Observational evidence of black hole event horizon from ultra-compact X-ray binaries

Qian-Qi Ma; Wei-Min Gu; Shan-Shan Weng; Mouyuan Sun

Home/Archive/arXiv

arXiv · 2610.17618

Observational evidence of black hole event horizon from ultra-compact X-ray binaries

Qian-Qi Ma·Wei-Min Gu·Shan-Shan Weng·Mouyuan Sun

View original source ↗Read source document ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

The event horizon is the most crucial feature that distinguishes black hole (BH) from all other objects in the universe. However, since no radiation can escape from the event horizon, its direct observational evidence remains lacking. Although both are compact objects, the event horizon leads to differences in the radiative behavior between black hole and neutron star (NS) X-ray binaries. Historically efforts to probe the existence of event horizons revealed that the BH X-ray binaries are fainter than NSs with similar orbital periods in their quiescent states. Here, we use a special class of X-ray binaries namely the ultra-compact X-ray binaries (UCXBs), to reveal the existence of the event horizon near stellar-mass black holes. In short-period UCXBs, gravitational radiation dominates the orbital angular momentum loss, allowing us to accurately determine their accretion rates. Based on five UCXBs with orbital periods shorter than 40 min, located in globular clusters, and identified accretors (NS or BH), we obtained their accretion rates. Combining their accretion rates and X-ray luminosities, we calculated the X-ray radiative efficiencies of NS and BH. The radiative efficiency of BH is about two to three orders of magnitude lower than that of NS systems, indicating the accretion energy is swallowed by the BH, thereby indirectly probe the presence of the event horizon.

Explore related subjects

astro-ph.HE astro-ph.SR

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeX RIS

Qian-Qi Ma, Wei-Min Gu, Shan-Shan Weng, Mouyuan Sun. 2026-10-13. Observational evidence of black hole event horizon from ultra-compact X-ray binaries. https://arxiv.org/abs/2610.17618

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related papers

arXiv2026

MAXI J1820+070: A rapidly spinning black hole with a small disk truncation in the soft state and warm corona layers

Our study seeks to address the debate over the spin of MAXI J1820+070 through broadband spectral modeling of NICER/NuSTAR observations obtained during the soft state. We further compare our results with previous spin estimates and examine the source variability across the soft state. In addition, we investigate the origin of the soft X-ray excess, which we argue does not originate from the plunging region as previously suggested. To further investigate the origin of this excess, we calculate spin-dependent radial disk temperature profiles across all epochs. We show that the soft spectral state of MAXI J1820+070 is well-described by the Comptonized emission from a thin relativistic accretion disk and two blackbody spectral components with kT$_{bb} = 0.5$ keV and kT$_{bb} = 0.2$ keV. Our results indicate that the black hole in MAXI J1820+070 is rapidly spinning, with $a$ > 0.8, potentially powering the relativistic jets. Our analysis reveals a significant decline in the inner disk temperature midway through the soft state, accompanied by a modest increase in the inferred inner disk radius up to 3Rg. This behavior is consistent with a small disk truncation, a phenomenon recently predicted by GRMHD simulations of the plunging region. The two blackbody components are considerably cooler than the inner disk, corresponding to large emission regions. This suggests that this emission may originate from warm corona layers located further away from the black hole, in close analogy to the warm Comptonization models proposed to explain the soft X-ray excess in active galactic nuclei.

astro-ph.HE↗

arXiv2026

On the triple nature of the PSR J0435+3233 system

The recent pulsar timing ephemeris of PSR J0435+3233 indicates that this millisecond pulsar (MSP) has a spin-down rate that is much higher than observed in other MSPs and challenges our understanding of the formation and evolution of MSPs. We propose that this system is a hierarchical triple, and that the high spin-down rate is caused by varying acceleration due to a tertiary in a wide orbit. We use pulsar timing methods with radio and gamma-ray observations of PSR J0435+3233 to determine the system properties. We find that a hierarchical triple timing model describes the timing observations of PSR J0435+3233 and that this results in the detection of gamma-ray pulsations back to the beginning of the Fermi Large Area Telescope (LAT) data in 2008. The intrinsic spin-down rate remains uncertain as it correlates with the parameters of the outer orbit, but large spin-down rates are excluded and the intrinsic rate is at least two orders of magnitude lower than the observed rate, in line with other Galactic MSPs. We identify a star located 11 mas from the pulsar position as the optical counterpart to the tertiary companion. From the 1.5-2.5 kpc distance and colours, we infer that the tertiary is a 1.2-solar mass F-type main-sequence star. Along with the pulsar binary, it orbits the common centre of mass with an eccentric (e ~ 0.6), wide (~70 yr) orbit that is likely seen at a low orbital inclination. We conclude that PSR J0435+3233 is a hierarchical triple system. We discuss the motivation and prospects for the continued study of this system. Spectral measurements of the outer star in addition to continued astrometric measurements will yield mass ratio and inclination estimates, while continued pulsar timing may yield a tighter constraint on violations of the Strong Equivalence Principle than are currently obtained from PSR J0337+1715.

astro-ph.HE↗

arXiv2026

Thermal evolution of neo-neutron stars. II. Temperature-dependent crusts

The neo-neutron star phase is an intermediate stage in the evolution from a hot, lepton-rich compact object, which is formed in the aftermath of a core-collapse supernova or an accretion-induced collapse of a white dwarf, to a cold deleptonized neutron star (NS). Alternatively, this phase can occur after a binary NS merger if the final compact object does not collapse immediately into a black hole. Radial temperature profiles provided by numerical simulations of proto-NS evolution suggest that the composition and mechanical structure of the star's core at the beginning of the neo-NS phase are approximately identical to those of a cold NS. In contrast, the composition and mechanical structure of the outer layers (i.e., the crust) are expected to change as the star cools. The thermal evolution of neo-NSs with temperature-dependent (inner) envelopes was considered by Beznogov et al. (2020). Here, we investigated what happens if the equation of state (EoS) of the entire crust, including its composition, depends on temperature. We analyzed the thermal, mechanical, and chemical evolution of neo-NSs by further developing and employing neo-NSCool, our NS thermal evolution code. First, we show that thermally dripped neutrons slightly slow down the cooling during the early thermal relaxation stage. Then, we demonstrate that the EoSs featuring exotic light species in the deepest layers of the crust result in significantly slower cooling in the photon-cooling era compared to the EoSs that favor massive nuclei. The crust's composition also impacts the crystallization process as well as the contraction of the crust during cooling. The EoSs with light nuclei cause the innermost layers to remain liquid for a longer time than the EoSs with heavy nuclei.

astro-ph.HE↗