Search arXiv⌕ Search

arXiv · 2105.06656

Analysis of coherence in turbulent stratified wakes using spectral proper orthogonal decomposition

Abstract

We use spectral proper orthogonal decomposition (SPOD) to extract and analyze coherent structures in the turbulent wake of a disk at Reynolds number $Re = 5 \times 10^{4}$ and Froude numbers $Fr$ = $2, 10$. We find that the SPOD eigenspectra of both wakes exhibit a low-rank behavior and the relative contribution of low-rank modes to total fluctuation energy increases with $x/D$. The vortex shedding (VS) mechanism, which corresponds to $St \approx 0.11-0.13$ in both wakes, is active and dominant throughout the domain in both wakes. The continual downstream decay of the SPOD eigenspectrum peak at the VS mode, which is a prominent feature of the unstratified wake, is inhibited by buoyancy, particularly for $Fr = 2$. The energy at and near the VS frequency is found to appear in the outer region of the wake when the downstream distance exceeds $Nt = Nx/U = 6 - 8$. Visualizations show that unsteady internal gravity waves (IGWs) emerge at the same $Nt = 6 - 8$. A causal link between the VS mechanism and the unsteady IGW generation is also established using the SPOD-based reconstruction and analysis of the pressure-transport term. These IGWs are also picked up in SPOD analysis as a structural change in the shape of the leading SPOD eigenmode. The $Fr = 2$ wake shows layering in the wake core at {$Nt > 15$} which is captured by the leading SPOD eigenmodes of the VS frequency at downstream locations $x/D > 30$. The VS mode of the $Fr = 2$ wake is streamwise-coherent, consisting of V-shaped structures at $x/D \gtrsim 30$. Overall, we find that the coherence of wakes, initiated by the VS mode at the body, is prolonged by buoyancy to far downstream. Also, this coherence is spatially modified by buoyancy into horizontal layers and IGWs. Low-order truncations of SPOD modes are shown to efficiently reconstruct important second-order statistics.

Explore related subjects

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

Sheel Nidhan, Oliver T. Schmidt, Sutanu Sarkar. 2021-12-23. Analysis of coherence in turbulent stratified wakes using spectral proper orthogonal decomposition. https://doi.org/10.1017/jfm.2021.1096

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related papers

Reynolds-number regimes of corrugation-induced lift enhancement in two-dimensional dragonfly-like wings

Corrugated wing structures commonly observed in insect wings can enhance aerodynamic performance at low Reynolds numbers ($Re \simeq O(10^3)$). However, their effectiveness strongly depends on the Reynolds number, and the corresponding operating range remains unclear. Direct numerical simulations of an impulsively started corrugated wing are performed over a wide range of Reynolds numbers ($100 \leq Re \leq 4000$) to identify the conditions under which corrugation is beneficial. Three Reynolds-number regimes are identified within the examined parameter sets. No characteristic lift-enhancement mechanism is observed for $100 \leq Re < 1000$. For $1000 \leq Re \leq 4000$, lift enhancement is associated with alternating vortices formed within the V-shaped region of the corrugated wing, which generate low-pressure regions near the wing surface. Above $Re=2000$, the collapse and confinement of a secondary vortex within the V-shaped region emerge as an additional dominant mechanism, further enhancing the lift. An analysis based on a local Reynolds number organizes the onset conditions of these mechanisms and provides a useful local measure for characterizing the onset of vortex detachment from the corrugation. Furthermore, long-time simulations confirm that the observed vortex dynamics persist well beyond the initial transient response following an impulsive start. These results elucidate Reynolds-number-dependent lift-enhancement mechanisms and define aerodynamic conditions under which corrugated wings provide an advantage.

physics.flu-dyn↗

PhysMiner: An Agentic AI Framework for Automated Flow Component Analysis

Uncovering the physical mechanisms of turbulent flows remains a fundamental challenge in fluid mechanics. In particular, conventional velocity-gradient analysis methods suffer from shear contamination, which hinders accurate identification of the dominant physical mechanisms. This study presents PhysMiner, an automated framework integrating the triple decomposition method of the velocity gradient tensor with large language model-driven reasoning for turbulence-physics discovery. The triple decomposition module automatically decomposes flow fields into rigid rotation, pure shearing, and normal straining components, enabling statistical analysis, contour visualization, vortex-line extraction, and threshold-insensitive vortex identification while eliminating shear contamination. These automated capabilities are validated across five benchmarks, ranging from canonical configurations to complex engineering flows. A discover-physics agent combines flow statistics, spatial structures, and literature-derived knowledge to perform pattern recognition and physical inference, while a review Agent iteratively validates physical consistency to ensure reliable conclusions. A continuously evolving Triple Decomposition Library accumulates statistical knowledge from successfully analyzed flows, enabling cross-case comparison and progressive enhancement of inductive capability. The complete PhysMiner pipeline is validated end-to-end on the periodic hill flow, where the framework autonomously generates turbulence modeling recommendations and derives an improved subgrid-scale model with superior Reynolds-stress predictions. PhysMiner is open to the public and establishes a foundation for long-term collaborative advancement in automated turbulence-physics discovery.

physics.flu-dyn↗

Lattice Boltzmann Methods for Navier-Stokes Equations in General Orthogonal Coordinates for Efficient Flow Simulations using Nonuniform Clustered Grids

Resolving multiscale fluid flows or boundary layers effectively requires the use of nonuniform meshes with local grid clustering. The standard lattice Boltzmann method (LBM), a kinetic theory-based approach for computational fluid dynamics, however, is restricted to the use of uniform Cartesian grids. We present new and improved formulations of the LBM that accommodate continuously varying spatial grids via coordinate transformations to simulate the Navier-Stokes equations (NSE) in the general orthogonal coordinates (GOC). They are constructed using a Chapman-Enskog analysis to specify the equilibrium moments of the distribution functions and the geometric force terms used in the collision step to be dependent on the local metric factors and their spatial derivatives, along with the density, momentum and their fluxes, and some correction terms related to the normal velocity gradients so as to accurately represent the NSE in the GOC. The resulting GOC-LBM importantly maintains the simplicity of the collide-and-stream approach and is Galilean invariant that is free of the cubic velocity artifacts. Our GOC-LBM is general and modular in that it can be used with any collision model with appropriate modifications to the equilibria and forcing terms. We present its implementation details for a variety of collision models while the central moments-based model using multiple relaxation times was found to be the most robust in practical implementations. We validate the GOC-LBM through numerical simulations for various benchmark flow problems. Moreover, we demonstrate significant computational advantages of our approach for a case study on simulating boundary layer flows efficiently that involves coupling the GOC-LBM for the NSE with a new GOC-LB scheme for solving the magnetic induction equation for magnetohydrodynamics (MHD), and for another case study involving orthogonal curvilinear grids.

physics.flu-dyn↗