Turing machines deciders, part I

Abstract

The Busy Beaver Challenge (or bbchallenge) aims at collaboratively solving the following conjecture: "$S(5) = 47{,}176{,}870$" [Radó, 1962], [Marxen and Buntrock, 1990], [Aaronson, 2020]. This conjecture says that if a 5-state Turing machine runs for more than 47,176,870 steps without halting, then it will never halt -- starting from the all-0 tape. Proving this conjecture amounts to deciding whether 181,385,789 Turing machines with 5 states halt or not -- starting from the all-0 tape [bbchallenge, 2025]. To do so, we write $\textit{deciders}$: programs that take as input a Turing machine and output either HALT, NONHALT, or UNKNOWN. Each decider is specialised in recognising a particular type of non-halting behavior. After two years of work, the Busy Beaver Challenge achieved its goal in July 2024 by delivering a proof of "$S(5) = 47{,}176{,}870$" formalised in Coq [bbchallenge, 2025]. In this document, we present deciders that were developed before the Coq proof and which were mainly not used in the proof; nonetheless, they are relevant techniques for analysing Turing machines. Part II of this work is the decider section of our paper showing "$S(5) = 47{,}176{,}870$" [bbchallenge, 2025], presenting the deciders that were used in the Coq proof.