Findings of sub-$T_\mathrm{g}$ endotherm in vapor-deposited ultrastable phenolphthalein glass
We have performed heat capacity measurements for physically vapor-deposited phenolphthalein glass using conventional and in-house high-sensitivity differential scanning calorimetry. As a result, we found that phenolphthalein forms an ultrastable glass when deposited at 313 K, about 0.86 times the ordinary glass transition temperature of 361 K. In addition, we observed a large endotherm (sub-$T_\mathrm{g}$ endotherm) between deposition and the ordinary glass transition temperature. From an enthalpy perspective, the integrated enthalpy of the sub-$T_\mathrm{g}$ endotherm increased with decreasing film thickness following an inverse-power dependence, whose exponent increased as the deposition rate decreased. In particular, the integrated enthalpy of the sub-$T_\mathrm{g}$ endotherm was comparable in magnitude to the enthalpy of fusion of crystalline phenolphthalein. To investigate the structural origin of the sub-$T_\mathrm{g}$ endotherm, we performed wide-angle X-ray diffraction and in situ atomic force microscopy. As a result, we found that while the stable structure is linked to an anisotropic amorphous structure consistent with past research on ultrastable glasses, the appearance of the sub-$T_\mathrm{g}$ endotherm is associated with surface morphological relaxation, as suggested by atomic force microscopy.