Search arXiv⌕ Search
Home/Archive/arXiv

arXiv · 2609.35535

Analysis of asymmetric errors in NISQ experiments

Gil Kalai·Tomer Shoham·Carsten Voelkmann
View original source ↗Read source document ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

This paper continues our analysis of NISQ experiments and especially the Google 2019 ``quantum supremacy" experiment. In arXiv:2008.05177 we proposed statistical tools to analyze symmetric and asymmetric readout errors, and the symmetric case was extensively developed and studied in arXiv:2404.00935, where we used Fourier methods combined with statistical tools. Here we extend and complement our earlier study and analyze asymmetric readout errors for data from experiments and simulations. Our study was further motivated by a paper by Fefferman et al. arXiv:2306.16659, who showed that the effect of amplitude damping gate errors is to have larger fractions of zeroes in the samples produced by the quantum computer. We show that this effect of gate errors is not observed in the Google experimental data, where, for the entire range of the number of qubits, $12 \le n \le 53$, the fraction of zeroes and ones reflects only the asymmetry of reported readout errors, and report on simulations with $n=12,14$ using IBM's and Google's simulators.

Explore related subjects

quant-ph

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

Gil Kalai, Tomer Shoham, Carsten Voelkmann. 2026-09-28. Analysis of asymmetric errors in NISQ experiments. https://arxiv.org/abs/2609.35535

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related papers

arXiv2026

Preparation of Hamming-Weight-Preserving Quantum States with Log-Depth Quantum Circuits

Hamming-Weight-Preserving (HWP) states, $\vertψ_{\mathrm{H}}\rangle=\sum_{\mathrm{HW}(x)=k}α_x\vert x\rangle$, represent a fundamental class of quantum states on $n$ qubits with fixed excitation number $k$, playing a pivotal role in quantum simulation, machine learning, and optimization, with prominent examples including the Bethe eigenstates of integrable models and Configuration Interaction states. However, existing preparation methodologies typically rely on sequential architectures whose depth scales linearly with the subspace dimension, whereas practical deployment on realistic quantum hardware demands shallow circuits to mitigate decoherence. In this work, we present quantum circuits that achieve the information theoretic limit of depth logarithmic in the number of populated computational basis states while maintaining asymptotically optimal size. Specifically, for general HWP states, we provide a construction that matches the lower bounds of $Θ(\log \binom{n}{k})$ depth and $Θ(\binom{n}{k})$ size. Furthermore, we propose a resource efficient scheme utilizing only $O(\log k)$ ancillary qubits. For the $k=2$ case, where HWP states naturally admit a graph representation, we show that states whose support graphs are trees or grids admit ancilla free preparation with $Θ(\log n)$ depth and $Θ(m)$ size. Overall, our work provides logarithmic depth state preparation algorithms across various regimes while establishing a connection between quantum state synthesis and Krawtchouk polynomials.

quant-ph↗
arXiv2026

Matrix-product-state-assisted variational Gibbs-state preparation

Evaluating the von Neumann entropy is a central challenge in variational Gibbs-state preparation. We introduce and benchmark matrix-product-state (MPS) assistance for classically evaluating and optimizing the purification circuits without full-statevector storage, examining how circuit architecture affects both thermal-state accuracy and the computational resources required. Comparisons on four- and six-spin transverse-field Ising and XXZ chains reveal complementary strengths: a thermofield-double ansatz performs better at high temperature, whereas a contiguous hardware-efficient ansatz (HEA) performs better on cooling. We identify a layer-dependent entropy ceiling in the contiguous HEA and compare it with an interleaved architecture whose entropy capacity is set solely by the ancilla qubit count. MPS-based benchmarks on 10 x 1, 20 x 1, 3 x 3, and 4 x 4 transverse-field Ising systems show that the tested interleaved circuits generally lower the free-energy errors and improve thermal observables. However, greater entropy capacity and lower free energy do not guarantee improvement in every observable. The architectures also differ in classical cost: contiguous registers permit entropy evaluation at a single MPS bond, whereas the interleaved arrangement requires a dense entropy calculation that scales exponentially with the number of ancillas. These benchmarks connect the accuracy of MPS-assisted Gibbs-state preparation to circuit capacity, optimization, and the tractability of energy and entropy evaluation.

quant-ph↗
arXiv2026

A Unified Error Correction Code for Universal Quantum Computing with Identical Particles

We present a universal fault-tolerant quantum computing architecture based on identical particle qubits (IPQs), where we find that the first-order IPQ - bath interaction fundamentally differs from the conventional first-order qubit-bath interaction. This key distinction necessitates a redesign of existing strategies to fight decoherence. We propose that the simplest quantum error correction code can be realized directly within the physical qubit, provided that conventional correction and restoration are generalized beyond unitary operations to employ physically implementable reversal operations -- naturally placing logical and physical qubits on equal footing. We further demonstrate that dynamical decoupling (DD) remains effective within this unified framework, and that a decoherence-free subspace (DFS) -- like structure emerges. Unlike previous approximate treatments, our analytically solvable IPQ-Bath model enables rigorous testing of these strategies, with numerical simulations validating their effectiveness.

quant-ph↗