Stochastic Subgradient Descent at Sharply Repulsive Points: A Bounded Noise Counterexample and Gaussian Noise Avoidance

Abstract

Motivated by the open question of Bianchi, Hachem, and Schechtman (Bianchi et al., 2024, Remark 4), we show that in the non-weakly convex definable setting, omnidirectional noise with conditional fourth-moment control does not suffice for universal almost-sure avoidance of sharply repulsive critical points. We demonstrate this failure by constructing a globally Lipschitz, coercive, definable objective that is not weakly convex. For this objective and its sufficiently small linear perturbations, stochastic subgradient descent with independent noise uniformly distributed on a ball in $\mathbb{R}^2$ converges with probability $1$ to a nonminimal sharply repulsive critical point from every initial point in a specified ball. A two-cycle argument establishes uniform bounds on the rescaled iterates, yielding convergence to the sharply repulsive critical point. In contrast, for locally Lipschitz definable objectives, Gaussian noise ensures simultaneous almost-sure avoidance of any finite collection of sharply repulsive points. Through a construction of difference quotient functions, we show that convergence to any such point with positive probability would produce a stationary distribution with expected descent $0$, whereas a global positive lower bound on the Fréchet subgradient norms of the limiting functions forces strictly positive expected descent under the same distribution. This contradiction proves avoidance, with the everywhere positive Gaussian density playing a key role.