Search arXivSearch

arXiv · 2104.08846

Tutorial on logistic-regression calibration and fusion: Converting a score to a likelihood ratio

Abstract

Logistic-regression calibration and fusion are potential steps in the calculation of forensic likelihood ratios. The present paper provides a tutorial on logistic-regression calibration and fusion at a practical conceptual level with minimal mathematical complexity. A score is log-likelihood-ratio like in that it indicates the degree of similarity of a pair of samples while taking into consideration their typicality with respect to a model of the relevant population. A higher-valued score provides more support for the same-origin hypothesis over the different-origin hypothesis than does a lower-valued score; however, the absolute values of scores are not interpretable as log likelihood ratios. Logistic-regression calibration is a procedure for converting scores to log likelihood ratios, and logistic-regression fusion is a procedure for converting parallel sets of scores from multiple forensic-comparison systems to log likelihood ratios. Logistic-regression calibration and fusion were developed for automatic speaker recognition and are popular in forensic voice comparison. They can also be applied in other branches of forensic science, a fingerprint/fingermark example is provided.

Explore related subjects

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

Geoffrey Stewart Morrison. 2021-04-18. Tutorial on logistic-regression calibration and fusion: Converting a score to a likelihood ratio. https://doi.org/10.1080/00450618.2012.733025

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related papers

Causal Inference with Video Features as Treatments

We develop the first statistical methodology for causal inference with video features as treatments. Video is the most engaging content modality on the internet. A central causal question is how audience reactions change in response to treatment features that unfold over the course of a video. Unfortunately, standard causal inference methods are not applicable because confounding features are latent, high-dimensional, and dynamically related to both the treatment sequence and the outcome trajectory. To address these challenges, we first reproduce each video using a deep generative model and leverage the model's internal representations as learned, low-dimensional summaries of video content for causal estimation. We then establish that the average potential-outcome trajectory under dynamic stochastic interventions is nonparametrically identified. Lastly, we propose a consistent and asymptotically normal estimator based on a longitudinal neural network architecture. We empirically validate our approach by constructing a new causal inference benchmark consisting of $10{,}000$ Super Mario Bros. levels played by fixed Mario AI agents, where ground-truth causal effects are known by construction. Finally, we apply our method to television advertisements from the 2020 U.S. presidential campaign and find that increasing the probability of a candidate appearing over time leads to higher average viewer evaluations. With the proposed methodology, researchers can ask which visual features, appearing at which points in a video, influence audience responses, while benchmarking new methods against datasets with known ground-truth causal effects.

stat.AP

Observational constraints on net radiative forcing confirm aviation contrail warming

Contrail cirrus represents a critical component of aviation's non-CO2 climate impact, but its net radiative forcing, the balance between longwave warming and shortwave cooling, remains poorly constrained by direct observations. As a result, current assessments rely almost exclusively on microphysical models such as CoCiP and global climate simulations. Existing empirical estimates are largely restricted to young, linear tracks, because satellite detection masks have a poor recall of contrails once they spread and merge with natural cirrus, leaving a structural gap in our understanding of long-lived, non-linear contrail cirrus. To address this we use a causal framework that isolates the net radiative contrail effect of flight traffic over the Americas. Building on recent progress that quantified the longwave warming contrail effect using advected flight paths as a proxy for contrails, we expand this continuous treatment approach to capture the highly skewed shortwave cooling impact, delivering a 12-hour lifespan net observational radiative forcing. Our analysis reveals a statistically significant net warming energy forcing of 33.7 (95% CI: 20.8, 47.8) GJ per km flown from April 2019 to April 2020, providing a large-scale empirical quantification of long contrail lifespan impact of the same order as, though somewhat larger than, previous bottom-up simulation estimates. This observational benchmark offers an independent line of evidence on the sign and magnitude of the climate impact of contrails.

stat.AP

Anthropogenic Forcing, Climate Change, and the Shape of Warming: Statistical Inference for Distributional Cointegration

Anthropogenic forcing components follow different long-run paths, while persistent temperature change can involve distributional changes beyond the mean. Scalar regressions aggregate these components and retain only mean temperature, obscuring how distinct forcing paths relate to persistent distributional change. We develop new testing, estimation, and inference methods for long-run relations between an integrated predictor vector and a density-valued response. These comprise a residual-based test of between-cointegration (whether predictor trends account for all stochastic trends in the response density), a fully modified least-squares estimator of predictor-specific functional responses, and simulation-based inference for interpretable projections. We apply the methods to densities of observed local temperature anomalies and anthropogenic effective radiative forcing divided into CO$_2$ and non-CO$_2$ portfolios. The test results are consistent with persistent movements in these portfolios statistically accounting for the persistent evolution of the anomaly distribution, with no additional stochastic trend detected in the residual. A joint test rejects the common-response restriction imposed by aggregating the two portfolios. The fitted CO$_2$ response mainly shifts mass toward warmer anomalies and increases central concentration, whereas the non-CO$_2$ response produces a smaller shift but greater dispersion and off-center reshaping. Positive fitted mean responses for both portfolios conceal these contrasts, demonstrating the information lost through scalar aggregation.

stat.AP