Search arXiv⌕ Search

arXiv · 2611.09678

Calibrating demand models versus adjusting OD matrices with traffic counts: a controlled comparison

Abstract

Traffic counts are routinely used to calibrate travel demand models, particularly when the origin-destination (OD) matrix is not observed directly. An important modelling decision is whether to adjust individual OD flows or the parameters of the demand model that generates them. The latter approach uses fewer parameters and preserves a relationship between zonal characteristics and demand, but its accuracy depends on the assumed model structure. We compare three established approaches using the same prior information, traffic counts and equilibrium assignment. They estimate five production-gravity coefficients, origin and destination adjustment factors, or individual OD flows. Synthetic experiments on the Eastern Massachusetts and Chicago Sketch networks allow recovery to be assessed against known demand under different forms of model misspecification. Calibrating the five-coefficient model gives better OD recovery and held-out link-flow prediction when demand follows its assumptions or a two-purpose gravity process. Its advantage declines or reverses when destination choice or production relationships vary across zones. Cellwise adjustment achieves the closest fit to calibration counts in 65 of 66 evaluated conditions, yet it recovers OD demand least accurately of the three approaches in 45 of them. These findings show that model parameterisation matters beyond calibration fit. For transport planning, traffic counts should be used alongside independent evidence on trip production and distribution when selecting and validating a demand model.

Explore related subjects

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

Yue Li, Shujuan Chen, Ying Jin. 2026-11-06. Calibrating demand models versus adjusting OD matrices with traffic counts: a controlled comparison. https://arxiv.org/abs/2611.09678

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related papers

Computational Construction and Engineering Evaluation of a Verified Mono-Monostatic Body

Many engineering failures in orientation-dependent systems are geometric failure modes: changing the material delays the failure; changing the geometry can eliminate it. The mono-monostatic property (exactly one stable equilibrium under gravity) is mathematically proven to exist in convex homogeneous bodies, but, to our knowledge, no verified smooth geometry had been openly published when v1 appeared (April 2026). We introduce an Equilibrium Count Score (ECS) oracle that measures stable equilibria via drainage basin analysis on the center-of-mass height landscape. v2 correction: v1 reported that Sloan's (2023) analytical Gomboc parameterization shows 4-11 local minima "at all published parameter values." That claim is withdrawn. The beta values swept were this work's own grid points, not Sloan's (he states convexity bounds beta <= 0.15 and beta <= 0.17); they lie inside the strictly convex sub-regime beta < ~0.036, where a body at beta = 0.023 was later certified mono-monostatic by interval arithmetic; and the oracle's two stages are biased in opposite directions, so its count can be wrong either way. We construct one strictly convex mono-monostatic body by extending the Sloan phase function with a Fourier term and optimizing via differential evolution, with ECS=1 confirmed across merge thresholds from 0.5% to 10%; two more reach ECS=1 under the oracle but are not strictly convex. Conventional geometries cannot achieve ECS=1 through ballast alone: cylinders and cubes retain multiple stable equilibria even at 30% bottom-weighted mass. Applications: an IMU calibration housing (349x orientation precision improvement), aerial reforestation seed pods (20-67% germination loss from incorrect landing orientation), and marine buoy self-righting. Cross-layer scoring shows the Gomboc is 11.8x worse than the cylinder on contact distribution while optimal on equilibrium stability.

cs.CE↗

Uncertainty-aware neural emulation reveals climate-resilient maize traits at scale

Climate change threatens maize yields worldwide, yet identifying which genetic traits sustain productivity under future conditions requires exploring an enormous space of genotype, soil, and climate combinations that process-based crop models are too costly to simulate at scale. Here we develop an integrated probabilistic emulation framework that transforms a mechanistic crop simulator (APSIM) into a fast, uncertainty-aware discovery engine. Built from two million simulations and coupled to a generative weather model that produces realistic climate sequences, the emulator reproduces thirteen maize growth outputs with high fidelity while returning calibrated confidence for every prediction, at a fraction of the original computational cost. Applying it across 100,000 trait configurations, six locations, and future climate projections extending to the year 2100, we identify 1,114 trait combinations that remain resilient under the 2100 future conditions and a stricter subset of 246 configurations that remain resilient across four future projection periods: 2040, 2060, 2080, and 2100. These resilient configurations occupy a distinct region of trait space, combining high radiation use efficiency with characteristic shifts in developmental and reproductive traits. Trait-importance analysis further identifies radiation use efficiency as the dominant driver of yield under future climate, while projected yields vary widely across locations and climate models, indicating strong spatial heterogeneity in the maize response to climate change.

cs.CE↗

VASTO: Simultaneous reconstruction of vascular geometry and blood flow from tomographic projections via differentiable topology optimization

Computed Tomography Angiography (CTA) is widely used to reconstruct vascular geometry from projection measurements, with conventional approaches such as Filtered Back-Projection (FBP) and Iterative Reconstruction (IR) forming the clinical standard. Despite recent advances, these methods remain susceptible to sparse and noisy measurement, making accurate recovery of critical anatomical features challenging. This consequently leads to poor estimation of blood flow. In this work, we present a fluid-physics-constrained reconstruction framework that leverages topology optimization (TO) to jointly recover vascular geometry and blood flow directly from time-resolved CTA sinograms. The formulation couples a steady incompressible flow model with a transient advection-diffusion contrast transport model, mapped to sinogram space through a differentiable projection operator. The velocity field is recovered as part of the reconstruction, and thus hemodynamic information can be obtained without requiring a separate computational fluid dynamics pipeline. The proposed method is demonstrated on synthetic phantoms under varying sparsity and noise levels, and on representative projection data.

cs.CE↗