A Structural Characterization of Entropy Functionals

Abstract

Entropy functionals and their associated divergences underlie many statistical methods, including maximum entropy inference, minimum divergence estimation, and goodness-of-fit testing, yet choosing among Shannon, Rényi, Tsallis, and more general entropies is often a matter of convention rather than structural principle. We introduce a measure theoretic framework in which admissibility requires the entropy of an input measure to be bounded above by that of its reference measure whenever the former is absolutely continuous with respect to the latter. Under generalized mean-value composition, we characterize all such entropy functionals and obtain a four-level hierarchy determined successively by the mean generator, entropy scale, and additivity assumptions. A continuous strictly monotone generator $g$ is admissible exactly when $t\mapsto g(1/t)$ is strictly convex for increasing $g$, or strictly concave for decreasing $g$. This resolves a question posed by Rényi (Proc. 4th Berkeley Sympos. Math. Statist. Prob., 1961) concerning which generalized means may replace the arithmetic mean in his entropy axiomatization. The same criterion is equivalent to strict convexity of an associated Csiszár $f$-divergence generator and therefore yields data processing under Markov kernels with an exact equality condition. Within this hierarchy, product additivity singles out the Rényi family, while internal additivity, or product additivity together with arithmetic mean-value composition, singles out Shannon entropy. The characterization is constructive and yields new admissible entropy and divergence families, including integral-transform examples.