Search arXivSearch

arXiv · 2401.14186

Graph-accelerated Markov Chain Monte Carlo using Approximate Samples

Abstract

It has become increasingly easy nowadays to collect approximate posterior samples via fast algorithms such as variational Bayes, but concerns exist about the estimation accuracy. It is tempting to build solutions that exploit approximate samples in a canonical Markov chain Monte Carlo framework. A major barrier is that the approximate sample as a proposal tends to have a low Metropolis-Hastings acceptance rate, as the dimension increases. In this article, we propose a simple solution named graph-accelerated Markov Chain Monte Carlo. We build a graph with each node assigned to an approximate sample, then run Markov chain Monte Carlo with random walks over the graph. We optimize the graph edges to enforce small differences in posterior density/probability between nodes, while encouraging edges to have large distances in the parameter space. The graph allows us to accelerate a canonical Markov transition kernel through mixing with a large-jump Metropolis-Hastings step. The acceleration is easily applicable to existing Markov chain Monte Carlo algorithms. We theoretically quantify the rate of acceptance as dimension increases, and show the effects on improved mixing time. We demonstrate improved mixing performances for challenging problems, such as those involving multiple modes, non-convex density contour, or large-dimension latent variables.

Explore related subjects

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

Leo L. Duan, Anirban Bhattacharya. 2024-06-13. Graph-accelerated Markov Chain Monte Carlo using Approximate Samples. https://arxiv.org/abs/2401.14186

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related papers

Wasserstein mixing of a systematic-scan random rotation sampler

We study the mixing time of a systematic-scan analogue of Kac's walk that was proposed as a fast surrogate for Haar-distributed orthogonal matrices in randomized high-dimensional algorithms and was conjectured to approach Haar measure after only logarithmically many sweeps. We show that this conjectured speed-up does not occur for convergence of the full matrix law to Haar measure in Frobenius Wasserstein distance. At fixed normalized accuracy, the mixing time lies between order $n/\log n$ and order $n$ sweeps; at fixed absolute Frobenius accuracy, the corresponding bounds are between order $n$ and order $n\log n$. More strongly, below the scale $n/\log n$, the normalized Wasserstein distance remains asymptotically at its extremal value. We also show that the output law is singular with respect to Haar measure for fewer than $n/2$ sweeps. Thus the sampler may provide effective application-specific randomization without exhibiting the much faster full-Haar mixing.

stat.CO

Bayesian Calibration with Functional Outputs Using Elastic Partial Matching

Calibrating a simulation model involves estimating its parameters by comparing model outputs with experimental data, so that simulation results faithfully reproduce the experimental observations. When the outputs are functions of time, there are multiple ways to quantify the discrepancy between experimental and simulated curves. A recent approach based on elastic functional data analysis decomposes a functional output into two components: a function temporally aligned to a template, and the corresponding warping function. This decomposition splits the problem into two independent calibration tasks, thereby addressing functional misalignment. However, it assumes that experimental and simulated curves share the same temporal support, an assumption often violated in practice when initial or end times are themselves uncertain or depend on the calibration parameters. In this work, we reinterpret the decomposition step as an approximation to a more general Bayesian calibration problem that incorporates an error term on the time axis. This perspective allows us to naturally extend the framework to a broader family of time warpings with varying initial or end times, using partial elastic alignment. We illustrate the method on a synthetic test case, comparing it with existing Bayesian calibration methods and demonstrating improved surrogate performance and error modeling. We then apply the proposed approach to the calibration of an equation of state (a thermodynamic equation relating the state variables of a material).

stat.CO

Delayed Acceptance Slice Sampling

Slice sampling is a well-established Markov chain Monte Carlo method for approximate sampling of target distributions which are only known up to a normalizing constant. The method is based on choosing a new state on a slice, i.e., a superlevel set of the given unnormalized target density (with respect to a reference measure). However, slice sampling algorithms usually require per step multiple evaluations of the target density, and thus can become computationally expensive. This is particularly the case for Bayesian inference with costly likelihoods. In this paper, we exploit deterministic approximations of the target density, which are relatively cheap to evaluate, and propose delayed acceptance versions of several common (hybrid) slice samplers. We show ergodicity of the resulting slice sampling methods, discuss the superiority of delayed acceptance (ideal) slice sampling over delayed acceptance Metropolis-Hastings algorithms, and illustrate the benefits of our novel approach in terms of improved computational efficiency in numerical experiments.

stat.CO