Search arXiv⌕ Search

arXiv · 2204.05205

Rethinking Machine Learning Model Evaluation in Pathology

Abstract

Machine Learning has been applied to pathology images in research and clinical practice with promising outcomes. However, standard ML models often lack the rigorous evaluation required for clinical decisions. Machine learning techniques for natural images are ill-equipped to deal with pathology images that are significantly large and noisy, require expensive labeling, are hard to interpret, and are susceptible to spurious correlations. We propose a set of practical guidelines for ML evaluation in pathology that address the above concerns. The paper includes measures for setting up the evaluation framework, effectively dealing with variability in labels, and a recommended suite of tests to address issues related to domain shift, robustness, and confounding variables. We hope that the proposed framework will bridge the gap between ML researchers and domain experts, leading to wider adoption of ML techniques in pathology and improving patient outcomes.

Explore related subjects

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

Syed Ashar Javed, Dinkar Juyal, Zahil Shanis, Shreya Chakraborty, Harsha Pokkalla, Aaditya Prakash. 2022-04-18. Rethinking Machine Learning Model Evaluation in Pathology. https://arxiv.org/abs/2204.05205

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related papers

Bridging the Inter-Domain Gap through Low-Level Features for Cross-Modal Medical Image Segmentation

This paper addresses cross-modal medical image segmentation, focusing on MRI-CT transfer in a source-only domain generalization setting. During training, only source-modality samples are available, while unlabeled target-modality images are used for testing. We propose LowBridge, which builds on the observation that cross-modal images share similar low-level features (e.g. edges) as they depict the same types of anatomical structures. Specifically, we first train a generative model to recover the source images from their edge features, followed by training a segmentation model on the generated source images, separately. At test time, edge features from the target images are input to the pretrained generative model to generate source-style target domain images, which are then segmented using the pretrained segmentation network. Experiments on various public datasets demonstrate that LowBridge achieves state-of-the-art performance, outperforming ten existing approaches. Ablation studies further show that LowBridge is compatible with different types of generative and segmentation models, suggesting its generalizability and potential to benefit from future advances in these models. The code will be available at https://github.com/JoshuaLPF/LowBridge.

eess.IV↗

Revolutionizing Diffusion MRI Microstructure Mapping via Global Inversion

Diffusion MRI microstructure mapping (MM) is conventionally solved voxel by voxel, ignoring the fact that tissue microstructure forms a spatially organized field. This isolation leaves each estimation problem ill-posed and nonconvex. We instead cast MM as a single global inverse problem, reconstructing the entire parameter field jointly from all measurements of a subject. An untrained neural representation supplies implicit spatial priors and eases the nonconvex optimization, requiring no training data, while coregistered T1-weighted anatomy contributes structural guidance that is freely available in standard protocols. On both synthetic and in-vivo data, our method compares favorably with established voxel-wise and learning-based baselines, suggesting global inversion is a promising alternative.

eess.IV↗

LC3EM: Long-Range Context Extrapolation Enhanced Entropy Model for Coordinate-based Overfitting Image Codecs

Coordinate-based overfitting image codecs have attracted increasing attention for their low decoding complexity and independence from cross-image generalization. However, representative approaches such as COOL-CHIC face an inherent entropy-modeling trade-off: lightweight models have limited capacity, while more expressive ones incur additional bitrate overhead from transmitting image-specific parameters. Inspired by the prediction mechanism in traditional codecs, we propose a new entropy-modeling strategy that introduces complementary prediction modes with region-adaptive soft mode selection, rather than relying on a single learned predictor to model diverse types of redundancy. Based on this concept, we develop a Long-Range Context Extrapolation Enhanced Entropy Model (LC3EM), which can be integrated into coordinate-based overfitting codecs. Specifically, a parameter-free Neighborhood-based Linear Extrapolation Mode (NLEM) complements the tiny MLP-based local predictor to exploit long-range contextual redundancy and strongly directional structures. A Minimum-Entropy-Inspired Continuous Mode Selection strategy is designed to adaptively fuse these two complementary modes, while requiring the transmission of only the parameters of a single additional linear layer. Moreover, to alleviate the mismatch between training-time relaxed and actual discrete quantization, we introduce a lightweight iterative latent rounding refinement stage to improve compression performance. Experiments demonstrate consistent improvements across diverse benchmarks, particularly on highly regular computer-generated images. When integrated with COOL-CHIC 4.0, the proposed method achieves BD-rate gains of -3.43\% and -7.69\% on the SIQAD and API datasets, respectively. With COOL-CHIC 5.0 as the backbone, the corresponding gains are -2.88\% and -3.15\%, respectively. The code will be made publicly available soon.

eess.IV↗