arXiv subjects

M. Mathioudakis

Publications and source records attributed to M. Mathioudakis.

At least 19 recordsLinked to original sources

arXiv2024

Insight into the solar plage chromosphere with DKIST

The strongly coupled hydrodynamic, magnetic, and radiation properties of the plasma in the solar chromosphere makes it a region of the Sun's atmosphere that is poorly understood. We use data obtained with the high-resolution Visible Broadband Imager (VBI) equipped with an H$\beta$ filter and the Visible Spectro-Polarimeter (ViSP) at the Daniel K. Inouye Solar Telescope to investigate the fine-scale structure of the plage chromosphere. To aid the interpretation of the VBI imaging data, we also analyze spectra from the CHROMospheric Imaging Spectrometer on the Swedish Solar Telescope. The analysis of spectral properties, such as enhanced line widths and line depths explains the high contrast of the fibrils relative to the background atmosphere demonstrating that H$\beta$ is an excellent diagnostic for the enigmatic fine-scale structure of the chromosphere. A correlation between the parameters of the H$\beta$ line indicates that opacity broadening created by overdense fibrils could be the main reason for the spectral line broadening observed frequently in chromospheric fine-scale structures. Spectropolarimetric inversions of the ViSP data in the Ca II 8542 {\AA} and Fe I 6301/6302 {\AA} lines are used to construct semiempirical models of the plage atmosphere. Inversion outputs indicate the existence of dense fibrils in the Ca II 8542 {\AA} line. The analyses of the ViSP data show that the morphological characteristics, such as orientation, inclination and length of fibrils are defined by the topology of the magnetic field in the photosphere. Chromospheric maps reveal a prominent magnetic canopy in the area where fibrils are directed towards the observer.

astro-ph.SR↗

arXiv2023

Statistical Signatures of Nanoflare Activity. III. Evidence of Enhanced Nanoflaring Rates in Fully Convective stars as Observed by the NGTS

Previous examinations of fully-convective M-dwarf stars have highlighted enhanced rates of nanoflare activity on these distant stellar sources. However, the specific role the convective boundary, which is believed to be present for spectral types earlier than M2.5V, plays on the observed nanoflare rates is not yet known. Here, we utilize a combination of statistical and Fourier techniques to examine M-dwarf stellar lightcurves that lie on either side of the convective boundary. We find that fully convective M2.5V (and later sub-types) stars have greatly enhanced nanoflare rates compared with their pre-dynamo mode transition counterparts. Specifically, we derive a flaring power-law index in the region of $3.00 \pm 0.20$, alongside a decay timescale of $200 \pm 100$~s for M2.5V and M3V stars, matching those seen in prior observations of similar stellar sub-types. Interestingly, M4V stars exhibit longer decay timescales of $450 \pm 50$~s, along with an increased power-law index of $3.10 \pm 0.18$, suggesting an interplay between the rate of nanoflare occurrence and the intrinsic plasma parameters, for example, the underlying Lundquist number. In contrast, partially convective (i.e., earlier sub-types from M0V to M2V) M-dwarf stars exhibit very weak nanoflare activity, which is not easily identifiable using statistical or Fourier techniques. This suggests that fully convective stellar atmospheres favor small-scale magnetic reconnection, leading to implications for the flare-energy budgets of these stars. Understanding why small-scale reconnection is enhanced in fully convective atmospheres may help solve questions relating to the dynamo behavior of these stellar sources.

astro-ph.SR↗

arXiv2023

DKIST unveils the serpentine topology of quiet Sun magnetism in the photosphere

We present the first quiet Sun spectropolarimetric observations obtained with the Visible SpectroPolarimeter (ViSP) at the $4-$m Daniel K. Inouye Solar Telescope (DKIST). We recorded observations in a wavelength range that includes the magnetically sensitive Fe I $6301.5/6302.5$ $\AA$ doublet. With an estimated spatial resolution of 0.08'', this represents the highest spatial resolution full-vector spectropolarimetric observations ever obtained of the quiet Sun. We identified $53$ small-scale magnetic elements, including $47$ magnetic loops and $4$ unipolar magnetic patches, with linear and circular polarisation detected in all of them. Of particular interest is a magnetic element in which the polarity of the magnetic vector appears to change three times in only $400$ km and which has linear polarisation signals throughout. We find complex Stokes $V$ profiles at the polarity inversion lines of magnetic loops and discover degenerate solutions, as we are unable to conclusively determine whether these arise due to gradients in the atmospheric parameters or smearing of opposite polarity signals. We analyse a granule which notably has linear and circular polarisation signals throughout, providing an opportunity to explore its magnetic properties. On this small scale we see the magnetic field strength range from $25$ G at the granular boundary to $2$ kG in the intergranular lane (IGL), and sanity check the values with the weak and strong field approximations. A value of $2$ kG in the IGL is among the highest measurements ever recorded for the internetwork.

