On simultaneous fitting of nonlinear and linear rheology data: Preventing a false sense of certainty

Piyush K. Singh; Randy H. Ewoldt

Home/Archive/arXiv

arXiv · 2202.02867

On simultaneous fitting of nonlinear and linear rheology data: Preventing a false sense of certainty

Piyush K. Singh·Randy H. Ewoldt

View original source ↗Read source document ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

Uncertainty propagates through calculations, down to molecular scales to infer microstructural features, and up to macroscopic scales with predictive flow simulations. Here we study uncertainty quantification for sequential (two-step) versus simultaneous (all at once) fitting methods with linear and weakly-nonlinear rheological data. Using an example of a combined dataset on small-amplitude oscillatory shear (SAOS) and medium-amplitude oscillatory shear (MAOS) for a linear entangled polymer melt (cis-1,4-polyisoprene), we demonstrate with a multi-mode Giesekus model how the fit parameter uncertainties are significantly under-estimated with the sequential fit because of the neglect of model parameter correlations. These results are surprising because weakly-nonlinear data is only an asymptotic step away from the linear data, yet it has significant impact on calibrating the linear model parameters. Similarly, the nonlinear parameter estimates and uncertainties are impacted by considering the linear data in a simultaneous fit. To compare multi-mode spectra of nonlinear parameters (mobility parameters {α_i} from the Giesekus model), we derive new average measures based on moments of the spectra related to the high-frequency MAOS limit. The spectral averages are also sensitive to sequential versus simultaneous fitting. Our results reveal the importance of using simultaneous fitting for honest uncertainty quantification, even with weakly-nonlinear data.

Explore related subjects

cond-mat.soft

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeX RIS

Piyush K. Singh, Randy H. Ewoldt. 2022-02-06. On simultaneous fitting of nonlinear and linear rheology data: Preventing a false sense of certainty. https://arxiv.org/abs/2202.02867

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related papers

arXiv2026

Spontaneous Vortex Instability in Active Nematics

One of the defining results in the study of active matter is the spontaneous flow instability, through which a homogeneous, uniformly aligned state breaks translational symmetry along a single direction and develops sustained flow. The vortex state that emerges at higher activity has instead been attributed to nonlinear dynamics. Using a Floquet-type linear stability analysis, we show that no such mechanism is required: the flowing state undergoes a secondary, zigzag instability that breaks the remaining translational symmetry and produces the vortex state. We further identify a regime in which the flowing state ceases to exist and vortices emerge directly from the uniformly aligned state. Under channel confinement, the instability selects a length scale that differs from the establishedactivelengthscale, andsetsthenumberofvorticesthatappear, leadingtoaconfinement- selected pattern reminiscent of a vortex lattice, opening a route toward direct experimental tests of this instability. Full nonlinear simulations reproduce the predicted onset activities and the selected vortex number.

cond-mat.soft↗

arXiv2026

Active pistons extract work by periodic compression alone

Active matter is liable to invent protocols that evade the constraints of equilibrium thermodynamics. We put forward active pistons that extract work by periodic compression alone without changing any bulk property of the system. Such pistons necessarily couple the perturbation imposed by an external operator with some degrees of freedom internal to active components. We illustrate this design principle with elastic networks composed of self-aligning motile particles. For slow protocols, self-alignment always overwhelms mechanical friction when the internal activity exceeds a specific threshold controlled by fluctuations. We identify the key response coefficient that helps delineate regimes of work extraction, and reveal that the corresponding phase diagram follows a master curve with re-entrance in terms of noise amplitude. Overall, our active pistons embody a novel design principle with broad implications for building innovative engines far from equilibrium.

cond-mat.soft↗

arXiv2026

Geometry-induced flocking and topological sound on a defect-free curved surface

We study an ordered polar active flock on a torus and show that topological sound persists on a compact curved surface without topological defects or physical boundaries. Using the covariant Toner Tu theory, we derive an effective nonHermitian Dirac operator whose curvature-induced mass changes sign across the outer and inner equators, producing two Jackiw Rebbi domain walls. These support co-propagating but distinct chiral edge excitations: a density mode localized on the positively curved outer equator and a Goldstone mode localized on the negatively curved inner equator. The bulk bands possess opposite half-integer Chern numbers whose jumps across the domain walls are determined by the sign of the Gaussian curvature. We further show that the localised modes are protected by a one-dimensional Callias index theorem, while the sum of the local indices obeys the Poincare Hopf theorem on the compact surface. Our results establish that curvature alone, independent of defects and boundaries, is sufficient to generate and protect topological sound in active matter, providing a unified connection between non-Hermitian topology, differential geometry, and hydrodynamic theory of collective motion.

cond-mat.soft↗