Search arXiv⌕ Search

arXiv · 2610.10873

When Does Inexact Matching Ensure Balance and Inference without Adjustment?

Abstract

One-to-one matching without replacement is a classical approach to constructing comparable treated and control samples in the design of observational studies. It pairs each treated unit with a distinct control while minimizing a covariate distance objective. With continuous covariates, the matched pairs generally remain inexact, which contributes to bias in downstream analysis. Its key theoretical properties, such as the resulting imbalance between matched pairs and when it is negligible to support valid inference, remain unclear. In this paper, we analyze one-to-one matching based on $d$-dimensional, continuous covariates with a quadratic covariate-distance objective. First, we find that when $d\leq 3$, under standard conditions on the propensity score ensuring abundant control samples near each treated sample, the imbalance (difference between within-group averages) is root-$n$ negligible uniformly over the family of smooth functions with a common first- and second-order derivative bound. However, such balance is subject to a dimension restriction, as we construct examples in which the imbalance is root-$n$ non-negligible when $d=4$ and dominates root-$n$ rate when $d>4$. Second, we show that when $d\leq 3$, the matched design allows valid Wald-type and bootstrap inference for the average treatment effect on the treated, distributional treatment effects, and quantile treatment effects. Thus, the same outcome-blind matched design supports various downstream inferences without having to tailor the design to the targets. Finally, paired randomization inference based on the matched design is asymptotically valid in the super-population sense for $d\leq 3$ but can fail when $d=4$. We corroborate the theoretical results with numerical experiments.

Explore related subjects

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

Ying Jin. 2026-10-07. When Does Inexact Matching Ensure Balance and Inference without Adjustment?. https://arxiv.org/abs/2610.10873

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related papers

Functional Extreme-PLS

An extreme dimension reduction method is proposed, extending the Extreme-PLS approach to the discretized functional framework, where the covariate lies in the infinite-dimensional Hilbert space ($L^2([0,1])$) but is partially observed on a dense time grid. The ideas are partly borrowed from both Partial Least-Squares (PLS) and Sliced Inverse Regression (SIR) techniques. Accordingly, the method relies on the projection of the covariate onto a subspace and maximizes the covariance between its projection and the response conditionally on an extreme event capturing tail information. The covariate and the heavy-tailed response are supposed to be linked through a nonlinear inverse single-index model, and the objective is to infer the index in this regression framework. A new family of estimators is proposed, and its asymptotic consistency with convergence rates under the model is established. Assuming mild conditions on the noise, most of the assumptions are stated in terms of regular variation, unlike those commonly imposed for SIR and single-index regression. In addition, the theoretical analysis is expanded to include a model-free consistency result in probability for the empirical tail-moments in a general separable Hilbert space. Finally, the results are illustrated through a finite-sample study with synthetic functional data and high-frequency financial data, highlighting the effectiveness of the dimension reduction in capturing tail dependence and supporting extreme risk management.

math.ST↗

Phase transition for conditional covariance matrices estimated by importance sampling, and implications for cross-entropy schemes in high dimension

Motivated by recent high-dimensional reliability algorithms, we study a random matrix model corresponding to the estimation by importance sampling of $Σ_A$, the covariance matrix of a Gaussian vector conditioned by a rare event $A$. For such models, we show that, in contrast to most random matrix models, the minimal sample size to ensure an accurate estimation of $Σ_A$ needs to grow superlinearly in the dimension. More precisely, if $n$ is the sample size and $d$ the dimension, we show that the estimation of $Σ_A$ is accurate if $n/d \gg L$ and not accurate if $n/d \ll L$ where $L$ is the maximum likelihood ratio. Moreover, we relate the asymptotic behavior of $L$ to $λ_1$, the smallest eigenvalue of the auxiliary covariance matrix, which suggests that $L$ (and thus the minimal sample size) will be larger for small values of $λ_1$. Numerical experiments confirm that this insight carries over to recent cross-entropy algorithms, with the best performing algorithms being also the ones with the largest smallest eigenvalue. Although backed up by our theoretical result, this result is surprising as these algorithms were not designed to act on the spectrum.

math.ST↗

A High Dimensional Wild Bootstrap Max-Test for Detecting the Presence of Significant Predictors

We construct a block bootstrap max-test for detecting the presence of significant predictors in a high dimensional setting, allowing for weakly dependent and heterogeneous (possibly non-stationary) data. The number of covariates to be screened may be large $p$ $>>$ $n$, and growing at an exponential rate, provided $\ln (p)$ $=$ $o(n^{a})$ for some $a$ $>$ $0$ that depends on memory decay and the growth of higher moments. We study the problem of correlation screening in a high dimensional marginal regression setting, assuming so-called \textit{physical dependence} in a time series setting. We entirely sidestep covariance matrix estimation and adaptive re-sampling by working with a max-statistic over the many computed parameters. Thus we do not need endogenous selection of the most relevant predictor index yielding non-uniform asymptotics, nor do we need a post-estimation Bonferroni correction. The sequence of non-standard approximating distributions arising from the maximum of an increasing number of estimators is easily approximated by a multiplier (wild) block bootstrap. The max-test controls for size well, performs well against various deviations from the null, including very slight deviations with a weak or sparse signal. A numerical experiment is performed and an empirical example with the VIX volatility index is provided.

math.ST↗