Search arXiv⌕ Search
Home/Archive/arXiv

arXiv · 2609.30359

Comment on "Note on the start-up of Couette flow for viscoelastic fluids" [Phys. Fluids 35, 113108 (2023)]

Ivan C. Christov
View original source ↗Read source document ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

I show that the initial conditions imposed by Balan [Phys. Fluids 35, 113108 (2023)] are incompatible with a nonzero retardation time, so that the problem solved is not impulsive start-up, but, as I prove exactly, the start-up of a plate ramped as $1 - \mathrm{e}^{-t/λ_2}$ on the retardation timescale $λ_2$ (a material parameter, not a setting in a rheometer). Values digitized from that paper's viscoelastic figures fall on the ramped-plate solution, not on Tanner's start-up solution. The large negative wall normal stress reported for the corotational model is a grid-dependent artifact due to the same error in the initial data. An open-source code repository provides annotated notebooks reproducing every figure and number in this Comment.

Explore related subjects

physics.flu-dyncond-mat.soft

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

Ivan C. Christov. 2026-09-28. Comment on "Note on the start-up of Couette flow for viscoelastic fluids" [Phys. Fluids 35, 113108 (2023)]. https://arxiv.org/abs/2609.30359

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related papers

arXiv2026

Adjoint-based shape optimization of a ship hull using a Conditional Variational Autoencoder (CVAE) assisted propulsion surrogate model

Adjoint-based shape optimization of ship hulls is a powerful tool for addressing high-dimensional design problems in naval architecture, particularly in minimizing the ship resistance. However, its application to vessels that employ complex propulsion systems introduces significant challenges. They arise from the need for transient simulations extending over long periods of time with small time steps and from the reverse temporal propagation of the primal and adjoint solutions. These challenges place considerable demands on the required storage and computing power, which significantly hamper the use of adjoint methods in the industry. To address this issue, we propose a machine learning-assisted optimization framework that employs a Conditional Variational Autoencoder-based surrogate model of the propulsion system. The surrogate model replicates the time-averaged flow field induced by a Voith Schneider Propeller and replaces the geometrically and time-resolved propeller with a data-driven approximation. Primal flow verification examples demonstrate that the surrogate model achieves significant computational savings while maintaining the necessary accuracy of the resolved propeller. Optimization studies demonstrate that neglecting the propulsion system can result in hull designs whose performance is inferior to that of the initial shape when subsequently validated using a numerically resolved propulsor. In contrast, the proposed method produces shapes that actually achieve more than an 8% reduction in resistance.

physics.flu-dyn↗
arXiv2026

Control of deterministic breakdown to turbulence of hypersonic boundary layer with spanwise non-uniform surface temperature

Direct Numerical Simulation (DNS) of a Mach 6 boundary layer over a flat plate is performed to assess the effect of spanwise non-uniform surface temperature on breakdown to turbulence under deterministic forcing. The streamwise location of laminar to turbulent transition in hypersonic boundary layers has a significant influence on viscous drag and aerodynamic heating of external surfaces of hypersonic vehicles. Previous work investigated the stabilization of hypersonic boundary layers by optimally growing streaks. More recently, DNS for a hypersonic boundary layer showed that it is possible to generate streaks through a spanwise non-uniform surface temperature distribution. The laminar computations showed the control method can stabilize the second Mack mode and it is robust across a range of Mach numbers and wall temperature ratios. In this work, two scenarios are investigated where two-dimensional (second Mack mode) and oblique (first Mack mode) disturbances dominate the initial linear stage of transition. It is found that weak control streaks with amplitude below 5% of the freestream velocity can reduce high-frequency shear-stress due to the second Mack mode by approximately 30% relative to the uncontrolled configuration, and delay transition. For first Mack mode dominated breakdown, the control streaks have no effect on transition location, but the peak amplitude of the spanwise-integrated wall heat flux is reduced. For the first and second Mack mode-dominated scenarios, the mean and high-frequency peak heat transfer are reduced approximately by 15% and 34%, respectively. The dominant mechanisms are identified and attributed to the pressure work contribution to turbulent kinetic energy and the second Mack mode dilatation work.

physics.flu-dyn↗
arXiv2026

On the Rayleigh-Taylor instability of a diffuse interface

We present a formulation for the linear stability of the miscible Rayleigh-Taylor instability, retaining viscosity, Fickian mass diffusion, and non-Boussinesq effects. Rather than adopting the diffusive corrections of Duff, Harlow, and Hirt (1962) or relying on the viscous eigenvalue problem of Chandrasekhar (1961), the present formulation is derived directly from the incompressible variable-density governing equations. Both approaches are recovered as limiting cases, extending Morgan, Likhachev, and Jacobs (2016). The governing equations admit a time-evolving self-similar diffusive base state in which an error-function density profile is accompanied by a nonzero vertical base velocity required by the non-solenoidal constraint. Linearization yields a reduced coupled formulation for the vertical velocity and density perturbations, suitable for both theoretical analysis and computation. Within the quasi-steady-state approximation, we show that the formulation reduces, in the infinite-Schmidt-number limit, to the classical viscous immiscible theory and recovers the Chandrasekhar eigenvalue problem. At finite Schmidt number, diffusion alters the growth-rate spectrum and its high-wavenumber structure. Beyond the spectral cutoff we establish the scaling $ω_r \sim -λ_m k^2$, where $λ_m$ is determined by the competition between the locally stratified kinematic viscosity and the reference diffusive scale. By isolating the effect of diffusion, we show that its stabilizing influence weakens with increasing density stratification. Buoyancy production becomes bimodal and shifts toward the lighter-fluid side, while pressure production grows to rival buoyancy and acts as an energy source on the heavier side of stratification. Together, these results clarify when classical diffusive corrections remain applicable and when diffusion and non-Boussinesq coupling must be retained.

physics.flu-dyn↗