astro-ph.SR↗

arXiv2022

Pre-emergence Signatures Of Horizontal Divergent Flows In Solar Active Regions

Solar active regions (ARs) play a fundamental role in driving many of the geo-effective eruptions which propagate into the Solar System. However, we are still unable to consistently predict where and when ARs will occur across the solar disk by identifying pre-emergence signatures in observables such as the Doppler velocity (without using Helioseismic methods). Here we aim to determine the earliest time at which pre-emergence signatures, specifically the Horizontal Divergent Flow (HDF), can be confidently detected using data from the Solar Dynamics Observatory's Helioseismic and Magnetic Imager (SDO/HMI). Initially, we follow previous studies using the thresholding method, which searches for significant increases in the number of pixels that display a specific line-of-sight velocity. We expand this method to more velocity windows and conduct a basic parameter study investigating the effect of cadence on the inferred results. Our findings agree with previous studies with $37.5$% of ARs displaying a HDF, with average lead times between the HDF and flux emergence of $58$ minutes. We present a new potential signature of flux emergence which manifests as cadence-independent transient disruptions to the amplitudes of multiple velocity windows and recover potential pre-emergence signatures for 10 of the 16 ARs studied, with lead times of 60-156 minutes. Several effects can influence both the estimated times of both HDF and flux emergence suggesting that one may need to combine Doppler and magnetic field data to get a reliable indicator of continued flux emergence.

astro-ph.SR↗

arXiv2021

Implications of spicule activity on coronal loop heating and catastrophic cooling

We report on the properties of coronal loop foot-point heating with observations at the highest resolution, from the CRisp Imaging Spectro-Polarimeter (CRISP) located at the Swedish 1-m Solar Telescope (SST) and co-aligned NASA Solar Dynamics Observatory (SDO) observations, of Type II spicules in the chromosphere and their signatures in the EUV corona. Here, we address one important issue, as to why there is not always a one-to-one correspondence, between Type II spicules and hot coronal plasma signatures, i.e. beyond TR temperatures. We do not detect any difference in their spectral properties in a quiet Sun region compared to a region dominated by coronal loops. On the other hand, the number density close to the foot-points in the active region is found to be an order of magnitude higher than in the quiet Sun case. A differential emission measure analysis reveals a peak at $\sim 5 \times 10^5$ K on the order of 10$^{22}$~cm$^{-5}$~K$^{-1}$. Using this result as a constraint, we conduct numerical simulations and show that with an energy input of $1.25 \times 10^{24}$ erg (corresponding to $\sim$10 RBEs contributing to the burst) we manage to reproduce the observation very closely. However, simulation runs with lower thermal energy input do not reproduce the synthetic AIA $171 {\AA}$ signatures, indicating that there is a critical number of spicules required in order to account for the AIA $171{\AA}$ signatures in the simulation. Furthermore, the higher energy ($1.25 \times 10^{24}$ ergs) simulations reproduce catastrophic cooling with a cycle duration of $\sim$5 hours, matching a periodicity we observe in the EUV observations.

astro-ph.SR↗

arXiv2021

Oscillations In The Line-of-Sight Magnetic Field Strength In A Pore Observed By The GREGOR Infrared Spectrograph (GRIS)

