Search arXivSearch

arXiv · 2511.07866

Symmetric Iterations with Countable and $<κ$-Support: A Framework for Choiceless ZF Extensions

Abstract

This replacement corrects the earlier manuscript. Its claimed general countable- and $<κ$-support iteration framework does not establish the advertised preservation or application theorems. The proposed limit filters can be improper; the dependent-choice arguments pass incorrectly from ground-model sequences of hereditarily symmetric names to arbitrary sequences in a generic extension; the class-length union argument does not verify Separation, Replacement, or Power Set; the Partition Principle argument uses an invalid same-generic compatibility inference; and the singular-support fusion argument assumes that a coherent inverse-limit family is a condition even when its support may have size $κ$. Accordingly, the main preservation, construction, class-length, dependent-choice, Partition Principle, and singular-cardinal claims are withdrawn. We retain only several conditional algebraic observations: pullback and completion operations on subgroup filters, closure of ground-model families of hereditarily symmetric names under canonical tupling, the standard ZF theorem for a genuine symmetric system, and ordinary conditional tail-closure facts. The remainder is preserved as a historical record of the superseded approach and is not asserted.

Explore related subjects

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

Frank Gilson. 2026-09-11. Symmetric Iterations with Countable and $<κ$-Support: A Framework for Choiceless ZF Extensions. https://arxiv.org/abs/2511.07866

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related papers

Loops, Inverse Limits and Non-Determinism

We introduce an operator on problems in Weihrauch complexity, which we call the infinite loop or inverse limit, and which corresponds to an infinite compositional product. This operation arises naturally whenever one implements algorithms that produce a sequence of results in an infinite loop, using some fixed subroutine. We prove that the corresponding operator is monotone with respect to (strong) Weihrauch reducibility but that it is not a closure operator. One of our findings is that weak Kőnig's lemma is closed under infinite loops, which implies that the class of non-deterministically computable problems is also closed under this operation. Consequently, this class allows for a high degree of flexibility in programming. As our main technical tools, we present an injective version of the recursion theorem and an infinitary version of the so-called independent choice theorem. We also show that, in general, the infinite loop operator is more powerful than the composition of the diamond operator followed by the parallelization operator. However, in many practical scenarios, these compositions yield a result, which coincides with the application of the infinite loop operator. Finally, we discuss the special situation of loops for single-valued problems and for problems on Turing degrees.

math.LO

Scott topologies on meet-continuous domains

We study Scott products and sobriety of countable meet-continuous domains, meaning meet-continuous dcpos without any additional continuity or least-element assumption. Using the complete-lattice test-family theorem of Xu and Ji, we prove finite-product equality for those domains that are $L$-dcpos, and for the weaker class whose principal ideals have suprema of all nonempty subsets. For an arbitrary family of nonempty countable meet-continuous $L$-dcpos, we prove that the Scott topology on the order product equals the product of the factor Scott topologies if and only if only finitely many factors lack a least element. We also establish sobriety under bounded completeness and under additional common-upper-bound conditions. Assuming square-product equality, sobriety is characterized by Scott closedness of common-upper-bound sections associated with irreducible Scott-closed sets, with an equivalent sequential formulation in the countable case. Two extraction lemmas extend to meet-semilattice dcpos. The finite-product and sobriety questions for general countable meet-continuous domains remain unresolved here.

math.LO

Randomized Borel $(2d+1)$-coloring of digraphs

Let $G$ be a Borel digraph with maximum out-degree $d \in \mathbb{N}$. We show that $G$ admits a random Borel $(2d+1)$-coloring for which every edge is almost surely not monochromatic. This gives a simpler proof of a recent result of Pelayo-Gómez: such a graph $G$ admits a measurable proper $(2d+1)$-coloring with respect to any Borel probability measure on $V(G)$. Our proof is an adaptation of Pelayo-Gómez's proof to the randomized Borel setting.

math.LO