple time bins of all four Stokes parameters yields the best precision measurements of the 21-cm signal, approaching the noise level in the data.

Explore related subjects

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

Keith Tauscher, David Rapetti, Jack O. Burns. 2020-04-23. Global 21-cm signal extraction from foreground and instrumental effects III: Utilizing drift-scan time dependence and full Stokes measurements. https://doi.org/10.3847/1538-4357%2Fab9b2a

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related papers

Agentic AI for Gravitational Wave Data Analysis: A Head-to-Head Comparison of Coding Agents Executing a Matched Filter Pipeline on Einstein Telescope Simulated Data

We report a methodological study of agentic AI in gravitational-wave data analysis: two systems, Claude Code (Anthropic) and Codex (OpenAI), autonomously executed the same simple end-to-end pipeline on Einstein Telescope (ET) simulated data, on shared infrastructure and without human intervention. The object of study is the behaviour, reliability and auditability of the agents, not the physics output, used here as a controlled test case. The pipeline comprises power spectral density estimation from simulated ET noise, geometric template bank generation with IMRPhenomD waveforms, matched-filter recovery of 100 binary black hole injections, results generation, and LLM-assisted production of a LaTeX manuscript in Physical Review D style. Both agents received identical specifications and resources. The experiment was run twice: first with unrealistically loud injections, then with signals rescaled to a physically motivated SNR range. In both runs the results converged, with comparable detection efficiency and template bank size. The agents, however, behaved very differently: Claude Code finished in about 3.4 minutes with silent deviations from the specification, while Codex needed about 16 minutes across explicit self-correcting restarts, including an unsolicited optimization of the matched-filter inner loop. In the second run, a subtle difference in interpreting the SNR-range instruction produced a genuine scientific divergence: Claude Code silently raised the SNR floor to 8 (100% efficiency), while Codex followed the specification literally down to SNR 7 and recorded one missed detection. We discuss the implications - speed versus auditability, silent deviation versus explicit self-correction, instruction interpretation, and intermediate data representations in multi-model pipelines - for agentic AI in scientific workflows, within the limits of a single-pipeline, two-run benchmark.

astro-ph.IM

Fast Astronomical Transients in Archival Photographic Plates: Using optical aberrations as a tool for discerning real images, from plate artifacts

The detection of fast astronomical transients in photographic plates from the Palomar sky surveys conducted in the 1950s, was subject to the criticism that such transients could be just the effect of otherwise unaccounted for plate artifacts. In this paper, we show that transient images exhibit the coma aberration pattern expected from off-axis point sources recorded through the telescope optics, a signature that plate artifacts cannot naturally reproduce. Although the data does not by themselves establish the physical origin of the light that generated the images, they lend support to hypotheses that do not rely on instrumental effects to explain transients.

astro-ph.IM

A Two-Stage Physically Grounded Optical Design Framework with Application to a Multi-Channel Focal Reducer

We present a two-stage optimization framework that formalizes classical optical design strategies within a reproducible computational workflow. Starting point designs are constructed from paraxial and third-order models, providing optically consistent initial configurations. These configurations are refined through a physically grounded residual merit function evaluated by exact ray tracing, followed by RMS-based image refinement. Applied to a multi-channel astronomical focal reducer, the methodology provides a structured transition from aberration-based modeling to numerical optimization while preserving physically interpretable intermediate stages. By embedding classical optical design principles into an open computational pipeline, the approach reduces reliance on heuristic initial conditions and improves the reproducibility and interpretability of the design process.

astro-ph.IM