Numerous magnetohydrodynamic oscillations have been reported within solar pores over the past decades, including in line-of-sight (LOS) velocities, intensities, and magnetic field strengths. Our aim is to identify whether high-amplitude oscillations in the LOS magnetic field strength can be detected within a pore located in Active Region 12748 and to investigate which physical mechanisms could be responsible for them. A solar pore was observed on the 1st September 2019 using the GREGOR Infrared Spectrograph for around one hour. Full-Stokes vectors were sampled in a 37 A window containing the Fe I 15648.52 A line (effective Lande g-factor of 3). The LOS magnetic field strength is inferred using the strong-field approximation. The Stokes Inversion based on Response functions code is used to gain a more complete understanding the properties of the solar atmosphere at the locations of these oscillations. Oscillations of more than 100 G are observed in the LOS magnetic field in the period window 600-1272 s at three localised (>1"^2) regions. These oscillations have coherence across individual regions indicating that jitter cannot account for their occurrence. Longer-period amplitude variations, amplitudes over 200 G, are also detected but these have periods outside of the cone-of-influence. Numerical inversions confirm both oscillations in the LOS magnetic field strength at optical depths of around log-tau_5000=-0.5 (potentially caused by compression) and other effects (e.g., changes in the optical depth or the inclination of the field) may account for these changes. The oscillations in the separations of the Stokes-V lobes of the 15648.52 A line appear to be solar in nature. Future work will be required to understand whether these are truly oscillations in the magnetic field strength at a specific depth in the solar atmosphere or whether other effects are responsible for these signatures.

astro-ph.SR↗

arXiv2021

Constraining the magnetic vector in the quiet solar photosphere and the impact of instrumental degradation

With the advent of next generation high resolution telescopes, our understanding of how the magnetic field is organized in the internetwork (IN) photosphere is likely to advance.We aim to evaluate the extent to which we can retrieve information about the magnetic vector in the IN photosphere using inversions. We use snapshots produced from high resolution 3D magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) simulations and employ the Stokes Inversions based on Response functions (SIR) code to produce synthetic observables in the near infrared spectral window observed by the GREGOR Infrared Spectrograph (GRIS), which contains the highly magnetically sensitive photospheric Fe I line pair at 15648.52 A and 15652.87 A. We perform nearly 14 million inversions to test how well the true MHD atmospheric parameters can be constrained. Finally, we degrade the synthetic Stokes vectors spectrally and spatially to GREGOR resolutions and examine how this influences observations, considering the impact of stray light, spatial resolution and signal-to-noise (S-to-N). We find the depth-averaged parameters can be recovered by the inversions of the undegraded profiles, and by adding gradients to magnetic field strength, inclination and line of sight velocity we show an improvement in the chi squared value is achieved. We evaluate the extent to which we can constrain these parameters at various optical depths, with the kinematic and thermodynamic parameters sensitive deeper in the atmosphere than the magnetic parameters. We find the S-to-N and spatial resolution play a significant role in determining how the atmosphere appears and the magnetic and kinematic parameters are invariant upon inclusion of unpolarized stray light. We studied a linear polarization feature which resembles those recently observed by GRIS, appearing as loop-like structures with similar magnetic flux density.

astro-ph.SR↗

arXiv2021

Chromospheric Heating by MHD Waves and Instabilities

The importance of the chromosphere in the mass and energy transport within the solar atmosphere is now widely recognised. This review discusses the physics of magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) waves and instabilities in large-scale chromospheric structures as well as in magnetic flux tubes. We highlight a number of key observational aspects that have helped our understanding of the role of the solar chromosphere in various dynamic processes and wave phenomena, and the heating scenario of the solar chromosphere is also discussed. The review focuses on the physics of waves and invokes the basics of plasma instabilities in the context of this important layer of the solar atmosphere. Potential implications, future trends and outstanding questions are also delineated.

astro-ph.SR↗

arXiv2020

Evolution Of Downflows In The Transition Region Above A Sunspot Over Short Time-Scales

