Search arXiv⌕ Search
Home/Archive/arXiv

arXiv · 2210.04867

Contra-Analysis: Prioritizing Meaningful Effect Size in Scientific Research

Bruce A. Corliss·Yaotian Wang·Heman Shakeri·Philip E. Bourne
View original source ↗Read source document ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

At every phase of scientific research, scientists must decide how to allocate limited resources to pursue the research inquiries with the greatest potential. This prioritization dictates which controlled interventions are studied, awarded funding, published, reproduced with repeated experiments, investigated in related contexts, and translated for societal use. There are many factors that influence this decision-making, but interventions with larger effect size are often favored because they exert the greatest influence on the system studied. To inform these decisions, scientists must compare effect size across studies with dissimilar experiment designs to identify the interventions with the largest effect. These studies are often only loosely related in nature, using experiments with a combination of different populations, conditions, timepoints, measurement techniques, and experiment models that measure the same phenomenon with a continuous variable. We name this assessment contra-analysis and propose to use credible intervals of the relative difference in means to compare effect size across studies in a meritocracy between competing interventions. We propose a data visualization, the contra plot, that allows scientists to score and rank effect size between studies that measure the same phenomenon, aid in determining an appropriate threshold for meaningful effect, and perform hypothesis tests to determine which interventions have meaningful effect size. We illustrate the use of contra plots with real biomedical research data. Contra-analysis promotes a practical interpretation of effect size and facilitates the prioritization of scientific research.

Explore related subjects

stat.MEq-bio.QM

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

Bruce A. Corliss, Yaotian Wang, Heman Shakeri, Philip E. Bourne. 2022-10-10. Contra-Analysis: Prioritizing Meaningful Effect Size in Scientific Research. https://arxiv.org/abs/2210.04867

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related papers

arXiv2026

Switchback Experiments under Geometric Mixing

The switchback is an experimental design that measures treatment effects by repeatedly turning an intervention on and off for a whole system. Switchback experiments are a robust way to overcome cross-unit spillover effects; however, they are vulnerable to bias from temporal carryovers. In this paper, we consider properties of switchback experiments in Markovian systems that mix at a geometric rate. We find that, in this setting, standard switchback designs suffer considerably from carryover bias: Their estimation error decays as $T^{-1/3}$ in terms of the experiment horizon $T$, whereas in the absence of carryovers a faster rate of $T^{-1/2}$ would have been possible. We also show, however, that judicious use of burn-in periods can considerably improve the situation, and enables errors that decay as $\log(T)^{1/2}T^{-1/2}$. Our formal results are mirrored in an empirical evaluation.

stat.ME↗
arXiv2026

Saddlepoint approximations for plug-in resampling

Resampling-based procedures can improve on normal approximations in sparse, large-scale testing problems, but their computational cost can be prohibitive. We recognize that several existing procedures belong to a faster plug-in resampling subclass, fixing fitted nuisance parameters during resampling. When the resampled statistic is a sum of conditionally independent terms, the saddlepoint approximation (SPA) for the resampling $p$-value offers further acceleration, replacing resampling with an analytical tail approximation. However, standard Edgeworth-based approximation-error bounds impose regularity conditions that are hard to verify for plug-in resampling laws. We use an alternative approach to establish a finite-sample relative-error bound for the Lugannani-Rice approximation under more tractable conditions, which we apply in two contexts. In statistical genetics, we identify response resampling procedures as the targets of existing SPAs and establish guarantees in a representative setting. In conditional independence testing, we introduce spaCRT, an SPA for the distilled conditional randomization test (dCRT), which has been applied successfully in biology. Our rates quantify the effects of sparsity and signal strength, with matching lower bounds in special cases. We additionally establish asymptotic Type-I error control of the corresponding plug-in resampling procedures under growing sparsity. In simulations and single-cell CRISPR data analysis, spaCRT closely approximates dCRT $p$-values and preserves its statistical performance while accelerating computation by up to 250-fold.

stat.ME↗
arXiv2026

NIRVAR: Network Informed Restricted Vector Autoregression

High-dimensional panels of time series often arise in finance and macroeconomics, where co-movements within groups of panel components occur. Extracting these groupings from the data provides a coarse-grained description of the complex system in question and can inform subsequent prediction tasks. We develop a novel methodology to model such a panel as a restricted vector autoregressive process, where the coefficient matrix is the weighted adjacency matrix of a stochastic block model. This network time series model, which we call the Network Informed Restricted Vector Autoregression (NIRVAR) model, yields a coefficient matrix that has a sparse block-diagonal structure. We propose an estimation procedure that embeds each panel component in a low-dimensional latent space and clusters the embedded points to recover the blocks of the coefficient matrix. Crucially, the method allows for network-based time series modelling when the underlying network is unobserved. We derive the bias, consistency and asymptotic normality of the NIRVAR estimator. Simulation studies suggest that the NIRVAR estimated embedded points are Gaussian distributed around the ground truth latent positions. On three applications to finance, macroeconomics, and transportation systems, NIRVAR outperforms competing models in terms of prediction and provides interpretable results regarding group recovery.

stat.ME↗