Dynamical Evolution of Galaxy Groups. A comparison of two approaches

Abstract

In this paper we test the performance of explicit simulations of groups of galaxies, (i.e. simulations in which each galaxy is treated as a mass point and the physics of the interactions is modelled by specific analand the physics of the interactions is modelled by specific analytical prescriptions for merging conditions), by comparing them with fully self-consistent simulations starting from identical initial conditions. The quality of the explicit simulations is very unequal. For somThe quality of the explicit simulations is very unequal. For some prescriptions the results are complete disagreement with the self-consistent simulations. The inclusion of other dynamical effects like dynamical friction gives, in some cases, better agreeement.like dynamical friction gives, in some cases, better agreeement. We also propose a new merging criterion, which, combined with dynamical friction, gives much better agreement with self-consistent simulations in a variety of initial conditions, but even this criterion has a limited ranof initial conditions, but even this criterion has a limited range of applicability.