Search arXiv⌕ Search
Home/Archive/arXiv

arXiv · 2510.15744

Cleaning up the Mess: Re-Evaluating the Real-System Modeling Accuracy of Ramulator 2.0

F. Nisa Bostanci·Haocong Luo·Ataberk Olgun·Maria Makeenkova·Geraldo F. Oliveira·A. Giray Yaglikci·Onur Mutlu
View original source ↗Read source document ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

A MICRO 2024 best paper runner-up publication (the Mess paper) with all three artifact badges awarded (including ``Reproducible'') proposes a new benchmark to evaluate real and simulated memory system performance. The publication contends that Ramulator 2.0 and DAMOV (ZSim+Ramulator) (along with other existing memory system simulators) ``poorly resemble the actual system performance'' and asserts that their simulator is better. In this paper, we show that the Mess paper has 1) demonstrable technical misconfigurations, 2) methodological errors in interpreting simulation statistics, and 3) an incomplete artifact that makes its key results irreproducible. We demonstrate that the Ramulator 2.0 simulation results reported in the Mess paper are incorrect due to multiple configuration errors instead of inherent simulation inaccuracy claimed by the Mess paper. We show that by correctly configuring Ramulator 2.0, Ramulator 2.0's simulated memory system performance actually resembles real system characteristics well, and thus a key claimed contribution of the Mess paper is factually incorrect. We also identify that the DAMOV simulation results in the Mess paper use wrong simulation statistics that are unrelated to the simulated DRAM performance. We show that DAMOV's simulated DRAM latency is not constant, in contrast to the Mess paper's claim. Moreover, the Mess paper's artifact repository lacks the necessary sources to fully reproduce all the Mess paper's results. We find that the experiment scripts use simulator executables and other resources that are neither described in the Mess paper nor found in the artifact repository. We strongly encourage the computer architecture community to consider our corrections to the Ramulator 2.0 and DAMOV results of the Mess paper to prevent the propagation of inaccurate and misleading results and to maintain the reliability of the scientific record.

Explore related subjects

cs.ARcs.PF

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

F. Nisa Bostanci, Haocong Luo, Ataberk Olgun, Maria Makeenkova, Geraldo F. Oliveira, A. Giray Yaglikci, Onur Mutlu. 2026-05-08. Cleaning up the Mess: Re-Evaluating the Real-System Modeling Accuracy of Ramulator 2.0. https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.15744

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related papers

arXiv2026

HLSmith: An Expert-Guided Agentic Framework for C/C++-to-HLS Translation

Application-specific FPGA accelerators offer substantial performance and energy-efficiency gains across many application domains, but developing them is costly, often requiring months of specialized effort. Even with high-level synthesis (HLS), designers still need extensive hardware expertise to build high-performance accelerators. Although large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated strong software-generation capabilities, even frontier models lack the hardware intuition and procedural knowledge needed to reliably translate baseline C/C++ programs into high-performance HLS designs: they struggle to identify effective architectures, follow the optimization processes used by HLS experts, and apply hardware transformations consistently across diverse kernels. We present HLSmith, an expert-guided framework for translating C/C++ programs into optimized HLS accelerators. HLSmith combines three components: an HLS optimization expertise library that encodes guarded transformation recipes, their applicability and prerequisite conditions, and unsafe cases to avoid; a staged, feedback-driven orchestration flow modeled on expert HLS development practice that guides agents through synthesis, bottleneck analysis, and optimization; and a tool-grounded model-adaptation pipeline that converts optimization trajectories from commercial frontier models into training data for fine-tuning open-weight LLMs. We evaluate HLSmith on PolyBench against ChatHLS, a leading prior agent-orchestration framework for HLS accelerator development. HLSmith achieves a geometric mean speedup of 4.24x over ChatHLS while producing functionally correct designs, in both software and RTL simulation, for every benchmark, compared with ChatHLS's 57% valid-design rate. It further reaches speedups of up to 252x and 138x with commercial frontier models and open-weight models, respectively.

cs.AR↗
arXiv2026

Accelerating the Mitigation of LLM Inference Nondeterminism Across GPU Architectures

Large language model (LLM) outputs are expected to be reproducible under greedy decoding, yet in practice the same model, prompt, and software stack produce different outputs on different GPUs. The root cause is floating-point non-associativity combined with hardware-dependent kernel selection. Inference frameworks select different matrix-multiplication kernels on each architecture, with different parallel reduction orders and unspecified tensor-core arithmetic, and the resulting rounding differences can flip output tokens. Existing solutions have imperfect cross-architecture reproducibility and incur a significant performance penalty. We present a solution employing a set of fixed-configuration fused-upcast GEMM kernels that load 16-bit weights from memory, upcast them to FP32 in registers, and accumulate with IEEE-754 arithmetic in a reduction order that is a pure function of the problem shape and is therefore independent of the device, its SM count, or kernel scheduling. By fixing the floating-point reduction order as a function of problem shape alone, every GPU runs the same operation sequence, so cross-architecture reproducibility of the linear layers reduces to correct IEEE-754 arithmetic rather than to rounding differences staying below a tie-flip threshold. We confirm our solution's linear-layer outputs are bitwise identical across NVIDIA Ampere, Ada, and Hopper GPUs, while running $1.17$ to $3.1\times$ faster end-to-end than the state-of-the-art solution and cutting weight-memory traffic in half.

cs.AR↗
arXiv2026

Decoupling Logical Masks from GPU Execution for Dynamic Block-Sparse Attention

Attention computation makes inference expensive in video diffusion transformers (vDiTs), which generate videos through iterative denoising. Block-sparse attention (BSA) reduces this cost by computing only blocks selected by a logical mask, which specifies attention interactions to compute. However, coupling logical block geometry to execution choices limits adaptation to varying masks and graphics processing units (GPUs), while runtime kernel specialization can incur preparation overhead that outweighs execution time savings. We present Tessera, a specialized runtime for dynamic BSA that decouples logical masks from GPU execution while preserving specified attention interactions. Its physical mapping layer retains, combines, or subdivides logical attention blocks into physical tiles suited to different attention mask shapes and GPU architectures. Its task organization layer groups and schedules tiles within GPU tasks to reuse data, expose parallelism, and overlap data movement with computation. Finally, profile-guided regime selection enables low- overhead execution plan selection through a lookup table constructed from offline profiling. We implement Tessera with specialized CUDA kernels supporting four NVIDIA GPU generations. Evaluated on 2,315 real attention masks and industrial video diffusion models, Tessera achieves up to 6.79x BSA request speedup over baseline systems in the evaluated video diffusion models.

cs.AR↗