Search arXivSearch

arXiv · 2106.08137

Hanbury Brown and Twiss effect demonstrated for sound waves from a waterfall; an experimental, numerical and analytical study

Abstract

The Hanbury Brown and Twiss effect (HBT) is described by numerical and analytical modeling, as well as experimentally, using sound waves and easily available instrumentation. An interesting phenomenon that has often been considered too difficult to be included in standard physics studies at bachelor and master level, can now be introduced even for second year bachelor students and up. In the original Hanbury Brown and Twiss effect the angular size of the source (the star Sirius) was calculated by determining the distance between two detectors that lead to a drop in the cross-correlations in the signals from the detectors. We find that this principle works equally well by sound waves from a waterfall. This is remarkable, since we use a completely different kind of waves from the HBT case, the frequency of the waves differ by a factor $\sim 10^{12}$ and the wavelength as well as the angular extension of the source seen from the observer's position differ by a factor $\sim 10^{7}$. The original HBT papers were based on measurements of \emph{intensity} fluctuations recorded by two detectors and correlations between these signals. The starting point for the theory that explained the effect was therefore intensity fluctuations per see, and the theory is not easy to understand, at least not for an undergraduate physics student. Our starting point is descriptions of broadband waves at the amplitude level (not at intensity level) by numerical modeling. Important properties of broadband waves can easily be revealed and understood by numerical modeling, and time-resolved frequency analysis (TFA) based on Morlet wavelets turns out to be a very useful tool. In fact, we think it has been far too little attention to broadband waves in physics education hitherto, but the growth of use of numerical methods in basic physics courses opens up new possibilities.

Explore related subjects

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

Arnt Inge Vistnes, Joakim Bergli. 2021-06-04. Hanbury Brown and Twiss effect demonstrated for sound waves from a waterfall; an experimental, numerical and analytical study. https://doi.org/10.1119/10.0006613

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related papers

The Force Concept Inventory Across Continents: Testing Q-Matrix Transferability and Cross-Cultural Differences in Mechanics Reasoning

The Force Concept Inventory (FCI) is one of the most widely used research-based assessments in physics education, yet the assumption that its underlying cognitive structure is transferable across educational contexts remains largely untested. This study investigates the transferability of FCI Q-matrices using the Generalized Deterministic Inputs, Noisy "And" Gate (G-DINA) cognitive diagnostic applied to two large cohorts: students from the Learning About STEM Student Outcomes (LASSO) online system database in the United States (N = 4,750) and introductory physics students at the University of Johannesburg, South Africa (N = 1,016). Rather than treating the analysis as a local model calibration exercise, we frame the problem as one of cross-context cognitive invariance. Differential Item Functioning (DIF) analyses revealed substantial cross-cultural differences, with 14 of 30 items exhibiting high DIF after controlling for latent skill mastery. These differences were concentrated in force dynamics and contact-force reasoning and remained invariant under alternative Q-matrix specifications. The findings suggest that observed differences reflect genuine variations in students' conceptual reasoning rather than psychometric artifacts, highlighting the importance of validating Q-matrix structures before deploying cognitive diagnostic and adaptive assessments across diverse non-local educational settings.

physics.ed-ph

Inference uncertainty about an aircraft crash

Problem-based learning benefits from situations taken from real life, which usually stimulate student interest. In this paper, we examine the shooting down of the Rwandan president's aircraft on April 6th, 1994. We discuss methods to infer information about the location from which the missile was launched, its trajectory and type, where the aircraft was struck and its trajectory during the fall. To this end, we developed a physics-based analysis based on expert reports, witness statements, and other publicly available information, as interpreted by our calculations. The analysis is designed to be understandable using undergraduate-level physics. The uncertainty of each result is discussed and propagated to ensure a proper assessment of the hypotheses and a traceability of their consequences. Such approach encourages the students to exercise their critical mind and teaches inference methods that are routinely used in physics research. In addition, it illustrates the importance and limits of scientific expertise during a judiciary process.

physics.ed-ph

Skepticism vs. Convenience: Physics Students' Perceptions and Use of Large Language Models Before and After Instruction

The recent emergence of large language models (LLMs) has produced research focusing on the ability of these tools to solve physics problems, evaluate student work, or otherwise impact the problem-solving process of students. However, studies exploring how physics students perceive LLMs (in terms of capabilities, educational impacts, usage, and role in problem solving) remain limited. This study evaluates the first-year physics students' perceptions toward LLMs and further explores how these perceptions change after practicing problem-solving with and without LLMs and engaging in a reflective lesson on the functioning and educational impacts of LLMs. We find that student opinions toward LLMs vary, with generally favorable perceptions of their capabilities but greater skepticism regarding their value for learning. Despite this skepticism, a majority of students self-report regularly using LLMs to obtain help, commonly reporting deadlines and convenience as motivating factors. Following the lesson, students expressed greater skepticism toward LLMs in several areas, with 88% of students believing that LLMs can leave them with a false sense of confidence about their understanding, up from 58% before the lesson.

physics.ed-ph