Downflows with high velocities occur in the transition region above many sunspots; however, how these signatures evolve over short time-scales in both spatial and spectral terms is still unknown. In this article, we investigate the evolution of downflows detected within the transition region on time-scales of the order minutes and search for clues as to their formation mechanisms in co-temporal imaging data. The high-resolution spectral and imaging data used to identify downflows here were sampled by IRIS on the 20th and 21st May 2015. Imaging data from the Hinode and SDO satellites provided context about the wider solar atmosphere. Four downflows were identified and analysed. The potential super-sonic components of these downflows had widths of around 2" and evolved over time-scales of the order minutes. The measured apparent downflow velocities were structured both in time and space, with the highest apparent velocities occurring above a bright region detected in Si IV 1400 {\AA} images. Downflows with apparent velocities below 50 km s^{-1} were observed to extend a few arcsecs away from the foot-points suggesting the potential super-sonic components are linked to larger-scale flows. The electron density and mass flux for these events were within the ranges 10^{9.6}-10^{10.2} cm^{-3} and 10^{-6.81}-10^{-7.48} g cm^{-2} s^{-1}, respectively. Each downflow formed at the foot-point of thin `fingers' extending out around 3-5" in Si IV 1400 {\AA} data with smaller widths (<1") than the super-sonic downflows. Downflows can appear, disappear, and recur within time-scales of less than one hour in sunspots. As potential super-sonic downflow signatures were detected at the foot-points of both extended fingers in Si IV 1400 {\AA} SJI data and sub-sonic downflows in Si IV 1394 \AA\ spectra, it is likely that these events are linked to flows within structures such as coronal loops.

astro-ph.SR↗

arXiv2020

Spectral Characteristics and Formation Height of Off-Limb Flare Ribbons

Flare ribbons are bright manifestations of flare energy dissipation in the lower solar atmosphere. For the first time, we report on high-resolution imaging spectroscopy observations of flare ribbons situated off-limb in the H$\beta$ and Ca II 8542 {\AA} lines and make a detailed comparison with radiative hydrodynamic simulations. Observations of the X8.2-class solar flare SOL2017-09-10T16:06 UT obtained with the Swedish Solar Telescope reveal bright horizontal emission layers in H$\beta$ line wing images located near the footpoints of the flare loops. The apparent separation between the ribbon observed in the H$\beta$ wing and the nominal photospheric limb is about 300 - 500 km. The Ca II 8542 {\AA} line wing images show much fainter ribbon emissions located right on the edge of the limb, without clear separation from the limb. RADYN models are used to investigate synthetic spectral line profiles for the flaring atmosphere, and good agreement is found with the observations. The simulations show that, towards the limb, where the line of sight is substantially oblique with respect to the vertical direction, the flaring atmosphere model reproduces the high contrast of the off-limb H$\beta$ ribbons and their significant elevation above the photosphere. The ribbons in the Ca II 8542 {\AA} line wing images are located deeper in the lower solar atmosphere with a lower contrast. A comparison of the height deposition of electron beam energy and the intensity contribution function shows that the H$\beta$ line wing intensities can be an useful tracer of flare energy deposition in the lower solar atmosphere

astro-ph.SR↗

arXiv2020

Velocity Response of the Observed Explosive Events in the Lower Solar Atmosphere: I. Formation of the Flowing Cool Loop System

We observe plasma flows in cool loops using the Slit-Jaw Imager (SJI) onboard the Interface Region Imaging Spectrometer (IRIS). Huang et al. (2015) observed unusually broadened Si IV 1403 angstrom line profiles at the footpoints of such loops that were attributed to signatures of explosive events (EEs). We have chosen one such uni-directional flowing cool loop system observed by IRIS where one of the footpoints is associated with significantly broadened Si IV line profiles. The line profile broadening indirectly indicates the occurrence of numerous EEs below the transition region (TR), while it directly infers a large velocity enhancement /perturbation further causing the plasma flows in the observed loop system. The observed features are implemented in a model atmosphere in which a low-lying bi-polar magnetic field system is perturbed in the chromosphere by a velocity pulse with a maximum amplitude of 200 km/s. The data-driven 2-D numerical simulation shows that the plasma motions evolve in a similar manner as observed by IRIS in the form of flowing plasma filling the skeleton of a cool loop system. We compare the spatio-temporal evolution of the cool loop system in the framework of our model with the observations, and conclude that their formation is mostly associated with the velocity response of the transient energy release above their footpoints in the chromosphere/TR. Our observations and modeling results suggest that the velocity responses most likely associated to the EEs could be one of the main candidates for the dynamics and energetics of the flowing cool loop systems in the lower solar atmosphere.

