Search arXiv⌕ Search
Home/Archive/arXiv

arXiv · 2412.00280

Choosing Covariate Balancing Methods for Causal Inference: Practical Insights from a Simulation Study

Etienne Peyrot·Raphaël Porcher·Francois Petit
View original source ↗Read source document ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

Background: Inverse probability of treatment weighting (IPTW) is used for confounding adjustment in observational studies. Newer weighting methods include energy balancing (EB), kernel optimal matching (KOM), and tailored-loss covariate balancing propensity scores (TLF), but practical guidance remains limited. We evaluate their performance when implemented according to published recommendations. Methods: We conducted Monte Carlo simulations across 36 scenarios varying sample size, treatment prevalence, and a complexity factor increasing confounding and reducing overlap. Data generation used predominantly categorical covariates with some correlation. Average treatment effect and average treatment effect on the treated were estimated using IPTW, EB, KOM, and TLF combined with weighted least squares and, when supported, a doubly robust (DR) estimators. Inference followed published recommendations for each method when feasible, using standard alternatives otherwise. \textsc{PROBITsim} dataset used for illustration. Results: DR reduced sensitivity to the weighting scheme with an outcome regression adjusted for all confounders, despite functional-form misspecification. EB and KOM were most reliable; EB was tuning-free but scale dependent, whereas KOM required kernel and penalty choices. IPTW was variance sensitive when treatment prevalence was far from 50\%. TLF traded lower variance for higher bias, producing an RMSE plateau and sub-nominal confidence interval coverage. \textsc{PROBITsim} results mirrored these patterns. Conclusions: Rather than identifying a best method, our findings highlight failure modes and tuning choices to monitor. When the outcome regression adjusts for all confounders, DR estimation can be dependable across weighting schemes. Incorporating weight-estimation uncertainty into confidence intervals remains a key challenge for newer approaches.

Explore related subjects

stat.MEstat.AP

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

Etienne Peyrot, Raphaël Porcher, Francois Petit. 2026-01-14. Choosing Covariate Balancing Methods for Causal Inference: Practical Insights from a Simulation Study. https://arxiv.org/abs/2412.00280

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related papers

arXiv2026

Likelihood Based Inference in Fully and Partially Observed Exponential Family Graphical Models with Intractable Normalizing Constants

Probabilistic graphical models that encode an underlying Markov random field are fundamental building blocks of generative modeling to learn latent representations in modern multivariate data sets with complex dependency structures. Among these, the exponential family graphical models are especially popular, given their fairly well-understood statistical properties and computational scalability to high-dimensional data based on pseudo-likelihood methods. These models have been successfully applied in many fields, such as the Ising model in statistical physics and count graphical models in genomics. Another strand of models allows some nodes to be latent, so as to allow the marginal distribution of the observable nodes to depart from exponential family to capture more complex dependence. These approaches form the basis of generative models in artificial intelligence, such as the Boltzmann machines and their restricted versions. A fundamental barrier to likelihood-based (i.e., both maximum likelihood and fully Bayesian) inference in both fully and partially observed cases is the intractability of the likelihood. The usual workaround is via adopting pseudo likelihood-based approaches, following the pioneering work of Besag(1974). The goal of this paper is to demonstrate that full likelihood-based analysis of these models is feasible in a computationally efficient manner under a logarithmically sparse setting. The chief innovation lies in utilizing the tractable independence model underlying an intractable graphical model, to estimate the normalizing constant, as well as its gradient. Extensive numerical results, supporting theory and comparisons with pseudo likelihood-based approaches demonstrate the applicability of the proposed method.

stat.ME↗
arXiv2026

Interpretable Deep Neural Network for Modeling Functional Surrogates

Developing surrogates for computer models has become increasingly important for addressing complex problems in science and engineering. This article introduces an artificial intelligent (AI) surrogate, referred to as the DeepSurrogate, for analyzing functional outputs with vector-valued inputs. The relationship between the functional output and vector-valued input is modeled as an infinite sequence of unknown functions, each representing the relationship at a specific location within the functional domain. These spatially indexed functions are expressed through a combination of basis functions and their corresponding coefficient functions, both of which are modeled using deep neural networks (DNN). The proposed framework accounts for spatial dependencies across locations, while capturing the relationship between the functional output and scalar predictors. It also integrates a Monte Carlo (MC) dropout strategy to quantify prediction uncertainty, enhancing explainability in the deep neural network architecture. The proposed method enables efficient inference on datasets with approximately 50,000 spatial locations and 20 simulations, achieving results in under 10 minutes using standard hardware. The approach is validated on extensive synthetic datasets and a large-scale simulation from the Sea Lake and Overland Surge from Hurricanes (SLOSH) simulator. An open-source Python package implementing the method is made available.

stat.ME↗
arXiv2026

Deep Generative Modeling with Spatial and Network Images: An Explainable AI (XAI) Approach

This article addresses the challenge of modeling the amplitude of spatially indexed low frequency fluctuations (ALFF) in resting state functional MRI as a function of cortical structural features and a multi-task coactivation network in the Adolescent Brain Cognitive Development (ABCD) Study. It proposes a generative model that integrates effects of spatially-varying inputs and a network-valued input using deep neural networks to capture complex non-linear and spatial associations with the output. The method models spatial smoothness, accounts for subject heterogeneity and complex associations between network and spatial images at different scales, enables accurate inference of each images effect on the output image, and allows prediction with uncertainty quantification via Monte Carlo dropout, contributing to one of the first Explainable AI (XAI) frameworks for heterogeneous imaging data. The model is highly scalable to high-resolution data without the heavy pre-processing or summarization often required by Bayesian methods. Empirical results demonstrate its strong performance compared to existing statistical and deep learning methods. We applied the XAI model to the ABCD data which revealed associations between cortical features and ALFF throughout the entire brain. Our model performed comparably to existing methods in predictive accuracy but provided superior uncertainty quantification and faster computation, demonstrating its effectiveness for large-scale neuroimaging analysis. Open-source software in Python for XAI is available.

stat.ME↗