On Solving the Dynamics of Constrained Rigid Multi-Body Systems with Kinematic Loops

Abstract

This technical report provides an in-depth evaluation of both established and state-of-the-art methods for simulating constrained rigid multi-body systems with hard-contact dynamics, using formulations of Nonlinear Complementarity Problems (NCPs). We are particularly interest in examining the simulation of highly coupled mechanical systems with multitudes of closed-loop bilateral kinematic joint constraints in the presence of additional unilateral constraints such as joint limits and frictional contacts with restitutive impacts. This work thus presents an up-to-date literature survey of the relevant fields, as well as an in-depth description of the approaches used for the formulation and solving of the numerical time-integration problem in a maximal coordinate setting. More specifically, our focus lies on a version of the overall problem that decomposes it into the forward dynamics problem followed by a time-integration using the states of the bodies and the constraint reactions rendered by the former. We then proceed to elaborate on the formulations used to model frictional contact dynamics and define a set of solvers that are representative of those currently employed in the majority of the established physics engines. A key aspect of this work is the definition of a benchmarking framework that we propose as a means to both qualitatively and quantitatively evaluate the performance envelopes of the set of solvers on a diverse set of challenging simulation scenarios. We thus present an extensive set of experiments that aim at highlighting the absolute and relative performance of all solvers on particular problems of interest as well as aggravatingly over the complete set defined in the suite.