Search arXivSearch

arXiv · 2201.00200

Local heating due to convective overshooting and the solar modelling problem

Abstract

Recent hydrodynamical simulations of convection in a solar-like model suggest that penetrative convective flows at the boundary of the convective envelope modify the thermal background in the overshooting layer. Based on these results, we implement in one-dimensional stellar evolution codes a simple prescription to modify the temperature gradient below the convective boundary of a solar model. This simple prescription qualitatively reproduces the behaviour found in the hydrodynamical simulations, namely a local heating and smoothing of the temperature gradient below the convective boundary. We show that introducing local heating in the overshooting layer can reduce the sound-speed discrepancy usually reported between solar models and the structure of the Sun inferred from helioseismology. It also affects key quantities in the convective envelope, such as the density, the entropy, and the speed of sound. These effects could help reduce the discrepancies between solar models and observed constraints based on seismic inversions of the Ledoux discriminant. Since mixing due to overshooting and local heating are the result of the same convective penetration process, the goal of this work is to invite solar modellers to consider both processes for a more consistent approach.

Explore related subjects

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

Baraffe I, Constantino T, Clarke J, Le Saux A, Goffrey T, Guillet T, Pratt J, Vlaykov D. G. 2022-01-01. Local heating due to convective overshooting and the solar modelling problem. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361%2F202142666

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related papers

Host-star metallicities and kinematics of directly imaged brown-dwarf companions

Brown dwarfs are common as free-floating objects but rare as close companions to Sun-like stars, a disparity known as the "brown-dwarf desert". Host-star metallicity can constrain whether these companions form mainly through metal-sensitive core accretion or through less metal-dependent disc or cloud fragmentation. We extend our homogeneous spectroscopic analysis of directly imaged planet hosts into the brown-dwarf regime and compare their metallicities with those of planet hosts and close-in brown-dwarf hosts. We compiled 54 unique directly imaged brown-dwarf systems selected over an inclusive 13-80 M_Jup interval and projected separations from about 5 au to several thousand au. Objects near the model-dependent 70-75 M_Jup hydrogen-burning boundary may instead be very-low-mass stars. For 31 hosts with archival high-resolution spectra, we derived atmospheric parameters and metallicities using Bayesian spectral synthesis. Literature companion masses and projected separations are heterogeneous and are used only for demographic context. Galactic velocities were calculated for 46 hosts solely to characterise the youth-biased imaging sample. The host stars have a broadly solar metallicity distribution, with a median [Fe/H] of +0.06 dex and a median absolute deviation of 0.11 dex, and show no strong metal-rich bias. No statistically significant metallicity difference is detected between the lower- and higher-mass directly imaged subsamples. The hosts are kinematically cold, as expected from the youth-biased selection of direct-imaging surveys. The absence of a strong metal-rich bias suggests that classical core accretion does not dominate the wide-orbit brown-dwarf population. Disc instability and cloud fragmentation remain plausible, but the current sample and heterogeneous companion properties do not permit object-by-object discrimination between these channels.

astro-ph.SR

Stability Analysis of the Proton Hammerhead Distribution Observed by Parker Solar Probe: Linear Theory and Fully Kinetic Simulations under Idealised Conditions

The non-adiabatic heating of the slow Solar Wind (SW) remains an open problem, with wave--particle interactions as a primary candidate mechanism. Novel in situ Parker Solar Probe (PSP) observations reveal strongly perpendicular anisotropic velocity distribution functions (VDFs), called "hammerhead", correlated with intense wave activity. These VDFs are systematically measured at the Heliospheric Current Sheet (HCS), making the hammerhead an important kinetic signature of the slow SW. In this work, we employ a fully kinetic particle-in-cell approach, complemented by a linear Vlasov solver to cross-validate the simulation results, to investigate the stability of these VDFs, the timescales over which they evolve, and their interaction with plasma waves. Our main findings indicate that the hammerhead distribution is primarily susceptible to drift-type instabilities, while energy is nonlinearly transferred back to the plasma through a combination of Landau and cyclotron resonances, resulting in net heating in the parallel direction, preferentially energizing the beam proton population. Crucially, these nonlinear interactions do not drastically alter the morphology of the distribution. This suggests the possibility that the hammerhead may be generated locally within the HCS in the inner heliosphere and subsequently advected outward, where it is eventually measured by PSP. This work lays the ground for future investigations into the kinetic physics of the HCS.

astro-ph.SR

The independence of the mid-infrared RR Lyrae Period-Luminosity relation from metallicity from a study of three globular clusters in the Large Magellanic Cloud

RR Lyrae are pulsating variable stars tracing old ($>10$ Gyr) stellar populations, and exhibit a strong mid-infrared Period-Luminosity (PL) relation that can be calibrated with known parallaxes to infer distances. Here we present Period-Luminosity relations and distance moduli for three isolated globular clusters in the Large Magellanic Cloud: Reticulum, NGC 1841, and NGC 1466. Our analysis uses legacy \textit{Spitzer Space Telescope} images obtained by the Carnegie RR Lyrae Program, and an internally self-consistent sample restricted to RRab stars, with cluster membership confirmed using Gaia DR3 proper motions and photometry. In the Spitzer 3.6~$μ$m band, we simultaneously fit a PL for these clusters using a slope derived from Galactic Globular Clusters, yielding extinction-corrected distance moduli of $18.47\pm0.09$ mag for Reticulum, $18.29\pm0.09$ mag for NGC 1841, and $18.61\pm0.09$ mag for NGC 1466. The latter two are the first RR Lyrae PL-based distance moduli for these clusters, and all three are consistent with literature values from other techniques. Additionally we fit a PL with slope as a free parameter, and find that this LMC-derived PL is consistent with that derived from Galactic GCs. Simultaneously fitting a PLZ for the three clusters yields a metallicity coefficient $c= -0.03\pm0.05~\mathrm{mag}~\mathrm{dex}^{-1}$ which can be considered a negligible dependence of the PL on metallicity ($|c| <0.1$ mag dex$^{-1}$). Modelling an intrinsic width, $W$, to the PL/ PLZ yields a consistent value $W\approx0.1\pm0.02~\mathrm{mag}$, suggesting intrinsic width is not driven by metallicity.

astro-ph.SR