Price Formation in Field Prediction Markets: the Wisdom in the Crowd

Frederik Bossaerts; Nitin Yadav; Peter Bossaerts; Chad Nash; Torquil Todd; Torsten Rudolf; Rowena Hutchins; Anne-Louise Ponsonby; Karl Mattingly

arXiv · 2209.08778

Price Formation in Field Prediction Markets: the Wisdom in the Crowd

Frederik Bossaerts·Nitin Yadav·Peter Bossaerts·Chad Nash·Torquil Todd·Torsten Rudolf·Rowena Hutchins·Anne-Louise Ponsonby·Karl Mattingly

View original source ↗Read source document ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

Prediction markets are a popular, prominent, and successful structure for a collective intelligence platform. However the exact mechanism by which information known to the participating traders is incorporated into the market price is unknown. Kyle (1985) detailed a model for price formation in continuous auctions with information distributed heterogeneously amongst market participants. This paper demonstrates a novel method derived from the Kyle model applied to data from a field experiment prediction market. The method is able to identify traders whose trades have price impact that adds a significant amount of information to the market price. Traders who are not identified as informed in aggregate have price impact consistent with noise trading. Results are reproduced on other prediction market datasets. Ultimately the results provide strong evidence in favor of the Kyle model in a field market setting, and highlight an under-discussed advantage of prediction markets over alternative group forecasting mechanisms: that the operator of the market does not need to have information on the distribution of information amongst participating traders.

Explore related subjects

q-fin.PR q-fin.TR

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeX RIS

Frederik Bossaerts, Nitin Yadav, Peter Bossaerts, Chad Nash, Torquil Todd, Torsten Rudolf, Rowena Hutchins, Anne-Louise Ponsonby, Karl Mattingly. 2022-09-19. Price Formation in Field Prediction Markets: the Wisdom in the Crowd. https://arxiv.org/abs/2209.08778

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related papers

arXiv2026

Fundamentals of Perpetual Futures

Perpetual futures are the most popular cryptocurrency derivatives. Perpetuals offer leveraged exposure to their underlying without rollover or direct ownership. Unlike fixed-maturity futures, perpetuals are not guaranteed to converge to the spot price. To minimize the gap between perpetual and spot prices, long investors periodically pay shorts a funding rate proportional to this difference. We derive no-arbitrage prices for perpetual futures in frictionless markets and bounds in markets with trading costs. Empirically, deviations from these prices in crypto are larger than in traditional currency markets, comove across currencies, and diminish over time. An implied arbitrage strategy yields high Sharpe ratios.

q-fin.PR↗

arXiv2026

A deep learning approach for pricing convertible bonds with path-dependent reset and call provisions

This paper develops a deep learning framework for pricing convertible bonds with path-dependent downward reset and issuer call provisions governed by rolling-window triggers. We formulate the valuation problem as a path-dependent partial differential equation (PPDE) that captures both the historical stock-price path and the evolution of the conversion price. Model-specific PPDEs are derived under GBM, CEV, and Heston dynamics. Under suitable conditions, we establish the existence and uniqueness of a piecewise viscosity solution linked by contractual transmission conditions at monitoring dates. For computation, we construct a fixed-grid backward dynamic programming scheme and approximate its conditional expectations using neural networks, with $L^2$ convergence to the exact fixed-grid recursion as the approximation errors vanish. An application to the China CITIC Bank Convertible Bond produces stable prices across the three models and close agreement with the LSMC benchmark, but outperforms in dimensional scaling. The results show that contractual provisions have a greater valuation effect than the choice of underlying dynamics. The call provision reduces the bond value by truncating upside gains, whereas the downward reset provision increases it under the benchmark specification because improved conversion terms dominate the effect of earlier redemption. Delta and Gamma obtained by automatic differentiation of smooth local network approximations closely agree with central finite-difference estimates. The framework provides a flexible approach to pricing and sensitivity analysis for convertible bonds with complex path-dependent provisions.

q-fin.PR↗

arXiv2026

Confidence intervals for empirical convergence rates of randomised quasi-Monte Carlo, with applications to option pricing

Empirical comparisons of quasi-Monte Carlo rules often report fitted convergence exponents without intervals. We estimate the root mean square error from independent randomisations, fit its log slope over a declared sample-size window, and resample whole randomisations to construct an interval. For a fixed window, we establish asymptotic validity under finite fourth moments and a positive limiting variance. We measure coverage of four interval constructions on integrands with known exponents. With Gaussian errors, all four are compatible with nominal coverage at 128 and 512 randomisations, and jackknife-$t$ already at 32. All four undercover for the two higher-kurtosis families even at 512 randomisations. For differences between slopes, including null and small effects, preserving the dependence between paired randomisations can greatly narrow intervals, but it does not ensure nominal coverage. In option pricing, a steeper slope and a smaller error at a fixed budget can rank rules differently. Preintegration lowers a digital Asian option's exponent by about 0.5 in every tested window. For a barrier option it reduces the error six- to ninefold while changing the exponent by less than four hundredths. An arithmetic basket's gain grows with sample size. A geometric basket remains a ridge function as assets are added, limiting its use as a dimension benchmark. For multi-asset Asian options, different bases within a degenerate PCA eigenspace can change the measured exponent, in a direction that depends on the payoff.

q-fin.PR↗