Search arXiv⌕ Search
Home/Archive/arXiv

arXiv · 2503.22358

Shapley Revisited: Tractable Responsibility Measures for Query Answers

Meghyn Bienvenu·Diego Figueira·Pierre Lafourcade
View original source ↗Read source document ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

The Shapley value, originating from cooperative game theory, has been employed to define responsibility measures that quantify the contributions of database facts to obtaining a given query answer. For non-numeric queries, this is done by considering a cooperative game whose players are the facts and whose wealth function assigns 1 or 0 to each subset of the database, depending on whether the query answer holds in the given subset. While conceptually simple, this approach suffers from a notable drawback: the problem of computing such Shapley values is #P-hard in data complexity, even for simple conjunctive queries. This motivates us to revisit the question of what constitutes a reasonable responsibility measure and to introduce a new family of responsibility measures -- weighted sums of minimal supports (WSMS) -- which satisfy intuitive properties. Interestingly, while the definition of WSMSs is simple and bears no obvious resemblance to the Shapley value formula, we prove that every WSMS measure can be equivalently seen as the Shapley value of a suitably defined cooperative game. Moreover, WSMS measures enjoy tractable data complexity for a large class of queries, including all unions of conjunctive queries. We further explore the combined complexity of WSMS computation and establish (in)tractability results for various subclasses of conjunctive queries.

Explore related subjects

cs.DBcs.AI

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

Meghyn Bienvenu, Diego Figueira, Pierre Lafourcade. 2026-01-16. Shapley Revisited: Tractable Responsibility Measures for Query Answers. https://arxiv.org/abs/2503.22358

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related papers

arXiv2026

Compass: General Filtered Search across Vector and Structured Data

The increasing prevalence of hybrid vector and relational data necessitates efficient, general support for queries that combine high-dimensional vector search with complex relational filtering. However, existing filtered search solutions are fundamentally limited by specialized indices, which restrict arbitrary filtering and hinder integration with general-purpose DBMSs. This work introduces \textsc{Compass}, a unified framework that enables general filtered search across vector and structured data without relying on new index designs. Compass leverages established index structures -- such as HNSW and IVF for vector attributes, and B+-trees for relational attributes -- implementing a principled cooperative query execution strategy that coordinates candidate generation and predicate evaluation across modalities. Uniquely, Compass maintains generality by allowing arbitrary conjunctions, disjunctions, and range predicates, while ensuring robustness even with highly-selective or multi-attribute filters. Comprehensive empirical evaluations demonstrate that Compass consistently outperforms NaviX, the only existing performant general framework, across diverse hybrid query workloads. It also matches the query throughput of specialized single-attribute indices in their favorite settings with only a single attribute involved, all while maintaining full generality and DBMS compatibility. Overall, Compass offers a practical and robust solution for achieving truly general filtered search in vector database systems.

cs.DB↗
arXiv2026

NeurIDA: Dynamic Modeling for Effective In-Database Analytics

Relational Database Management Systems (RDBMS) manage complex, interrelated data and support a broad spectrum of analytical tasks. With the growing demand for predictive analytics, the deep integration of machine learning (ML) into RDBMS has become critical. However, a fundamental challenge hinders this evolution: conventional ML models are static and task-specific, whereas RDBMS environments are dynamic and must support diverse analytical queries. Each analytical task entails constructing a bespoke pipeline from scratch, which incurs significant development overhead and hence limits wide adoption of ML in analytics. We present NeurIDA, an autonomous end-to-end system for in-database analytics that dynamically "tweaks" the best available base model to better serve a given analytical task. In particular, we propose a novel paradigm of dynamic in-database modeling to pre-train a composable base model architecture over the relational data. Upon receiving a task, NeurIDA formulates the task and data profile to dynamically select and configure relevant components from the pool of base models and shared model components for prediction. For friendly user experience, NeurIDA supports natural language queries; it interprets user intent to construct structured task profiles, and generates analytical reports with dedicated LLM agents. By design, NeurIDA enables ease-of-use and yet effective and efficient in-database AI analytics. Extensive experiment study shows that NeurIDA consistently delivers up to 12% improvement in AUC-ROC and 25% relative reduction in MAE across ten tasks on five real-world datasets. The source code is available at https://github.com/Zrealshadow/NeurIDA

cs.DB↗
arXiv2026

kgsteward: a tool for building, reproducing and maintaining distributed knowledge graphs

Collaborative research projects in life sciences increasingly need to integrate private, embargoed consortium data with public reference databases in order to reach statistically meaningful interpretations. The Resource Description Framework (RDF) is well suited to this task: it facilitates the integration of heterogeneous data sources, and allows researchers to keep data and their documentation as metadata in the same place, provided the knowledge graph itself remains private during the time course of the project. Nevertheless, the development and long-term maintenance of a scientific knowledge graph remains a challenging, labour-intensive endeavour owing to the state of constant flux of most public resources. To tackle this challenge, we present kgsteward, a Python command-line tool that builds and maintains knowledge graphs inside RDF stores from a single, version-controlled configuration file. kgsteward supports multiple triplestores, keeps the local graph up-to-date with its external sources possibly already in RDF, or transformed into it on the fly, and uses SPARQL 1.1 UPDATE commands to amend further imported RDF on the fly. It can also validate the resulting graph with SPARQL queries that double as usage examples for both human users and AI agents. kgsteward has already been used in several collaborative projects at the SIB Swiss Institute of Bioinformatics, and we demonstrate its applicability in two real-world international research projects: one that builds a library of plant extracts with chemical analyses and associated bio-activities, and a second that reconciles public reference resources for human metabolic-network reconstruction.

cs.DB↗