Constraints on the spectral distribution of energy and enstrophy dissipation in forced two-dimensional turbulence

Abstract

We study two-dimensional turbulence in a doubly periodic domain driven by a monoscale-like forcing and damped by various dissipation mechanisms of the form $ν_μ(-Δ)^μ$. By ``monoscale-like'' we mean that the forcing is applied over a finite range of wavenumbers $k_\min \leq k \leq k_\max$, and that the ratio of enstrophy injection $η\geq 0$ to energy injection $ε\geq 0$ is bounded by $k_\min^2 ε\leq η\leq k_\max^2 ε$. It is shown that for $μ\geq 0$ the asymptotic behaviour satisfies (eqnarray) \norm u_1^2&\leq&k_\max^2\norm u^2,(eqnarray) where $\norm u^2$ and $\norm u_1^2$ are the energy and enstrophy, respectively. It is also shown that for Navier-Stokes turbulence ($μ= 1$), the time-mean enstrophy dissipation rate is bounded from above by $2ν_1 k_\max^2$. These results place strong constraints on the spectral distribution of energy and enstrophy and of their dissipation, and thereby on the existence of energy and enstrophy cascades, in such systems. In particular, the classical dual cascade picture is shown to be invalid for forced two-dimensional Navier--Stokes turbulence ($μ=1$) when it is forced in this manner. Inclusion of Ekman drag ($μ=0$) along with molecular viscosity permits a dual cascade, but is incompatible with the log-modified -3 power law for the energy spectrum in the enstrophy-cascading inertial range. In order to achieve the latter, it is necessary to invoke an inverse viscosity ($μ<0$).