Niche Dynamics in Complex Online Community Ecosystems

Nathan TeBlunthuis

Home/Archive/arXiv

arXiv · 2504.02153

Niche Dynamics in Complex Online Community Ecosystems

Nathan TeBlunthuis

View original source ↗Read source document ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

Online communities are important organizational forms where members socialize and share information. Curiously, different online communities often overlap considerably in topic and membership. Recent research has investigated competition and mutualism among overlapping online communities through the lens of organizational ecology; however, it has not accounted for how the nonlinear dynamics of online attention may lead to episodic competition and mutualism. Neither has it explored the origins of competition and mutualism in the processes by which online communities select or adapt to their niches. This paper presents a large-scale study of 8,806 Reddit communities belonging to 1,919 clusters of high user overlap over a 5-year period. The method uses nonlinear time series methods to infer bursty, often short-lived ecological dynamics. Results reveal that mutualism episodes are longer lived and slightly more frequent than competition episodes. Next, it tests whether online communities find their niches by specializing to avoid competition using panel regression models. It finds that competitive ecological interactions lead to decreasing topic and user overlaps; however, changes that decrease such niche overlaps do not lead to mutualism. The discussion proposes that future designs may enable online community ecosystem management by informing online community leaders to organize "spin-off" communities or via feeds and recommendations.

Explore related subjects

cs.SI cs.CY cs.HC

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeX RIS

Nathan TeBlunthuis. 2025-04-14. Niche Dynamics in Complex Online Community Ecosystems. https://arxiv.org/abs/2504.02153

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related papers

arXiv2026

Detection and Characterization of Coordinated Online Behavior: A Survey

Coordination is a fundamental aspect of life. The advent of social media has made it integral also to online human interactions, such as those that characterize thriving online communities and social movements. At the same time, coordination is also core to effective disinformation, manipulation, and hate campaigns. This survey collects, categorizes, and critically discusses the body of work produced as a result of the growing interest on coordinated online behavior. We reconcile industry and academic definitions, propose a comprehensive framework to study coordinated online behavior, and review and critically discuss the existing detection and characterization methods. Our analysis identifies open challenges and promising directions of research, serving as a guide for scholars, practitioners, and policymakers in understanding and addressing the complexities inherent to online coordination. We also provide an interactive companion website for exploring the surveyed literature.

cs.SI↗

arXiv2026

The Game is the Game: Dynamic network analysis and shifting roles in criminal networks

Objectives: This paper incorporates time as a crucial variable to identify key players in criminal networks and explores how actors' positions change over time. It then assesses the accuracy of the results against the uncertainty around network data collected from criminal justice records. Methods: Network data are from a judicial document for a two-year investigation targeting a drug trafficking and distribution network. We use Katz centrality in its dynamic version to explore changes in relationships and relative importance of network actors. We then use a novel method of introducing new edges to the network using Bernoulli random trials to simulate missing data and assess the extent to which node rankings based on Katz centrality change or remain the same when introducing some level of uncertainty to our observed network. Results: We identify actors who consistently held a central role over the course of the two-year investigation and differentiate them from actors who provided key contributions to the group's activities, but only for a limited period. We show that compared to centrality measures commonly used in criminal network analysis, dynamic Katz centrality is helpful to differentiate individual contributions even among central nodes and explore individual trajectories over time, even when data are incomplete. Conclusions: This paper demonstrates the value of key player identification using temporal network data and offers an additional analytical tool to both organised crime scholars trying to capture the complex nature of criminal collaboration and law enforcement agencies aiming at identifying appropriate targets and disrupting criminal groups.

cs.SI↗

arXiv2026

Link prediction in complex networks via fusing node centrality and local similarity indices: a fair-protocol reassessment and parameter design principles

Local similarity indices assign zero scores to node pairs without common neighbors, which limits link prediction in sparse networks; fusing node centrality with local similarity is a common remedy, but existing fusion studies use heterogeneous protocols and the robustness of their gains is unclear. Within a unified piecewise fusion framework (multiplicative modulation when local information is sufficient, small-dose completion when it is absent), we show that the dynamic range of the centrality product governs the modulation mechanism: the PageRank product is of order O(n^-2), so its factor degenerates to a near-identity map. Under a fair protocol with exhaustive negative-sample comparison on eight real-world networks, PageRank fusion therefore yields no consistent significant gain for six of the seven local indices; its single exception, a gain of about +0.035 on the near-tree-like wiki-Vote network, comes entirely from completion, indicating that the completion gain depends on both the fraction of zero-score node pairs and the standalone predictive power of the centrality product. The min-max normalized DomiRank product, with an O(1) range, instead gives stable gains under unified parameters (modulation weight 5, completion coefficient 0.1): all seven fused indices improve significantly at the fold level (p <= 3.3e-3), and a 10x5 repeated cross-validation confirms robustness to the randomness of fold partitions. DR-RA reaches an average AUC of 0.9257, surpassing Katz, LNB, CN2D, CNC, CND, SimRank, CCPA, Gravity and CNPop, and comparable to RWR. The design rules obtained for the two mechanisms (completion coefficient at most 0.3, modulation weight in [0.5,12], competition intensity near critical) provide a reproducible protocol benchmark and quantitative parameter design principles for the centrality x local-similarity fusion paradigm.

cs.SI↗