astro-ph.SR↗

arXiv2020

Evolution Of Super-Sonic Downflows In A Sunspot

Super-sonic downflows have been observed in transition region spectra above numerous sunspots; however, little research has been conducted to date into how persistent these signatures are within sunspots on time-scales longer than a few hours. Here, we analyse the lead sunspot of AR 12526 to infer the properties and evolution of super-sonic downflows occurring within it. Sixteen large, dense raster scans sampled by IRIS are analysed. These rasters tracked the lead sunspot of AR 12526 at discrete times between the 27th March 2016 and the 2nd April 2016. One sit-and-stare observation acquired on the 1st April 2016 is also studied in order to analyse the evolution of super-sonic downflows on shorter time-scales. Super-sonic downflows are variable within this sunspot both in terms of spatial structuring and velocities. 13 of the 16 raster scans display some evidence of super-sonic downflows in the Si IV 1394 {\AA} line co-spatial to a sustained bright structure detected in the 1400 {\AA} slit-jaw imaging channel, with a peak velocity of 112 km s^{-1} being recorded on the 29th March 2016. Evidence for super-sonic downflows in the O IV 1401 {\AA} line was found in 14 of these rasters, with the spatial structuring differing from that inferred from the Si IV 1394 {\AA} line. In the sit-and-stare data, no dual flow is initially detected, however, a super-sonic downflow does develop after 60 minutes. This downflow accelerates from 73 km s^{-1} to close to 80 km s^{-1} in both the Si IV 1394 {\AA} and O IV 1401 {\AA} lines over the course of 20 minutes before the end of the observation. The morphology of these downflows evolved over the course of both hours and days and was often different in the Si IV 1394 {\AA} and O IV 1401 {\AA} lines. These events were found co-spatial to a bright region in the core of the Si IV 1394 {\AA} line which appeared to form at the foot-points of coronal fan loops.

astro-ph.SR↗

arXiv2019

Propagation of Waves above a Plage as Observed by IRIS and SDO

Context. MHD waves are proposed to transport sufficient energy from the photosphere to heat the transition-region (TR) and corona. However, various aspects of these waves such as their nature, propagation characteristics and role in the atmospheric heating process remain poorly understood and are a matter of further investigation. Aims. We aim to investigate wave propagation within an active-region (AR) plage using IRIS and AIA observations. The main motivation is to understand the relationship between photospheric and TR oscillations. We plan to identify the locations in the plage region where magnetic flux tubes are essentially vertical, and further our understanding of the propagation and nature of these waves. Methods. We have used photospheric observations from AIA (i.e., AIA 1700 {\AA}) as well as TR imaging observations (IRIS/SJI Si iv 1400.0 {\AA}). We have investigated propagation of the waves into the TR from the photosphere using wavelet analysis (e.g., cross power, coherence and phase difference) with inclusion of a customized noise model. Results. Fast Fourier Transform(FFT) shows the distribution of wave power at photospheric & TR heights. Waves with periods between 2.0- and 9.0-minutes appear to be correlated between the photosphere and TR. We exploited a customized noise model to estimate 95% confidence levels for IRIS observations. On the basis of the sound speed in the TR and estimated propagation speed, these waves are best interpreted as the slow magneto acoustic waves (SMAW). It is found that almost all locations show correlation/propagation of waves over broad range of period from photosphere to TR. It suggests the wave's correlation/propagation spatial occurrence frequency is very high within the plage area.

astro-ph.SR↗

arXiv2019

Spatially resolved signatures of bi-directional flows observed in inverted-Y shaped jets

Numerous apparent signatures of magnetic reconnection have been reported in the solar photosphere, including inverted-Y shaped jets. The reconnection at these sites is expected to cause localised bi-directional flows and extended shock waves; however, these signatures are rarely observed as extremely high spatial-resolution data are required. Here, we use H-alpha imaging data sampled by the Swedish Solar Telescope's CRisp Imaging SpectroPolarimeter to investigate whether bi-directional flows can be detected within inverted-Y shaped jets near the solar limb. These jets are apparent in the H-alpha line wings, while no signature of either jet is observed in the H-alpha line core, implying reconnection took place below the chromospheric canopy. Asymmetries in the H-alpha line profiles along the legs of the jets indicate the presence of bi-directional flows, consistent with cartoon models of reconnection in chromospheric anemone jets. These asymmetries are present for over two minutes, longer than the lifetimes of Rapid Blue Excursions, and beyond \pm 1 \AA\ into the wings of the line indicating that flows within the inverted-Y shaped jets are responsible for the imbalance in the profiles, rather than motions in the foreground. Additionally, surges form following the occurrence of the inverted-Y shaped jets. This surge formation is consistent with models which suggest such events could be caused by the propagation of shock waves from reconnection sites in the photosphere to the upper atmosphere. Overall, our results provide evidence that magnetic reconnection in the photosphere can cause bi-directional flows within inverted-Y shaped jets and could be the driver of surges.

