On Possible Indicators of Negative Selection in Germinal Centers

Abstract

A central feature of vertebrate immune response is affinity maturation, wherein antibody-producing B cells undergo evolutionary selection in microanatomical structures called germinal centers, which form in secondary lymphoid organs upon antigen exposure. While it has been shown that the median B cell affinity dependably increases over the course of maturation, the exact logic behind this evolution remains vague. Three potential selection methods include encouraging the reproduction of high affinity cells (``birth/positive selection''), encouraging cell death in low affinity cells (``death/negative selection''), and adjusting the mutation rate based on cell affinity (``mutational selection''). While all three forms of selection would lead to a net increase in affinity, different selection methods may lead to distinct statistical dynamics. We present a tractable model of selection, and analyze proposed signatures of negative selection. Given the simplicity of the model, such signatures should be stronger here than in real systems. However, we find a number of intuitively appealing metrics -- such as preferential ancestry ratios, terminal node counts, and mutation count skewness -- are all ill-suited for detecting selection method.