Revisit the Partial Coloring Method: Prefix Spencer and Sampling

Abstract

As the most powerful tool in discrepancy theory, the partial coloring method has wide applications in many problems including the Beck-Fiala problem and Spencer's celebrated result. Currently, there are two major algorithmic methods for the partial coloring method: the first approach uses linear algebraic tools; and the second is called Gaussian measure algorithm. We explore the advantages of these two methods and show the following results for them separately. 1. Spencer conjectured that the prefix discrepancy of any $\mathbf{A} \in \{0,1\}^{m \times n}$ is $O(\sqrt{m})$. We show how to find a partial coloring with prefix discrepancy $O(\sqrt{m})$ and $Ω(n)$ entries in $\{ \pm 1\}$ efficiently. To the best of our knowledge, this provides the first partial coloring whose prefix discrepancy is almost optimal. However, unlike the classical discrepancy problem, there is no reduction on the number of variables $n$ for the prefix problem. By recursively applying partial coloring, we obtain a full coloring with prefix discrepancy $O(\sqrt{m} \cdot \log \frac{O(n)}{m})$. Prior to this work, the best bounds of the prefix Spencer conjecture for arbitrarily large $n$ were $2m$ and $O(\sqrt{m \log n})$. 2. Our second result extends the first linear algebraic approach to a sampling algorithm in Spencer's classical setting. On the first hand, Spencer proved that there are $1.99^m$ good colorings with discrepancy $O(\sqrt{m})$. Hence a natural question is to design efficient random sampling algorithms in Spencer's setting. On the other hand, some applications of discrepancy theory, prefer a random solution instead of a fixed one. Our second result is an efficient sampling algorithm whose random output has min-entropy $Ω(n)$ and discrepancy $O(\sqrt{m})$. Moreover, our technique extends the linear algebraic framework by incorporating leverage scores of randomized matrix algorithms.