astro-ph.SR↗

arXiv2019

The Effect Of Cooling On Driven Kink Oscillations Of Coronal Loops

Ever since their detection two decades ago, standing kink oscillations in coronal loops have been extensively studied both observationally and theoretically. Almost all driven coronal loop oscillations (e.g., by flares) are observed to damp through time often with Gaussian or exponential profiles. Intriguingly, however, it has been shown theoretically that the amplitudes of some oscillations could be modified from Gaussian or exponential profiles if cooling is present in the coronal loop systems. Indeed, in some cases the oscillation amplitude can even increase through time. In this article, we analyse a flare-driven coronal loop oscillation observed by the Solar Dynamics Observatory's Atmospheric Imaging Assembly (SDO/AIA) in order to investigate whether models of cooling can explain the amplitude profile of the oscillation and whether hints of cooling can be found in the intensity evolution of several SDO/AIA filters. During the oscillation of this loop system, the kink mode amplitude appears to differ from a typical Gaussian or exponential profile with some hints being present that the amplitude increases. The application of cooling coronal loop modelling allowed us to estimate the density ratio between the loop and the background plasma, with a ratio of between 2.05-2.35 being returned. Overall, our results indicate that consideration of the thermal evolution of coronal loop systems can allow us to better describe oscillations in these structures and return more accurate estimates of the physical properties of the loops (e.g., density, scale height, magnetic field strength).

astro-ph.SR↗

arXiv2019

Stellar Surface Magneto-Convection as a Source of Astrophysical Noise III. Sun-as-a-star Simulations and Optimal Noise Diagnostics

Stellar surface magnetoconvection (granulation) creates asymmetries in the observed stellar absorption lines that can subsequently manifest themselves as spurious radial velocities shifts. In turn, this can then mask the Doppler-reflex motion induced by orbiting planets on their host stars, and represents a particular challenge for determining the masses of low-mass, long-period planets. Herein, we study this impact by creating Sun-as-a-star observations that encapsulate the granulation variability expected from 3D magnetohydrodynamic simulations. These Sun-as-a-star model observations are in good agreement with empirical observations of the Sun, but may underestimate the total variability relative to the quiet Sun due to the increased magnetic field strength in our models. We find numerous line profile characteristics linearly correlate with the disc-integrated convection-induced velocities. Removing the various correlations with the line bisector, equivalent width, and the V_asy indicator may reduce ~50-60% of the granulation noise in the measured velocities. We also find that simultaneous photometry may be a key diagnostic, as our proxy for photometric brightness also allowed us to remove ~50% of the granulation-induced radial velocity noise. These correlations and granulation-noise mitigations breakdown in the presence of low instrumental resolution and/or increased stellar rotation, as both act to smooth the observed line profile asymmetries.

astro-ph.EP↗

arXiv2019

Mapping the magnetic field of flare coronal loops

Here we report on the unique observation of flaring coronal loops at the solar limb using high resolution imaging spectropolarimetry from the Swedish 1-meter Solar Telescope. The vantage position, orientation and nature of the chromospheric material that filled the flare loops allowed us to determine their magnetic field with unprecedented accuracy using the weak-field approximation method. Our analysis reveals coronal magnetic field strengths as high as 350 Gauss at heights up to 25 Mm above the solar limb. These measurements are substantially higher than a number of previous estimates and may have considerable implications for our current understanding of the extended solar atmosphere.

astro-ph.SR↗

arXiv2019

Continuum emission enhancements and penumbral changes observed during flares by IRIS, ROSA, and Hinode

In this paper we describe observations acquired by satellite instruments (Hinode/SOT and IRIS) and ground-based telescopes (ROSA@DST) during two consecutive C7.0 and X1.6 flares occurred in active region NOAA 12205 on 2014 November 7. The analysis of these data show the presence of continuum enhancements during the evolution of the events, observed both in ROSA images and in IRIS spectra. Moreover, we analyze the role played by the evolution of the $\delta$ sunspots of the active region in the flare triggering, indicating the disappearance of a large portion of penumbra around these sunspots.

astro-ph.SR↗