Memory-Centric Computing: Security Benefits and Challenges of Processing-in-DRAM

Abstract

Today's computing systems are processor-centric: they require frequent data movement between processing elements (e.g., CPU) and main memory (DRAM), leading to significant inefficiencies in performance and energy consumption. Memory-centric computing instead moves computation to the data, enabling computation capability in and near all places where data is generated and stored, and greatly reducing the performance and energy overheads of data access and data movement. This shift from a processor-centric to a memory-centric paradigm has important and underexplored consequences for system security. Turning memory from a dumb, inactive store into an active computing substrate introduces benefits as well as challenges for system security: it can provide new in-memory security primitives and also reduce data exposure, but it can also expose new attack surfaces. This work discusses the security benefits and challenges of memory-centric computing, specifically Processing-in-DRAM (PiD), a paradigm where the operational characteristics of a DRAM chip are exploited and enhanced to perform computation on data stored in DRAM. Specifically, we describe 1) new state-of-the-art DRAM-based true random number generators that provide up to 16.05 Gb/s throughput and physical unclonable functions with 5.75% lower evaluation latency than the prior state-of-the-art, both on real DRAM chips and 2) two key security challenges of PiD: amplified DRAM read disturbance (e.g., 158x reduction in the minimum number of DRAM accesses required to induce the first bitflip) and high throughput memory timing channels (e.g., a communication throughput of 14.8Mb/s). We believe it is time to design, use, and program DRAM, and in general memory, not as an inactive storage substrate, but as a combined computation, storage, and security substrate, where computational capability, storage density, and security are all key goals.