Methodology of safety evaluation of In-Vessel Retention

Florian Fichot; Laure Carénini; Stephan Brumm; Marco Sangiorgi

Home/Archive/arXiv

arXiv · 2408.14522

Methodology of safety evaluation of In-Vessel Retention

Florian Fichot·Laure Carénini·Stephan Brumm·Marco Sangiorgi

View original source ↗Read source document ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

Molten corium stabilization following a severe accident is of crucial importance in order to ensure containment integrity on a long-term basis and minimizing radioactive elements releases outside the plant. Among the possible options, In-Vessel Retention (IVR) through external cooling appears as an attractive solution that would limit the dispersion of corium in the plant and minimize the risks of containment failure. Nevertheless its feasibility has to be proved.The IVR strategy is already adopted in Europe for some VVER 440 type 213 reactors thanks to thorough research work started in the '90s for the Finnish Loviisa power plant, and subsequently extended to Bohunice and Mochovce (Slovakia), Dukovany (Czech Republic) and Paks (Hungary) power plants. The strategy is also included in the design of some high power new Gen.III reactors such as AP1000, APR 1400 and Chinese HPR1000 and CAP1400. It has also been studied in the past for other reactor concepts like KERENA (1250 MWe - BWR), AP600 or VVER-640.Current approaches for reactors with relatively small power, such as VVER 440 or AP600, use conservative assumptions for the safety demonstration. However, for higher power reactors (around 1000 MWe), the safety margin is reduced and it is necessary to evaluate the IVR strategy with best-estimate methods in order to reduce the uncertainties associated with the involved phenomena. Additional R&D as well as a revision of the methodology are needed to ensure and demonstrate adequate safety margins, including, in particular, best-estimate evaluations of thermal load applied on the vessel and mechanical resistance of the ablated vessel.The IVMR project (In-Vessel Melt Retention) was built with the goal of providing new knowledge (experimental, theoretical and technical) and a new methodology able to provide a best-estimate evaluation of IVR strategy for large power reactors. The main objective of Task 2.1 within WP2 was to define a common methodology to analyse IVR Severe Accident Management (SAM) strategy for the different types of EU NPPs. It started by reviewing the status of existing methodology and aimed at elaborating a more general, updated and less conservative one applicable to several types of reactors.This paper describes the proposed new methodology. It starts with the identification of the deficiencies of the standard methodology when it is applied to a high power reactor. It introduces the minimum vessel thickness as a parameter representing the cumulated imbalance between internal heat load and external cooling. Then it explains how to use that parameter in the evaluation of the safety margin. Although some examples are given as illustrations, it must be kept in mind that this paper proposes a generic methodology but there cannot be any generic conclusion: any reactor design must be evaluated independently.

Explore related subjects

physics.med-ph

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeX RIS

Florian Fichot, Laure Carénini, Stephan Brumm, Marco Sangiorgi. 2024-08-26. Methodology of safety evaluation of In-Vessel Retention. https://arxiv.org/abs/2408.14522

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related papers

arXiv2026

A digital-twin framework for forecasting treatment-day imaging with contour uncertainty in adaptive proton radiotherapy

Head-and-neck anatomy changes over a six-to-seven-week proton course, and the anatomy of a later week cannot be imaged when the plan is made. We present a digital-twin framework that forecasts a patient's treatment-day anatomy as an ensemble of predicted CTs with propagated contours and quantifies the uncertainty of the forecast contours. The twin is a library of previously treated patients with planning and weekly quality-assurance CTs (QACTs), made patient-specific by a two-step foundation-model deformable registration: a cross-patient field carries each library patient onto the current patient, and a longitudinal field, estimated in the current patient's frame, carries that patient's planning-to-QACT change onto the current patient's own planning CT. A library of 302 observations from 88 patients yields about 300 replicates per patient, each a deformation that occurred in a treated patient. The dispersion of the propagated contours, resolved by outward normal, is six-direction contour uncertainty in millimeters. This is uncertainty in the input to the forecast, which library patient the current patient follows, rather than in model parameters, and it is unchanged when the registration engine is exchanged. On ten patients with clinician contours on two QACTs, the library alone fixes the anisotropic shape of the uncertainty (4.5 to 6.2 mm); the first QACT narrows it by a factor of 3.2 to 3.6 without a contour being drawn; an approved contour improves the center but not the width. The estimate orders directions correctly but is not Gaussian-calibrated. A clinical target volume expansion is worked out as one application.

physics.med-ph↗

arXiv2026

On phase aberration estimation using common mid-angle speckle correlations

Phase aberrations, despite degrading ultrasound images, also encode valuable information about the spatial distribution of the speed of sound in tissue. In pulse-echo ultrasound, we can quantify them by exploiting speckle correlations. Among existing strategies, correlations between steered acquisitions that share a common mid-angle have proven particularly effective for inferring the speed of sound. Their phases can be linearly related to the phase aberrations undergone by both the incident and reflected wavefronts. This relationship has so far been demonstrated only through geometric arguments based on point reflectors. Here, we develop a rigorous theoretical formalism that extends this relationship to the speckle regime, completing the previously established linear model and clarifying its underlying assumptions. More importantly, we build on this formalism to analyze correlation-phase fluctuations arising from aberration-induced speckle decorrelation. The analysis reveals that phase variance is governed by the relative loss of coherence, which increases approximately linearly with the square of the correlation phases. Local correlation-phase estimates therefore become increasingly uncertain as their magnitude grows. Experimental measurements in a uniform tissue-mimicking phantom show excellent agreement with the predicted variance. Beyond providing a theoretical basis for advancing speed-of-sound imaging, this formalism establishes the accuracy limit of common-mid-angle correlation phases, offering a benchmark for evaluating more advanced aberration-estimation techniques.

physics.med-ph↗

arXiv2026

Buccal-Lingual Analysis and Inflammation Tracking in Oral Soft Tissues Using Quantitative Ultrasound: A Preclinical Study

Four out of 10 adults aged 30 years or older in the USA are impacted by periodontal diseases which span a spectrum of inflammatory conditions. Currently, a subjective, invasive and a semi-quantitative approach, termed bleeding on probing, is employed in clinics for inflammation assessment. The long-term goal of this study is to fill the current clinical diagnostic gap in dentistry by proposing quantitative ultrasound (QUS)-based biomarkers for inflammation diagnosis and monitoring. Here, as one of the early works in this area, we investigated two QUS parameters for characterizing periodontal inflammation in gingival tissues using a longitudinal preclinical porcine study: attenuation coefficient slope (ACS) and backscatter intensity (BSI). Our study included eight pigs imaged intraorally (24 MHz) at four bi-weekly timepoints from week 0 (healthy) to week 6 (post inflammation inoculation) at their interproximal sites of the third premolars (PM3-Mes) from all quadrants. Moreover, we compared gingival tissues surrounding a tooth at lingual/palatal side versus buccal side at the second molar (M2-Dis) in healthy condition. Our results showed that gingival ACS at all inflammation timepoints were significantly lower than healthy gingival ACS (1.69 \pm 0.53 dB/cm.MHz) using a mixed effect analysis (week 6: 1.08 \pm 0.25 dB/cm.MHz). Longitudinal comparison of BSI did not demonstrate any statistical significance. Gingival ACS and BSI at lingual/palatal versus buccal sides of M2-Dis did not exhibit any statistical significance. These ACSs were linearly correlated with R-squared = 0.89 and a correlation slope of 0.87. For BSI, Bland-Altman analysis demonstrated no difference in mean BSI, although variability was high. These findings highlight the promising potential of ultrasonography paired with QUS to complement current standard of care in dentistry.

physics.med-ph↗