Search arXiv⌕ Search
Home/Archive/arXiv

arXiv · 2008.06790

On the Power of Automata Minimization in Reactive Synthesis

Shufang Zhu·Lucas M. Tabajara·Geguang Pu·Moshe Y. Vardi
View original source ↗Read source document ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

Temporal logic is often used to describe temporal properties in AI applications. The most popular language for doing so is Linear Temporal Logic (LTL). Recently, LTL on finite traces, LTLf, has been investigated in several contexts. In order to reason about LTLf, formulas are typically compiled into deterministic finite automata (DFA), as the intermediate semantic representation. Moreover, due to the fact that DFAs have canonical representation, efficient minimization algorithms can be applied to maximally reduce DFA size, helping to speed up subsequent computations. Here, we present a thorough investigation on two classical minimization algorithms, namely, the Hopcroft and Brzozowski algorithms. More specifically, we show how to apply these algorithms to semi-symbolic (explicit states, symbolic transition functions) automata representation. We then compare the two algorithms in the context of an LTLf-synthesis framework, starting from LTLf formulas. While earlier studies on comparing the two algorithms starting from randomly-generated automata concluded that neither algorithm dominates, our results suggest that starting from LTLf formulas, Hopcroft's algorithm is the best choice in the context of reactive synthesis. Deeper analysis explains why the supposed advantage of Brzozowski's algorithm does not materialize in practice.

Explore related subjects

cs.FL

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

Shufang Zhu, Lucas M. Tabajara, Geguang Pu, Moshe Y. Vardi. 2021-09-17. On the Power of Automata Minimization in Reactive Synthesis. https://doi.org/10.4204/eptcs.346.8

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related papers

arXiv2026

A Myhill-Nerode Theorem for Generalized Automata, with Applications to Pattern Matching and Compression

The model of generalized automata, introduced by Eilenberg in 1974, allows representing a regular language more concisely than conventional automata by allowing edges to be labeled not only with characters, but also strings. Giammarresi and Montalbano introduced a notion of determinism for generalized automata [STACS 1995]. While generalized deterministic automata retain many properties of conventional deterministic automata, the uniqueness of a minimal generalized deterministic automaton is lost. In the first part of the paper, we show that the lack of uniqueness can be explained by introducing a set $ \mathcal{W(A)} $ associated with a generalized automaton $ \mathcal{A} $. In this way, we derive for the first time a full Myhill-Nerode theorem for generalized automata, which contains the textbook Myhill-Nerode theorem for conventional automata as a degenerate case. In the second part of the paper, we show that the set $ \mathcal{W(A)} $ leads to applications for pattern matching and data compression. We show that a Wheeler generalized automata can be stored using $ \mathfrak{e} \log σ(1 + o(1)) + O(e) $ bits so that pattern matching queries can be solved in $ O(m \log \log σ) $ time, where $ \mathfrak{e} $ is the total length of all edge labels, $ e $ is the number of edges, $ σ$ is the size of the alphabet and $ m $ is the length of the pattern.

cs.FL↗
arXiv2026

Quadratic Word Equations with a Linear Side: Polynomial Nielsen Graph Diameter and NP-Completeness

The satisfiability problem for word equations asks whether variables can be replaced by words so that the two sides become equal. For regular word equations, in which each variable occurs at most once on each side, satisfiability is NP-complete. For general quadratic word equations, in which each variable occurs at most twice in total, satisfiability is NP-hard, but its membership in NP remains open. We consider an intermediate class: quadratic word equations with a linear side, where each variable occurs at most once on one designated side. We show that the Nielsen graph of an equation $U=V$ in this class, with total length $N=|U|+|V|$, has diameter $O(N^{12})$, measured over reachable pairs of vertices. Together with the known NP-hardness for regular word equations, this result establishes NP-completeness of satisfiability for this class. We also show that each strongly connected component is isomorphic to the length-preserving reachability graph of a regular equation, and that the condensation graph has depth at most $|U|+2|V|$.

cs.FL↗
arXiv2026

Contributions to the hierarchy of probabilistic languages

We reconsider the theory of probabilistic formal languages generated by n-gram models and by probabilistic context-free grammars (PCFGs). The expected hierarchy of probabilistic grammars is established by proving that every probabilistic language generated by an n-gram model is also generated by some PCFG, while some probabilistic languages generated by PCFGs cannot be generated by any $n$-gram model. We introduce the notion of fully connected PCFGs, namely PCFGs in Chomsky normal form where every production rule only involving non-terminals has non-zero probability. Our main result shows that any probabilistic language generated by an $n$-gram model differs from any probabilistic language generated by a fully connected PCFG. Therefore, the class of probabilistic languages generated by $n$-gram models is not a subset of the class generated by fully connected PCFGs.

cs.FL↗