Little Red and Blue Dots: simply stratified Broad Line Regions

Abstract

It has been claimed that a fraction of the so-called Little Red Dots (LRDs) are characterised by exponential broad line profiles, which have been ascribed to broadening from electron scattering by an ionised cocoon. In this work, we investigate the H$α$ broad line profiles of 32 AGN, including Little Red Dots (LRDs), Little Blue Dots (LBDs), and X-ray detected sources, using high SNR and resolution spectroscopy. We find that while single Gaussian models are statistically rejected, the exponential model is not universally preferred. Lorentzian and multi-Gaussian profiles provide equally good or superior fits for the majority of the sample, with no statistical preference for exponential profiles in $\sim$60% of cases across all AGN subtypes. There are indications that exponential profiles are preferred more frequently among LBDs, indicating that exponential profiles are not a prerogative of LRDs, which actually seem to more often favour Lorentzian profiles. Furthermore, we demonstrate that exponential wings can emerge naturally from the stratification of BLR clouds in virial motion, without invoking any scattering process. More generally, we also show that stacking multiple broad lines (either from multiple objects, as done in previous works, or from different BLR components within the same object) generally yields an exponential profile, even if none of the individual profiles are exponential. Explaining the exponential profiles in terms of BLR stratification solves various observational tensions with the electron scattering interpretation. While electron scattering may play a role, there is no evidence that it dominates the line profiles and that it significantly affects the inferred black hole masses.