Search arXiv⌕ Search
Home/Archive/arXiv

arXiv · physics/0412112

Effect of noise and modeling errors on the reliability of fully 3D Monte Carlo reconstruction in SPECT

D. Lazaro·Z. El Bitar·V. Breton·I. Buvat
View original source ↗Read source document ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

We recently demonstrated the value of reconstructing SPECT data with fully 3D Monte Carlo reconstruction (F3DMC), in terms of spatial resolution and quantification. This was shown on a small cubic phantom (64 projections 10 x 10) in some idealistic configurations. The goals of the present study were to assess the effect of noise and modeling errors on the reliability of F3DMC, to propose and evaluate strategies for reducing the noise in the projector, and to demonstrate the feasibility of F3DMC for a dataset with realistic dimensions. A small cubic phantom and a realistic Jaszczak phantom dataset were considered. Projections and projectors for both phantoms were calculated using the Monte Carlo simulation code GATE. Projectors with different statistics were considered and two methods for reducing noise in the projector were investigated: one based on principal component analysis (PCA) and the other consisting in setting small probability values to zero. Energy and spatial shifts in projection sampling with respect to projector sampling were also introduced to test F3DMC in realistic conditions. Experiments with the cubic phantom showed the importance of using simulations with high statistics for calculating the projector, and the value of filtering the projector using a PCA approach. F3DMC was shown to be robust with respect to energy shift and small spatial sampling off-set between the projector and the projections. Images of the Jaszczak phantom were successfully reconstructed and also showed promising results in terms of spatial resolution recovery and quantitative accuracy in small structures. It is concluded that the promising results of F3DMC hold on realistic data sets

Explore related subjects

physics.med-ph

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

D. Lazaro, Z. El Bitar, V. Breton, I. Buvat. 2004-12-17. Effect of noise and modeling errors on the reliability of fully 3D Monte Carlo reconstruction in SPECT. https://doi.org/10.1109/nssmic.2004.1462770

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related papers

arXiv2026

Evaluation of Image Noise from Computed Tomography in an Organ-Specific Anthropomorphic Phantom

Computed tomography (CT) is used ubiquitously for diagnostic imaging, with novel iterative reconstructions such as hybrid iterative reconstruction with partial model-based component (ASiR-V) and deep learning image reconstruction (DLIR) increasingly utilized. In conjunction, CT vendors have developed a noise index (NI) to reduce radiation dose during protocol development. However, it is unclear how these reconstruction algorithms reduce noise as NI changes, particularly across multiple organs. The goal of this study was to utilize an anthropomorphic phantom to evaluate image noise against the prescribed NI across different organs, determine if DLIR reduces image noise compared to ASiR-V, and use this relationship to determine the maximum volume CT dose index (CTDIvol) reduction at equivalent noise levels. Repeat images were acquired on a GE HealthCare Revolution Apex CT scanner across NI values in an anthropomorphic adult-sized phantom from Kyoto Kagaku with ASiR-V and DLIR. Organs-of-interest were contoured using TotalSegmentator in 3D Slicer. The correlation between the CTDIvol and NI was determined. The standard deviation of the difference in the repeat images was used as a noise metric (NM), correlated with NI, used to determine the NI at equivalent NM between ASiR-V and DLIR, then applied to determine the dose reduction and difference in NM. The relationship between NI and the resulting CTDIvol was found to be proportional to a power law of exponent -2.23. The maximum potential absolute dose reduction from using DLIR was found in the liver at 1.3 mGy with an NI of 7.9. Across all organs, the relative dose reduction increased, the NM-to-NI ratio decreased, and the noise reduction increased across NI. The relationship between image noise and the prescribed NI differed between ASiR-V and DLIR and varied by organ, with model-based dose reductions of up to 1.3 mGy in the liver.

physics.med-ph↗
arXiv2026

Constrained estimation of rotational invariants of the cumulant expansion (RICE) for rapid tensor-valued diffusion MRI

Purpose: To complement 1.5-minute measurements of common tensor-valued diffusion MRI (dMRI) markers with rapid constrained fitting. Methods: Fast dMRI protocols for obtaining rotational invariants of the cumulant expansion (RICE) were paired with constrained weighted linear least squares (CWLLS) to stabilize the more fragile WLLS fit. A compact constraint set was formulated, including a novel mean-dependent upper bound on total diffusional variance. Evaluation used diffusion tensor distribution (DTD) simulations, healthy-volunteer data with a resolution-dependent SNR experiment, and a glioma patient dataset. A 5-minute q-space trajectory imaging (QTI) protocol served as a reference. Results: Across experiments, CWLLS reduced unphysical estimates and fit outliers in parameters such as microscopic FA and isotropic diffusivity variance. In simulations, it narrowed error distributions most clearly in the CSF-dominant case, while some metrics showed a bias-variance trade-off. In vivo, CWLLS removed negative variance estimates, truncated out-of-bounds tails, and reduced artifacts in fluid-contaminated voxels while preserving anatomical contrast. It also retained more stable maps than WLLS at higher resolution, although both estimators degraded in the lowest-SNR setting. Notably, the new mean-dependent variance bound was violated in 15.4% of voxels in the patient dataset, accounting for nearly half of the 32.7% that violated at least one constraint. Healthy-volunteer benchmarking showed that CWLLS completed in under 30 seconds. The constrained QTI fit required 72 minutes, making CWLLS 160 times faster. Conclusion: CWLLS for fast RICE yielded high-quality parameter maps at an online-ready computational cost. This may enhance the reliability of dMRI tissue characterization and strengthen the path toward clinical translation.

physics.med-ph↗
arXiv2026

Estimation of Very High Energy Electron (VHEE) beam parameters using an in-air screen

Very high energy electron (VHEE) beams offer several promising properties for radiotherapy. Accurate beam delivery requires a beam model that accounts for scattering along the beam propagation path. This work develops and validates a beam model incorporating Multiple Coulomb Scattering (MCS) to estimate beam parameters. MCS is incorporated as an additive term to the covariance matrix transformation for a drift space, allowing conventional quadrupole scans to estimate beam parameters in the presence of a downstream scatterer. The scattering correction factor is fitted to Monte Carlo (MC) simulations for a range of materials and thicknesses. The model is then validated by recovering the initial beam parameters from simulated quadrupole scans of a realistic beamline. Finally, the method is applied to in-air screen measurements at the Pulsed Energetic Electrons for Research (PEER) end station of the Australian Synchrotron. After fitting the correction factors, the mean and standard deviation of the estimation errors for the final emittance, diameter, divergence, and mean kinetic energy were $(-0.06 \pm 3.17)\%$, $(0.15 \pm 0.66)\%$, $(0.18 \pm 2.18)\%$, and $(-0.03 \pm 0.06)\%$, respectively. Simulated quadrupole scans successfully recovered the initial beam parameters, with errors of at most $13\%$. PEER measurements yielded emittance estimates ranging from $0.238$ to $1.753~\mathrm{mm\,mrad}$ across scans, which were within the expected range. Following an initial quadrupole scan, the method allows the in-air beam size to be estimated for other quadrupole configurations. Further work is required to improve the consistency and reliability of the experimental estimates.

physics.med-ph↗