Search arXiv⌕ Search
Home/Archive/arXiv

arXiv · 2210.09651

Comparison of Popular Video Conferencing Apps Using Client-side Measurements on Different Backhaul Networks

Rohan Kumar·Dhruv Nagpal·Vinayak Naik·Dipanjan Chakraborty
View original source ↗Read source document ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

Video conferencing platforms have been appropriated during the COVID-19 pandemic for different purposes, including classroom teaching. However, the platforms are not designed for many of these objectives. When users, like educationists, select a platform, it is unclear which platform will perform better given the same network and hardware resources to meet the required Quality of Experience (QoE). Similarly, when developers design a new video conferencing platform, they do not have clear guidelines for making design choices given the QoE requirements. In this paper, we provide a set of networks and systems measurements, and quantitative user studies to measure the performance of video conferencing apps in terms of both, Quality of Service (QoS) and QoE. Using those metrics, we measure the performance of Google Meet, Microsoft Teams, and Zoom, which are three popular platforms in education and business. We find a substantial difference in how the three apps treat video and audio streams. We see that their choice of treatment affects their consumption of hardware resources. Our quantitative user studies confirm the findings of our quantitative measurements. While each platform has its benefits, we find that no app is ideal. A user can choose a suitable platform depending on which of the following, audio, video, or network bandwidth, CPU, or memory are more important.

Explore related subjects

cs.MMcs.NI

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

Rohan Kumar, Dhruv Nagpal, Vinayak Naik, Dipanjan Chakraborty. 2022-10-18. Comparison of Popular Video Conferencing Apps Using Client-side Measurements on Different Backhaul Networks. https://doi.org/10.1145/3492866.3557734

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related papers

arXiv2026

Amanous: Distribution-Switching for Superhuman Piano Density on Disklavier

A player piano can strike more keys, across more of the register, and faster than any pianist can reach. Three traditions dominate composition in that region, namely Nancarrow's tempo canons, Xenakis' stochastic distributions, and L-system grammars. They have developed in isolation, and none of them accounts for the instrument itself. A Disklavier does not answer instantly, because a loud note reaches the string sooner than a soft one, so music written as if the mechanism were transparent arrives distorted. We present Amanous, a hardware-aware composition system for the Yamaha Disklavier that unifies the three traditions through distribution-switching, in which each grammar symbol selects an entire distributional regime rather than adjusting parameters within a fixed one. A four-layer pipeline carries a symbol from grammar to actuation-ready MIDI. An L-system fixes the macro-form, each symbol is mapped to distributions and a tempo-canon ratio, events are sampled and time-scaled, and a hardware layer pre-compensates velocity-dependent latency and enforces the key-reset time. Convergence points close a feedback loop, letting the music's own temporal structure trigger the next switch. Sections from different symbols remain statistically separable at the output, and ablating the L-system, the tempo canon, or the hardware compensation each degrades a distinct property. Under the modelled latency curve, pre-compensation takes the mean onset error from roughly 18 ms to below the instrument's 1 ms scanning resolution. Structured and random textures are most separable near 25 notes/s, and melodic metrics lose their discriminative power over the 40-100 notes/s band, above which the difference is consistent with distributional content rather than melodic order. All results are computational, nothing was played or measured on an instrument, and a psychoacoustic protocol is proposed for future work.

cs.MM↗
arXiv2026

If You Hear It, Help Find It: Orthogonal Knowledge Distillation for Open-Vocabulary Audio-Visual Event Localization

Open-vocabulary audio-visual event localization (OV-AVEL) grounds a text-queried event in time from video, audio, and language. The supervision sources available to this task can differ in temporal-boundary reliability: on OV-AVEBench, our configured visual teacher gives more reliable boundary cues than the configured audio teacher, although the latter is a strong pretrained audio model and remains semantically informative. This is a setting-specific diagnostic rather than a universal ranking of vision and audio. We formulate the resulting challenge as supervision placement: which teacher signals may shape the localization decision, and which should remain auxiliary. Based on this view, we propose OV-OrthKD, a reliability-aware asymmetric distillation framework. Visual feature transfer shapes a decision-aligned representation, audio feature transfer enriches a complementary auxiliary subspace, a text prototype anchors seen/unseen category semantics, and an orthogonality loss limits directional overlap between the two teacher-specific projections. The student continues to use both modalities through query-aware fusion at inference, while the default training recipe keeps audio-teacher supervision off the segment-logit path. On OV-AVEBench, OV-OrthKD achieves 0.816 segment AP and improves F1@0.5 over the official fine-tuning baseline by 2.7 points overall and 3.4 points on unseen categories. Path-assignment, role-swap, corruption, and transfer analyses consistently support supervision placement as a task-specific design axis for OV-AVEL.

cs.MM↗
arXiv2026

Adaptive Hierarchical Representation Alliance for Multimodal Learning

Multimodal models often align language, vision, and audio in a single final-layer latent space, implicitly assuming that task-relevant evidence emerges at the same semantic depth across modalities. Using layer-wise CKA analysis, we observe that this assumption leads to semantic granularity mismatch: textual cues usually require deeper contextual abstraction, whereas visual and acoustic cues often provide discriminative perceptual evidence in shallow or middle layers. This mismatch can flatten fine-grained modality-private cues and reduce reliability under noisy, imbalanced, or missing inputs. To address this, we proposed Adaptive Hierarchical Representation Alliance (AHRA), a hierarchical shared--private expert framework. AHRA factorizes each modality into shared and private streams across semantic levels, regularizes them with shared alignment and private decorrelation, routes shared information through a cross-modal expert, and enhances task-relevant private tokens with modality-specific experts guided by a sparsity-controlled soft-gating mechanism (foreground exam). A hierarchical co-fusion module then performs intra-level expert coordination and inter-level semantic selection. Experiments on six benchmarks across image-text classification, multimodal intent recognition, and trimodal sentiment analysis show that AHRA consistently improves over strong baselines and remains robust under noisy and missing-modality settings.

cs.MM↗