Search arXiv⌕ Search
Home/Archive/arXiv

arXiv · 2010.00640

Counterfactual Thermodynamics: Extracting work from a lack of macroscopic change

Sushrut Ghonge·Dervis Can Vural
View original source ↗Read source document ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

A sudden change in the macroscopic parameters of a system will cause it to depart from equilibrium. In this paper we study how a lack of change can also inform of such a departure, and allow for work extraction. Potential events that are unrealized can provide information pertaining the microstates of the system, essentially playing the role of a passive Maxwell demon, thereby allowing one to infer details about the microstate probability distribution. Here, we first qualitatively argue that this effect is present and consequential in almost every physical system, but is ignored in the standard formulation of equilibrium statistical mechanics. Then, as a case study, we quantitatively investigate the local and global thermodynamic properties of an ideal gas placed in a fragile container that nevertheless, does not burst. This non-event indicates a departure from equilibrium and allows work extraction from the system. It also leads to corrections to the heat capacity of the gas.

Explore related subjects

cond-mat.stat-mech

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

Sushrut Ghonge, Dervis Can Vural. 2022-02-02. Counterfactual Thermodynamics: Extracting work from a lack of macroscopic change. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.physa.2022.126893

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related papers

arXiv2026

The meaning of entropy (demonstration of a much needed theorem)

The association of information with entropy has been argued on plausibility arguments involving the operation of imaginary engines and beings, and it is not a universal theorem. In this paper, a theorem by Charles Bennett on reversible computation that associates entropy with erasure of information is recognized as this much needed theorem. It is proposed a real, non thermal engine, operated by humans. It is proved: (1) The engine obeys two laws, identical {\it mutatis mutandis} to the two laws of thermodynamics; therefore, the entropy that arises in the operation of the engine has the same meaning of the entropy that arises in the operation of thermal engines. (2) The engine operates in stages similar to the stages in Bennett's three tapes reversible computer; therefore the entropy in the engine has the same meaning of the entropy in computation. The conclusion is that also the thermal entropy is a measure of erased or missing information. As a side result, information is measured in physical units, which complies with Landauer's principle. A prototype at work is shown in video.

cond-mat.stat-mech↗
arXiv2026

Information geometry of perturbed gradient flow systems on hypergraphs: A perspective towards nonequilibrium physics

This article serves to concisely review the link between gradient flow systems on hypergraphs and information geometry which has been established within the last five years. Gradient flow systems describe a wealth of physical phenomena and provide powerful analytical technquies which are based on the variational energy-dissipation principle. Modern nonequilbrium physics has complemented this classical principle with thermodynamic uncertaintly relations, speed limits, entropy production rate decompositions, and many more. In this article, we formulate these modern principles within the framework of perturbed gradient flow systems on hypergraphs. In particular, we discuss the geometry induced by the Bregman divergence, the physical implications of dual foliations, as well as the corresponding infinitesimal Riemannian geometry for gradient flow systems. Through the geometrical perspective, we are naturally led to new concepts such as moduli spaces for perturbed gradient flow systems and thermodynamical area which is crucial for understanding speed limits. We hope to encourage the readers working in either of the two fields to further expand on and foster the interaction between the two fields.

cond-mat.stat-mech↗
arXiv2026

Anomalous diffusion and singular transport from hydrodynamic recoupling

In charge neutral fluids, such as the Dirac fluid in graphene at the Dirac point, charge transport remains diffusive despite the presence of ballistically propagating sound waves: sound waves ``hydrodynamically decouple'' from the slower charge fluctuations. For quasi-one-dimensional charge neutral fluids, we show that this convective charge diffusion is not smoothly connected to the normal diffusion that arises when momentum conservation is broken by noise (or static impurities). Instead, the charge diffusion constant is a discontinuous function of noise, which (in the weak-noise limit) depends only on the ratio of momentum and energy relaxation rates. In the special limit of momentum-conserving noise (e.g., spatially uniform fluctuations of the Hamiltonian), the diffusion constant diverges in the presence of noise. We describe the resulting superdiffusion in terms of coupled Burgers equations. We present a general mechanism---hydrodynamic recoupling---by which weak noise can induce singular changes in transport coefficients. Our results highlight the limits of zero-noise extrapolation for predicting dynamical quantities like diffusion constants.

cond-mat.stat-mech↗